Decision Accuracy and the Role of Spatial Interaction in Opinion Dynamics

Torney, Colin; Levin, Simon; Couzin, Iain
April 2013
Journal of Statistical Physics;Apr2013, Vol. 151 Issue 1/2, p203
Academic Journal
The opinions and actions of individuals within interacting groups are frequently determined by both social and personal information. When sociality (or the pressure to conform) is strong and individual preferences are weak, groups will remain cohesive until a consensus decision is reached. When group decisions are subject to a bias, representing for example private information known by some members of the population or imperfect information known by all, then the accuracy achieved for a fixed level of bias will increase with population size. In this work we determine how the scaling between accuracy and group size can be related to the microscopic properties of the decision-making process. By simulating a spatial model of opinion dynamics we show that the relationship between the instantaneous fraction of leaders in the population ( L), system size ( N), and accuracy depends on the frequency of individual opinion switches and the level of population viscosity. When social mixing is slow, and individual opinion changes are frequent, accuracy is determined by the absolute number of informed individuals. As mixing rates increase, or the rate of opinion updates decrease, a transition occurs to a regime where accuracy is determined by the value of $L\sqrt{ N}$. We investigate the transition between different scaling regimes analytically by examining a well-mixed limit.


Related Articles

  • Smarter than you think. Keogh, Bill // Apply;Feb2005, Vol. 5 Issue 2, p12 

    Provides information on the wisdom of the crowds and its implementation on decision making. Accuracy of group decision making; Characteristics of wise crowds; Benefits of collaboration; Suggestions with regard to utilizing the collective insights of customers in decision making.

  • OPINION QUALITY IN PUBLIC OPINION RESEARCH. Price, Vincent; Neijens, Peter // International Journal of Public Opinion Research;Winter97, Vol. 9 Issue 4, p336 

    The article discusses opinion quality in public opinion polls. The concept of public opinion is part of democratic theory, created in response to problems of collective judgment and decision making. Judging the quality of public opinion, then, is inextricably bound to judging the quality of...

  • APUNTES TEÓRICOS SOBRE LA RELACIÓN ENTRE CONOCIMIENTO COLECTIVO E INSTITUCIONES. Morales Sánchez, Mario Alberto // Revista de Economía Institucional;Segundo Semestre 2014, Vol. 16 Issue 31, p61 

    No abstract available.

  • The New Self-Help Backlash. Riessman, Frank // Social Policy;Summer90, Vol. 21 Issue 1, p42 

    This article relates the issues and criticisms faced by self-help groups in the U.S. Self-help groups have had a significant empowering effect on people at the personal level: participants are able to overcome problems (addictions) they have not been able to overcome alone. And note that...

  • TAKING ADVANTAGE OF DIFFERENCE IN OPINION. Bradley, Richard // Episteme (Edinburgh University Press);2006 Special Issue, Vol. 3 Issue 3, p141 

    Diversity of opinion both presents problems and affords opportunities. Differences of opinion can stand in the way of reaching an agreement within a group on what decisions to take. But at the same time, the fact that the differences in question could derive from access to different information...

  • Selecting the Best Bank That Offered Islamic Personal Loan Package by Using Consistent Fuzzy Preference Relations (CFPR). Kadir, Norhidayah A.; Sarudin, Ezzah Suraya; Hamid, Fairus; Ahmad Shamsuddin, Nor Diyana // AIP Conference Proceedings;2014, Vol. 1621, p498 

    There are various thoughts and opinions when it comes to how people think of their selected banks. Therefore, to choose the best bank with a good personal loan package can be a bit tricky especially for first time customer. This research offers a guide in choosing the right bank for applying...

  • Can the public be trusted to choose the best architecture.  // Building Design;10/31/2008, Issue 1842, p9 

    The author reflects on the capability of the public to select the best architecture. He argues that the basis for a best architecture is when the building is successful in changing for the better lives of the people who use them. The author suggests that only the expert jury can make the final...

  • WHAT POLLS CAN AND CANNOT TELL US ABOUT PUBLIC OPINION: KEYNOTE SPEECH AT THE 60TH ANNUAL CONFERENCE OF WAPOR. Lang, Kurt // International Journal of Public Opinion Research;Spring2008, Vol. 20 Issue 1, p3 

    The article examines the nature and function of public opinion. It explores the notion of popular sovereignty affirmed on the idea that a genuine democracy is ruled by the people. The author discusses the three conceptually distinct types of collective behavior, which are the mass behavior,...

  • The German 'Wutbürger': How Justice Sensitivity Accounts for Individual Differences in Political Engagement. Rothmund, Tobias; Baumert, Anna; Zinkernagel, Axel // Social Justice Research;Mar2014, Vol. 27 Issue 1, p24 

    Perceived injustice can trigger strong emotional reactions and motivate political protest. Although there is vast empirical evidence for this chain of reactions, we know little about individual differences in how perceived injustice can motivate people to engage in political actions. In a survey...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics