'Explain' in scientific discourse

Overton, James
May 2013
Synthese;May2013, Vol. 190 Issue 8, p1383
Academic Journal
The philosophical literature on scientific explanation contains a striking diversity of accounts. I use novel empirical methods to address this fragmentation and assess the importance and generality of explanation in science. My evidence base is a set of 781 articles from one year of the journal Science, and I begin by applying text mining techniques to discover patterns in the usage of 'explain' and other words of philosophical interest. I then use random sampling from the data set to develop and test a classification scheme for scientific explanation. My results show that explanation and inference to the best explanation are ubiquitous in science, that they occur across a wide range of scientific disciplines, and that they are a goal of scientific practise. These explanations and inferences to the best explanation come in a diversity forms, which at least partially justifies the fragmentation of philosophical accounts. I draw two methodological lessons: first that text mining can enhance traditional conceptual analysis by establishing facts about word usage; and second that random sampling of cases can increase our confidence that a philosophical account applies in general. These empirical techniques supplement traditional philosophical methods.


Related Articles

  • Integrating Instance-level and Attribute-level Knowledge into Document Clustering. Jinlong Wang; Shunyao Wu; Gang Li; Zhe Wei // Computer Science & Information Systems;Jun2011, Vol. 8 Issue 3, p635 

    The article focuses on document clustering framework that would unite instance-level knowledge and attribute-level knowledge. It mentions that document clustering is an important task in text mining and analysis and in information retrieval processes. It also states that instance-level knowledge...

  • Mining metabolites: extracting the yeast metabolome from the literature. Nobata, Chikashi; Dobson, Paul; Iqbal, Syed; Mendes, Pedro; Tsujii, Jun'ichi; Kell, Douglas; Ananiadou, Sophia // Metabolomics;Mar2011, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p94 

    Text mining methods have added considerably to our capacity to extract biological knowledge from the literature. Recently the field of systems biology has begun to model and simulate metabolic networks, requiring knowledge of the set of molecules involved. While genomics and proteomics...

  • Bisimulation-based Consistency Checking on Syndrome Feng-Shi-Re-Bi in Rheumatoid Arthritis. Guang Zheng; Kai Cui; Junping Zhan; Zekun Ning; Miao Jiang; Cheng Lu; Aiping Lu // Journal of Software (1796217X);Apr2014, Vol. 9 Issue 4, p536 

    Checking the consistency of knowledge items between textbook and clinical practice is very important for traditional Chinese medicine (TCM). According to the textbook of internal medicine of TCM, rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is a disease with four main syndromes (also called pattern) and...

  • The nexus of knowledge and behavior for school-aged children: implementation of Health Education Programs and a Nutritional Symbol System. Miller, Judith; Graham, Lorraine; Pennington, Jim // Asia-Pacific Journal of Health, Sport & Physical Education;Nov2013, Vol. 4 Issue 3, p217 

    Health-related knowledge has been assumed to inform lifestyle choices for school-aged students. A 'health-promoting school' provides the conceptual framework for this intervention. A large boarding school developed, implemented and refined a Nutritional Symbol System for their dining hall. The...

  • O lugar da História no consumo do chamado patrimônio histórico. Montoya Uriarte, Urpi // Intersecoes: Revista de Estudios Interdisciplinares;jun2012, Vol. 14 Issue 1, p7 

    It is often said we must preserve historical heritage because it keeps the memory and the identity of particular people alive, and therefore becomes a way of educating new generations about a time worth remembering. The question is: what period of time? We carried on a study with groups of...

  • Inference to the Best Explanation (IBE) Versus Explaining for the Best Inference (EBI). Wilkenfeld, Daniel; Lombrozo, Tania // Science & Education;Nov2015, Vol. 24 Issue 9/10, p1059 

    In pedagogical contexts and in everyday life, we often come to believe something because it would best explain the data. What is it about the explanatory endeavor that makes it essential to everyday learning and to scientific progress? There are at least two plausible answers. On one view, there...

  • Understanding as representation manipulability. Wilkenfeld, Daniel // Synthese;Apr2013, Vol. 190 Issue 6, p997 

    Claims pertaining to understanding are made in a variety of contexts and ways. As a result, few in the philosophical literature have made an attempt to precisely characterize the state that is y understanding x. This paper builds an account that does just that. The account is motivated by two...

  • A realistic assessment of methods for extracting gene/protein interactions from free text.  // BMC Bioinformatics;2009, Vol. 10, p233 

    Background: The automated extraction of gene and/or protein interactions from the literature is one of the most important targets of biomedical text mining research. In this paper we present a realistic evaluation of gene/protein interaction mining relevant to potential non-specialist users....

  • The first step in the development of text mining technology for cancer risk assessment: identifying and organizing scientific evidence in risk assessment literature.  // BMC Bioinformatics;2009, Vol. 10, p303 

    Background: One of the most neglected areas of biomedical Text Mining (TM) is the development of systems based on carefully assessed user needs. We have recently investigated the user needs of an important task yet to be tackled by TM – Cancer Risk Assessment (CRA). Here we take the first...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics