Validation of key indicators in cattle farms at high risk of animal welfare problems: a qualitative case-control study

Kelly, P. C.; More, S. J.; Blake, M.; Higgins, I.; Clegg, T.; Hanlon, A.
March 2013
Veterinary Record: Journal of the British Veterinary Association;3/23/2013, Vol. 172 Issue 12, p1
Academic Journal
The objective of this study was to validate four key farmer performance indicators (KFPI), identified in a previous study, as indicators of on-farm cattle welfare incidents in Ireland, through comparison of the distribution of these KPFIs in the national herd (n=109,925) and in case herds (n=18), where welfare incidents were previously studied. The KFPIs identified were late registrations, and exits from the herd by on-farm burial, by moves to knackeries and by moves to 'herd unknown'. Data were extracted from two Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine databases for the national herd and the case herds. All four KFPIs differed significantly between the case herds and the national herd, and one further KFPI was identified, namely moves to factories. The data for these KFPIs are routinely stored on national databases, which were established in order to comply with Regulation (EC) 1760/2000. Based on the results obtained in this study, it may be possible in the future to use routine data capture to improve strategy towards on-farm animal welfare. At this point, however, based on calculated specificities and sensitivities, none of these five KFPIs, at the cut-offs investigated and using several combinations, are able to distinguish herds with and without on-farm animal welfare problems at an accuracy suitable for routine national use in Ireland.


Related Articles

  • Comparative evaluation of condylar position in symptomatic (TMJ dysfunction) and asymptomatic individuals. Padala, Soumya; Padmanabhan, Sridevi; Chithranjan, Arun B. // Indian Journal of Dental Research;Jan/Feb2012, Vol. 23 Issue 1, following p119 

    Context: The etiopathogenesis of temporomandibular joint (TMJ) disorders has been attributed to multiple factors and, while the importance of centric relation (CR) has been acknowledged in dental literature, the role of condylar position and CR-CO (CO-centric occlusion) discrepancy in TMJ...

  • DETERMINATION OF ENERGY-POWER PARAMETERS OF CO- EXTRUSION PROCESS OF TUBULAR SHAPES FROM RUBBER MIXTURES. GUDANOV, I. S.; YURIGIN, P. P.; GONCHAROV, G. M.; LOMOV, A. A. // Izvestiya Vysshikh Uchebnykh Zavedenii. Seriya Khimiya i Khimich;2012, Vol. 55 Issue 5, p116 

    The comparative analysis of the energy-power characteristics of the worm machines aggregated with forming heads of different geometry of boundaries of profiling channel was carried out.

  • Using Restriction to Minimize Bias in Observational Studies. Turakhia, Mintu P.; Heidenreich, Paul A.; Psaty, Bruce M.; Siscovick, David S. // JAMA: Journal of the American Medical Association;12/1/2010, Vol. 304 Issue 21, p2359 

    A letter to the editor is presented in response to the article "Minimizing bias due to confounding by indication in comparative effectiveness research: The importance of restriction," by B. M. Psaty and colleagues published in a 2010 issue, and a response from the authors of the article.

  • A Comparative Study of "Learning by Doing" and "Integrative Teaching, Doing and Learning". Ma Young-jun // Qingdao Daxue Shifanxueyuan Xuebao/Journal of Teachers College Q;2009, Vol. 26 Issue 1, p22 

    Learning by doing", a science education reform, has become a focus of attention in China. In order to better understand the science education reform of "learning by doing", the writer of this paper thinks that it has become a necessity to compare John Dewey' s "learning by doing" with Tao Xing -...

  • Perineal Distensibility Using Epi-no in Twin Pregnancies: Comparative Study with Singleton Pregnancies. Kubotani, Juliana Sayuri; Moron, Antonio Fernandes; Júnior, Edward Araujo; Diniz Zanetti, Miriam Raquel; Marques Soares, Vanessa Cardoso; Júnior, Julio Elito // ISRN Obstetrics & Gynecology;2014, p1 

    The aims of this study were to compare perineal distensibility between women with twin and singleton pregnancies and to correlate these women's perineal distensibility with anthropometric data. This prospective cross-sectional case-control study was conducted among nulliparous women, of whom 20...

  • A Comparative Study on Need-Based Aid Policy in Higher Education between U.S. State of Indiana and Taiwan. Ching-Hui Lin; Hossler, Donald // Journal of Student Financial Aid;11/7/2014, Vol. 44 Issue 2, p149 

    The question of how the government can best support access to postsecondary education has become a critical issue for education policymakers around the globe, as the practice of cost sharing for funding postsecondary education has been more widely adopted. In this context, this study explores...

  • A COMPARATIVE STUDY TO ASSESS THE IMPACT OF 6 DAYS CORE COMPETENCY TRAINING OF THE ANMs OF DAMOH DISTRICT OF MADHYA PRADESH. Prasad, Pankaj; Arya, Rajendra Singh; Bansal, Manoj; Singh, S. P. // National Journal of Community Medicine;Jan-Mar2012, Vol. 3 Issue 1, p121 

    Background: In India, public health nursing in the villages today is still limited to services rendered by Auxiliary Nurse Midwife (ANM). ANMs are regarded as the first contact person between people and organization, between needs and services and between consumer and provider. Recognizing this...

  • Importance of Relationship Context in HIV Transmission: Results From a Qualitative Case-Control Study in Rakai, Uganda. Higgins, Jenny A.; Mathur, Sanyukta; Eckel, Elizabeth; Kelly, Laura; Nakyanjo, Neema; Sekamwa, Richard; Namatovu, Josephine; Ddaaki, William; Nakubulwa, Rosette; Namakula, Sylvia; Nalugoda, Fred; Santelli, John S. // American Journal of Public Health;Apr2014, Vol. 104 Issue 4, p612 

    We present results from life history interviews with 60 young adults from southern Uganda.Using a novel qualitative case-control design, we compared newly HIV-positive cases with HIV-negative controls matched on age, gender, marital status, and place of residence. Relationship context was the...

  • Acute cholecystitis: quantitative and qualitative evaluation with 64-section helical CT. Soyer, Philippe; Hoeffel, Christine; Dohan, Anthony; Gayat, Etienne; Eveno, Clarisse; Malgras, Brice; Pautrat, Karine; Boudiaf, Mourad // Acta Radiologica;Jun2013, Vol. 54 Issue 5, p477 

    Background: Because of an expanded role for CT in the evaluation of patients with acute abdominal pain, it is not rare that acute cholecystitis is depicted by CT. However, the sensitivity and the specificity of a given CT variable for the diagnosis of acute cholecystitis is not known. Purpose:...


Read the Article


Sign out of this library

Other Topics