Assessing the impacts of sustainable development projects in the Amazon: the DURAMAZ experiment

Le Tourneau, François-Michel; Marchand, Guillaume; Greissing, Anna; Nasuti, Stéphanie; Droulers, Martine; Bursztyn, Marcel; Léna, Philippe; Dubreuil, Vincent
April 2013
Sustainability Science;Apr2013, Vol. 8 Issue 2, p199
Academic Journal
Since 1992, a boom of 'sustainable development projects' has been registered in the Brazilian Amazon, turning it into a kind of open-air laboratory for sustainability. But their real impacts remain unclear, especially because of inadequate evaluation tools. A new device is therefore needed to unveil the inner mechanisms of development aid despite the difficulties linked with the diversity of contexts or the heterogeneity in the relevant parameters. Those are the challenges we met when we engaged in comparing the impacts of sustainable development programs in 13 sites throughout the Brazilian Amazon in order to identify determining factors of sustainability. To achieve our objective, we conceived an indicator system based on the results of intensive fieldwork, including social, economic, environmental, and biographical issues. Our results show that the most prominent problem of sustainability-evaluation of effectiveness-has not been tackled; life conditions and environmental preservation continue to appear antagonistic. At the same time, variability appears among outwardly coherent social groups, showing that a case-to-case approach is definitely indispensable and confirming the need to go 'beyond panaceas' to find resolutions. This article successively addresses three points. First, we present the starting point of our research, or how the Amazon region was turned into a laboratory for sustainability and how our research project aimed at analyzing the consequences of this trend. Second, we discuss how available indicator systems fail to respond to the need for a multidimensional evaluation at the local level and, therefore, how we constituted our own analytical tool. Third, we focus on some results that can be derived from our system, especially in terms of identifying key factors needed to achieve sustainability in the Amazon.


Related Articles

  • Comparative study of vent and seep macrofaunal communities in the Guaymas Basin. Portail, M.; Olu, K.; Escobar-Briones, E.; Caprais, J. C.; Menot, L.; Waeles, M.; Cruaud, P.; Sarradin, P. M.; Godfroy, A.; Sarrazin, J. // Biogeosciences;2015, Vol. 12 Issue 18, p5455 

    Understanding the ecological processes and connectivity of chemosynthetic deep-sea ecosystems requires comparative studies. In the Guaymas Basin (Gulf of California, Mexico), the presence of seeps and vents in the absence of a biogeographic barrier, and comparable sedimentary settings and depths...

  • REFLEXÃO AMBIENTAL DO MUNICÍPIO DE PAROBÉ SOB A VISÃO DE MORADORES E DE ALUNOS DA E. E. DE ENSINO MÉDIO ENGENHEIRO PAROBÉ. Krummenauer, Luciane; Correa Peres, Paulo Edelvar // Revista Monografias Ambientais;2012, Vol. 6 Issue 6, p1423 

    With the grand population growth of the latest decades, it also appeared the growth of the environmental impacts caused by this demand. The environmental Science has the role of developing an ecological conscience in the individuals, through the environmental sensibility related to specific...

  • THE EXPERIENCE OF QUANTITATIVE EVALUATION OF BIOCLIMATIC CONDITIONS FOR THE REGIONAL STRATEGY OBJECTIVES (on the Example of the Russian Far East). Nikolaevich, Demyanenko Alexander; Alexandrovich, Demyanenko Nikolay // Spatial Economics;2012, Vol. 4 Issue 32, p138 

    The authors consider an assessment of bioclimatic conditions, which serve as a measure of the environment's aggressiveness, as one of the stages of the regional economic strategy development. The calculation of the wet cooling wind index according to Hill (which was carried out on the data of...

  • Addressing heterogeneities in climate change studies for water resources in Korea. Young-Oh Kim; Jae-Kyoung Lee // Current Science (00113891);4/25/2010, Vol. 98 Issue 8, p1077 

    Without exception, global warming affects the water resources in Korea. Several climate change projects have been initiated for future water resources assessment but have produced very different projections with a significant range of heterogeneities. Therefore, it is necessary to develop a...

  • Organic land hogs. Page, Andrew // New Scientist;10/30/2004, Vol. 184 Issue 2471, p30 

    The article presents information on research that shows that organically farmed land supports wildlife better than intensively farmed land, but this is not the same as demonstrating that a move to organic farming would be good for biodiversity. The point of farming is to produce food, not to...

  • Land use change in Asia and the ecological consequences. Shuqing Zhao; Changhui Peng; Hong Jiang; Dalun Tian; Xiangdong Lei; Xiaolu Zhou // Ecological Research;Nov2006, Vol. 21 Issue 6, p890 

    Viewed within a historical context, Asia has experienced dramatic land transformations, and currently more than 50% of Asian land area is under agriculture. The consequences of this transformation are manifold. Southeast Asia has the highest deforestation rate of any major tropical region. Many...

  • Scale effects and human impact on the elevational species richness gradients. Nogués-Bravo, D.; Araújo, M. B.; Romdal, T.; Rahbek, C. // Nature;5/8/2008, Vol. 453 Issue 7192, p216 

    Despite two centuries of effort in characterizing environmental gradients of species richness in search of universal patterns, surprisingly few of these patterns have been widely acknowledged. Species richness along altitudinal gradients was previously assumed to increase universally from cool...

  • Linking an economic model for European agriculture with a mechanistic model to estimate nitrogen losses from cropland soil in Europe. Leip, A.; Marchi, G.; Koeble, R.; Kempen, M.; Britz, W.; Li, C. // Biogeosciences Discussions;2007, Vol. 4 Issue 4, p2215 

    For the comprehensive assessment of the policy impact on greenhouse gas emissions from agricultural soils both socio-economic aspects and the environmental heterogeneity of the landscape are important factors that must be considered. We developed a modelling framework that links the large-scale...

  • Heterogeneity among Orf Virus Isolates from Goats in Fujian Province, Southern China. Chi, Xuelin; Zeng, Xiancheng; Hao, Wenbo; Li, Ming; Li, Wei; Huang, Xiaohong; Wang, Shihua; Luo, Shuhong // PLoS ONE;Oct2013, Vol. 8 Issue 10, p1 

    Orf virus is a parapoxvirus that causes recurring contagious ecthyma or orf disease in goat, sheep and other wild and domestic ruminants. Infected animals show signs of pustular lesions on the mouth and muzzle and develop scabs over the lesions. Although the infection is usually cleared within...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics