Subjective Impressions Do Not Mirror Online Reading Effort: Concurrent EEG-Eyetracking Evidence from the Reading of Books and Digital Media

Kretzschmar, Franziska; Pleimling, Dominique; Hosemann, Jana; Füssel, Stephan; Bornkessel-Schlesewsky, Ina; Schlesewsky, Matthias
February 2013
PLoS ONE;Feb2013, Vol. 8 Issue 2, p1
Academic Journal
In the rapidly changing circumstances of our increasingly digital world, reading is also becoming an increasingly digital experience: electronic books (e-books) are now outselling print books in the United States and the United Kingdom. Nevertheless, many readers still view e-books as less readable than print books. The present study thus used combined EEG and eyetracking measures in order to test whether reading from digital media requires higher cognitive effort than reading conventional books. Young and elderly adults read short texts on three different reading devices: a paper page, an e-reader and a tablet computer and answered comprehension questions about them while their eye movements and EEG were recorded. The results of a debriefing questionnaire replicated previous findings in that participants overwhelmingly chose the paper page over the two electronic devices as their preferred reading medium. Online measures, by contrast, showed shorter mean fixation durations and lower EEG theta band voltage density – known to covary with memory encoding and retrieval – for the older adults when reading from a tablet computer in comparison to the other two devices. Young adults showed comparable fixation durations and theta activity for all three devices. Comprehension accuracy did not differ across the three media for either group. We argue that these results can be explained in terms of the better text discriminability (higher contrast) produced by the backlit display of the tablet computer. Contrast sensitivity decreases with age and degraded contrast conditions lead to longer reading times, thus supporting the conclusion that older readers may benefit particularly from the enhanced contrast of the tablet. Our findings thus indicate that people's subjective evaluation of digital reading media must be dissociated from the cognitive and neural effort expended in online information processing while reading from such devices.


Related Articles

  • Consolidation Differentially Modulates Schema Effects on Memory for Items and Associations. van Kesteren, Marlieke T. R.; Rijpkema, Mark; Ruiter, Dirk J.; Fernández, Guillén // PLoS ONE;Feb2013, Vol. 8 Issue 2, p1 

    Newly learned information that is congruent with a preexisting schema is often better remembered than information that is incongruent. This schema effect on memory has previously been associated to more efficient encoding and consolidation mechanisms. However, this effect is not always...

  • Evaluation of a Short-Form of the Berg Card Sorting Test Fox, Christopher J.; Mueller, Shane T.; Gray, Hilary M.; Raber, Jacob; Piper, Brian J. // PLoS ONE;May2013, Vol. 8 Issue 5, p1 

    The Psychology Experimental Building Language http://pebl.sourceforge.net/ Berg Card Sorting Test is an open-source neurobehavioral test. Participants (N = 207, ages 6 to 74) completed the Berg Card Sorting Test. Performance on the first 64 trials were isolated and compared to that...

  • Visual Working Memory Contents Bias Ambiguous Structure from Motion Perception. Scocchia, Lisa; Valsecchi, Matteo; Gegenfurtner, Karl R.; Triesch, Jochen // PLoS ONE;Mar2013, Vol. 8 Issue 3, p1 

    The way we perceive the visual world depends crucially on the state of the observer. In the present study we show that what we are holding in working memory (WM) can bias the way we perceive ambiguous structure from motion stimuli. Holding in memory the percept of an unambiguously rotating...

  • Resting-State Neuronal Oscillatory Correlates of Working Memory Performance. Heister, David; Diwakar, Mithun; Nichols, Sharon; Robb, Ashley; Angeles, Anne Marie; Tal, Omer; Harrington, Deborah L.; Song, Tao; Lee, Roland R.; Huang, Mingxiong // PLoS ONE;Jun2013, Vol. 8 Issue 6, p1 

    Purpose: Working memory (WM) represents the brain’s ability to maintain information in a readily available state for short periods of time. This study examines the resting-state cortical activity patterns that are most associated with performance on a difficult working-memory task....

  • Two Distinct Dynamic Modes Subtend the Detection of Unexpected Sounds. King, Jean-Rémi; Gramfort, Alexandre; Schurger, Aaron; Naccache, Lionel; Dehaene, Stanislas // PLoS ONE;Jan2014, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p1 

    The brain response to auditory novelty comprises two main EEG components: an early mismatch negativity and a late P300. Whereas the former has been proposed to reflect a prediction error, the latter is often associated with working memory updating. Interestingly, these two proposals predict...

  • Visuospatial Working Memory in Toddlers with a History of Periventricular Leukomalacia: An EEG Narrow-Band Power Analysis. García-Gomar, María Luisa; Santiago-Rodríguez, Efraín; Rodríguez-Camacho, Mario; Harmony, Thalía // PLoS ONE;Jul2013, Vol. 8 Issue 7, p1 

    Background: Periventricular Leukomalacia (PVL) affects white matter, but grey matter injuries have also been reported, particularly in the dorsomedial nucleus and the cortex. Both structures have been related to working memory (WM) processes. The aim of this study was to compare behavioral...

  • Visual Working Memory Capacity for Color Is Independent of Representation Resolution. Ye, Chaoxiong; Zhang, Lingcong; Liu, Taosheng; Li, Hong; Liu, Qiang // PLoS ONE;Mar2014, Vol. 9 Issue 3, p1 

    Background: The relationship between visual working memory (VWM) capacity and resolution of representation have been extensively investigated. Several recent ERP studies using orientation (or arrow) stimuli suggest that there is an inverse relationship between VWM capacity and representation...

  • Working Memory and Its Relation to Deterministic Sequence Learning. Martini, Markus; Furtner, Marco R.; Sachse, Pierre // PLoS ONE;Feb2013, Vol. 8 Issue 2, p1 

    Is there a relation between working memory (WM) and incidental sequence learning? Nearly all of the earlier investigations in the role of WM capacity (WMC) in sequence learning suggest no correlations in incidental learning conditions. However, the theoretical view of WM and operationalization...

  • Increased Attentional Focus Modulates Eye Movements in a Mixed Antisaccade Task for Younger and Older Adults. Wang, Jingxin; Tian, Jing; Wang, Rong; Benson, Valerie // PLoS ONE;Apr2013, Vol. 8 Issue 4, p1 

    We examined performance in the antisaccade task for younger and older adults by comparing latencies and errors in what we defined as high attentional focus (mixed antisaccades and prosaccades in the same block) and low attentional focus (antisaccades and prosaccades in separate blocks)...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics