Regulating audit quality: Restoring trust and legitimacy

Holm, Claus; Zaman, Mahbub
March 2012
Accounting Forum;Mar2012, Vol. 36 Issue 1, p51
Academic Journal
Abstract: The global financial crisis, corporate failures and scandals in many countries raise significant questions audit quality. In the UK, the FRC took the unprecedented step of codifying audit quality in its ‘Audit Quality Framework’. We analyze the extent to which audit firms, professional bodies, and investors considered the FRC proposals sufficient for addressing concerns about audit quality. Using impression management and legitimacy as a framework to analyze stakeholder responses we go beyond audit quality drivers identified by the FRC. In contrast to the drivers identified by the FRC, our focus on transparency, expertise, professionalism and commercialization of the audit shows that FRC, audit firms and professional bodies have mainly focused on issues which possibly do not pose a threat to the commercial interest of audit firms. Overall, our analysis shows that regulatory and professional bodies engaged in image management and the promotion of audit quality in an attempt to remedy tarnished image and augment their legitimacy and standing. In attempting to restore trust and legitimacy regulatory bodies, such as the FRC, have to reconcile complex often contradictory stakeholder demands.


Related Articles

  • Evaluating the Performance and Accountability of Regulators. Scott, Colin // Seattle University Law Review;Winter2014, Vol. 37 Issue 2, p353 

    The article focuses on the accountability processes that encompass both democratic and technical dimensions of regulation. Topics discussed include global financial crisis of 2008, fragmented regulation or the tradition of independent federal regulatory agencies in the U.S and solutions to the...

  • REGULATORY TRUST. Bratspies, Rebecca M. // Arizona Law Review;Fall2009, Vol. 51 Issue 3, p575 

    When regulators make decisions in the face of uncertainty, what gives legitimacy to their decisions? This question arises more and more frequently as globalized markets and new technologies crash through pre-existing social and political fault lines. In the myriad contexts of regulation, the...

  • AUDIT REPORTING AND CORPORATE GOVERNANCE: LINKS AND IMPLICATIONS. CORDOŞ, George-Silviu; FÜLÖP, Melinda Timea // SEA: Practical Application of Science;2014, Vol. 2 Issue 1, p146 

    Financial scandals of the last decade have had a negative effect upon the trust and perception of investors regarding auditor responsibility and their part in fraud and error detection. As a result of legal conditions and regulations, audit firms in some jurisdictions have recently started to...

  • Audit regulation - one year on. Fearnley, Stella; Page, Michael // Accountancy;Jan1993, Vol. 111 Issue 1193, p59 

    Focuses on the response to Great Britain's audit regulation after a year of implementation. Improvement of the quality of auditing; Changes in procedures for recording audit work; Audit for small companies.

  • Denetçi Bağımsızlığının Etik Ä°lkeler Çerçevesinde Ä°ncelenmesi: Bir Denetim Firması Uygulaması. DEMİR, Esra; ÇİFTCİ, Yavuz // Karamanoglu Mehmetbey University Journal of Social & Economic Re;Dec2016, Vol. 18 Issue 31, p88 

    With the developments in economy, the interest in financial statements crossed national borders and stepped into international arena. The need in reliable information regarding financial status of businesses has leveraged as a result of effects of globalization, in particular, the need in...

  • Auditing in the 21st Century: Has Self-regulation Failed? Islam, Mahbubul // Journal of Modern Accounting & Auditing;Aug2013, Vol. 9 Issue 8, p1059 

    From the very beginning, auditing is pretty much a self-regulated profession and has some ethical rules of thumb to follow in practice. But the plethora of recent corporate failures and scandals where auditors' instrumental role is evident in many instances raise question about the validity and...

  • AUDIT BLACKSPOTS. WOOLF, EMILE // Accountancy;Jul2011, Vol. 148 Issue 1415, p16 

    The author argues that the trend for checklist auditing has been degrading the quality of audit methodology in Great Britain. He discusses how the procedures that require direct contact with client records have shifted in favour of compliance with auditing rules and regulations. He also comments...

  • Restoring the Public Trust. Seidman, Leslie F. // CPA Journal;Dec2014, Vol. 84 Issue 12, p80 

    The author reflects on the restoration of public trust to the accounting profession. Topics covered include the belief that majority of people are trying to do the right thing, the concern raised by investors on the way accounts have been prepared and audited by professionals and the loss of...

  • Auditing Trust and Governance: Developing Regulation in Europe. CARMICHAEL, DOUGLAS R. // Accounting Review;Nov2008, Vol. 83 Issue 6, p1677 

    the article reviews the book "Auditing Trust and Governance: Developing Regulation in Europe," edited by Reiner Quick, Stuart Turley, and Marleen Willekens.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics