Is providing elective ventilation in the best interests of potential donors?

McGee, Andrew John; White, Benjamin Peter
March 2013
Journal of Medical Ethics;Mar2013, Vol. 39 Issue 3, p135
Academic Journal
In this paper, we examine the lawfulness of a proposal to provide elective ventilation to incompetent patients who are potential organ donors. Under the current legal framework, this depends on whether the best interests test could be satisfied. It might be argued that, because the Mental Capacity Act 2005 (UK) (and the common law) makes it clear that the best interests test is not confined to the patient's clinical interests, but extends to include the individual's own values, wishes and beliefs, the proposal will be in the patient's best interests. We reject this claim. We argue that, as things currently stand, the proposal could not lawfully be justified as a blanket proposition by reference to the best interests test. Accordingly, a modification of the law would be necessary to render the proposal lawful. We conclude with a suggestion about how that could be achieved.


Related Articles

  • Dying to give? Talk about it.  // Nursing Standard;8/29/2007, Vol. 21 Issue 51, p26 

    The article presents the readers' response on whether everyone should be regarded as a potential organ donor when they die. One reader states that having an opt-out system would reduce some of the stress of decision for bereaved relatives. Another reader stresses the choice of persons to give...

  • Donation after Uncontrolled Cardiac Death (uDCD): A Review of the Debate from a European Perspective. Borry, Pascal; Van Reusel, Walter; Roels, Leo; Schotsmans, Paul // Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics;Winter2008, Vol. 36 Issue 4, p752 

    Presumed consent alone will not solve the organ shortage, but it will create an ethical and legal context that supports organ donation, respects individuals who object to organ donation, relieves families from the burden of decision making, and can save lives.

  • Legal Authority to Preserve Organs in Cases of Uncontrolled Cardiac Death: Preserving Family Choice. Bonnie, Richard J.; Wright, Stephanie; Dineen, Kelly K. // Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics;Winter2008, Vol. 36 Issue 4, p741 

    The gap between the number of organs available for transplant and the number of individuals who need transplanted organs continues to increase. At the same time, thousands of transplantable organs are needlessly overlooked every year for the single reason that they come from individuals who were...

  • Tissue donation.  // Nursing Standard;9/19/2007, Vol. 22 Issue 2, p59 

    The article talks about staff nurse and theater practitioner Suzanne Ward's working knowledge of tissue donation. The benefits of tissue transplantation not only for the recipients but also for the bereaved relatives, who may take some comfort in knowing their loved one has been able to help...

  • The Washington, D.C. Experience with Uncontrolled Donation after Circulatory Determination of Death: Promises and Pitfalls. Light, Jimmy A. // Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics;Winter2008, Vol. 36 Issue 4, p735 

    The author recounts his experience with an uDCD program that ran for three years at the Washington Hospital I Center in Washington, D.C. in the 1990s. Challenges, I benefits, and lessons learned are considered in depth. A I primary focus is the importance of community education, Organ...

  • Non-heart organ donation: old procurement strategy. Bell, M.D.D. // Journal of Medical Ethics;Jun2003, Vol. 29 Issue 3, p176 

    The imbalance between supply of organs for transplantation and demand for them is widening. Although the current international drive to re-establish procurement via non-heart beating organ donation/donor (NHBOD) is founded therefore on necessity, the process may constitute a desirable outcome...

  • NATCO, The Organization for Transplant Professionals Position Statement.  // Progress in Transplantation;Jun2006, Vol. 16 Issue 2, p106 

    Presents a position statement issued by NATCO, the Organization for Transplant Professionals, concerning organ donation following cardiac death. Support of the organization on patient and family autonomy; Ethical aspects of organ or tissue donation; Policy implemented by the organization in...

  • The Problems of Organ Donor Shortage. Galandiuk, Susan; Sterioff, Sylvester // Mayo Clinic Proceedings;Mar2005, Vol. 80 Issue 3, p320 

    Describes the improvisational approach of combining different transplantation technologies to help bridge the gap formed by the ongoing shortage of donor organs for transplantation into humans. Failure of the current system for procuring and distributing organs to patients in need; Pronouncement...

  • Investors Take Heart. Taylor, Marisa // Red Herring;4/30/2007, Vol. 4 Issue 16, p16 

    The article reports that TransMedics, based in Andover, Massachusetts, has created the Organ Care System, a device that powers the pulse of a recently donated heart while it is transported from donor to recipient. The device would substitute for current organ transplant protocols, which place...

  • NB launches ambitious Organ Donation Network. Moulton, Donalee // CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal;7/11/2000, Vol. 163 Issue 1, p75 

    Reports that the New Brunswick Organ Donation Network has challenged itself to increase the province's donor rate with the goal of becoming Atlantic Canada's leader in organ and tissue donation. Details of waiting lists for a transplant; Need to find ways to gain public support.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics