The distinctive feeling theory of pleasure

Bramble, Ben
January 2013
Philosophical Studies;Jan2013, Vol. 162 Issue 2, p201
Academic Journal
In this article, I attempt to resuscitate the perennially unfashionable distinctive feeling theory of pleasure (and pain), according to which for an experience to be pleasant (or unpleasant) is just for it to involve or contain a distinctive kind of feeling. I do this in two ways. First, by offering powerful new arguments against its two chief rivals: attitude theories, on the one hand, and the phenomenological theories of Roger Crisp, Shelly Kagan, and Aaron Smuts, on the other. Second, by showing how it can answer two important objections that have been made to it. First, the famous worry that there is no felt similarity to all pleasant (or unpleasant) experiences (sometimes called 'the heterogeneity objection'). Second, what I call 'Findlay's objection', the claim that it cannot explain the nature of our attraction to pleasure and aversion to pain.


Related Articles

  • I WANTED BLACK SKATES: GENDER, CASH, PLEASURE, AND THE POLITICS OF CRITICISM. Rand, Erica // Criticism;Fall2008, Vol. 50 Issue 4, p555 

    The article focuses on the issues concerning the concept of criticisms based on the book "Her Tongue on My Theory: Images, Essays, Fantasies." It concerns pleasure, politics and gender in a particular format and gender of the book. According to the author, one of her arguments in the article...

  • Avoiding Motivation Killers. Smith, Leif // Broker Magazine;Dec2004/Jan2005, Vol. 6 Issue 6, p14 

    The article discusses the importance of personal motivation. The impetus for personal motivation, said Leif Smith, a business and sports consultant, is often discussed, but rarely agreed upon. What is seldom discussed with regards to motivation is those obstacles that get in the way of feeling...

  • Descartes and the Primacy of Practice: The Role of the Passions in the Search for Truth. Schmitter, Amy M. // Philosophical Studies;Mar2002, Vol. 108 Issue 1/2, p99 

    This paper argues that Descartes conceives of theoretical reason in terms derived from practical reason, particularly in the role he gives to the passions. That the passions serve – under ``normal'' circumstances – to preserve the union of mind and body is a well-known feature of...

  • Finding Flow. Jackson, Bruce H. // Personal Excellence Essentials;Sep2004, Vol. 9 Issue 9, p3 

    Provides tips on gaining opportunities for full engagement and joy in the pursuit of a goal. Description of the flow experience of people; Result of the experience of flow; Importance of having clear goals and objectives.

  • McKenna's Quality of Will. Shoemaker, David // Criminal Law & Philosophy;Dec2015, Vol. 9 Issue 4, p695 

    In this paper, I investigate the role played by Quality of Will in Michael McKenna's conversational theory of responsibility. I articulate and press the skeptical challenge against it, and then I show that McKenna has the (untapped) resources in his account to deflect it.

  • When need for closure leads to positive attitudes towards a negatively stereotyped outgroup. Kossowska, Małgorzata; Dragon, Piotr; Bukowski, Marcin // Motivation & Emotion;Feb2015, Vol. 39 Issue 1, p88 

    The study examined the relationship between epistemic motivation, which is the need for closure (NFC), and positive attitudes towards a negatively stereotyped outgroup (i.e., Gypsies). Although extensive research has revealed that NFC is related to derogatory behavioural tendencies and negative...

  • Pedal to The Meddle. Svoboda, Elizabeth // Psychology Today;May/Jun2010, Vol. 43 Issue 3, p38 

    The author discusses how one can be a better backseat driver, someone who aims to give helpful advice but is often regarded as annoying and distracting. She explains that such attitude reflects one's desire to overcome their feeling of powerlessness and the realization that they are not in...

  • CHAPTER 12.  // Aristotle, Rhetoric II: A Commentary;1989, p183 

    Chapter 12 of the book "Rhetoric," by Aristotle, is presented. It focuses on the young and their character traits. In particular, it examines the desires of the young, their emotions, their attitudes and their actions. In general, young people are strong, bodily in character, violet but not...

  • Stay Motivated. Widener, Chris // Personal Excellence Essentials;Jul2007, Vol. 12 Issue 7, p7 

    The author presents tips on how to stay motivated. According to the author, to be motivated means to have found one's motive or reason to act. He adds that if a person wants to see change in his life, the first thing he must do is change his current actions. He says by changing one's current...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics