Modeling Stadium Statue Subject Choice in U.S. Baseball and English Soccer

Stride, Chris; Thomas, Ffion E.; Wilson, John P.; Pahigian, Josh
March 2012
Journal of Quantitative Analysis in Sports;Mar2012, Vol. 8 Issue 1, p0
Academic Journal
From an almost standing start at the beginning of the 1990s, the number of statues of U.S. baseball and English soccer heroes has risen inexorably. By 1st September 2011, 33 soccer players and 67 Major League Baseball (MLB) players were, or were soon to be, depicted by existing or commissioned subject specific statues inside or adjacent to the stadia they once performed in. Yet even amongst the very finest exponents of their sport, relatively few players are honored in this way.This paper investigates and compares the defining characteristics of stadium statue subjects in these two national sports. We first developed a shortlist of potential causal factors likely to influence subject selection by considering the motivations behind statue building. The MLB Hall of Fame and the English Football League “100 Legends” list were then used as samples of the best performers from each sport. Logistic regression models were built to test the effects of potential predictors for the selection of statue subjects; these included loyalty, locality, longevity, performance of the player and their team, national recognition, sympathy and the effect of nostalgia or memory (i.e., the era a player performed in).The optimal models for soccer and baseball correctly identified depiction or non-depiction for 87% and 90.6% of the respective samples, and their significant constituent effects indicated the importance of club loyalty and era. Players who played most or all of their careers at one club or franchise and those active in the 1950s and 1960s were most likely to be depicted. This latter finding in particular suggests that the role of a statue as a nostalgia/heritage marketing object impacts upon subject choice, which is thus dependent in part on the “chance” effect of birth era. Distinct characteristics of each sport, such as baseball franchise relocation and international soccer success, were also found to have a significant effect upon the probability of depiction. Predicted probabilities were calculated for players with statues who were not Football League “Legends” or MLB Hall of Famers; these confirm the viability of the model outside of the elite performers it was constructed upon.


Related Articles

  • Untitled. Bourke, Joanna // EG: Estates Gazette;7/5/2014, Issue 1379, p03 

    The article reports on the proposed stadium for the AFC Wimbledon football club and home development at Plough Lane in London, England in 2014.

  • Untitled. Bourke, Joanna // EG: Estates Gazette;11/30/2013, Issue 1349, p03 

    The article reports that England's League Two football club, Northampton Town Football Club, has been granted planning permission for the first phase of its Sixfields Stadium redevelopment.

  • TOTTENHAM SPURS ON MIXED-USE MAKEOVER FOR STADIUM.  // EG: Estates Gazette;10/31/2009, Issue 943, p32 

    The article reports that Premier League football club Tottenham Hotspur has submitted plans for a mixed-use redevelopment of its Hart Lane stadium in Tottenham, England. Included in the new stadium are 434 homes, a hotel and a supermarket. Public consultation will be conducted for the designs of...

  • SPURS SCORE WITH STADIUM PROPOSAL.  // EG: Estates Gazette;12/20/2008, Issue 850, p14 

    The article reports that the Tottenham Hotspur football club has unveiled the first images of its proposed stadium-led regeneration on the site of its traditional White Hart Lane base in London N17 in England. The Northumberland Development Project, designed by KSS architects, will increase...

  • Starting Five. Hille, Bob // Sporting News;11/20/2000, Vol. 224 Issue 47, p7 

    Presents the top five sporting news in the United States as of November 2000. Tips for improving baseball games; Importance of qualifying in World Cup soccer for Americans; Record of the Philadelphia 76ers basketball team.

  • When William Wallace was a Unionist. WILKIE, BENJAMIN // Quadrant Magazine;Apr2014, Vol. 58 Issue 4, p30 

    The article offers information about the statue of the Scottish hero William Wallace. The statue, designed by Melbourne sculptor Percival Ball, represents Wallace standing on Abbey Craig waiting to give the signal for his troops to descend upon the English forces crossing Stirling Bridge. It...

  • Manchester United.  // Conference & Incentive Travel;Jan2011 Global Event Planner, p64 

    The article offers a corporate profile for Manchester United Ltd. in Manchester, England. Manchester United works with devoted suppliers who can offer a complete range of professional audio visual services and facilities for any event. Manchester United has 160 meeting rooms and 24 suites set...

  • Emirates gunning for live gig events. Masson, Gordon // Music Week;11/22/2008, Issue 47, p7 

    This article reports that the British football stadium Emirates Stadium in London, England has been approved for use as a concert venue by the Islington Council. Musician Bruce Springsteen hosted two concerts at the venue in May, 2008, grossing approximately 6.2 million pounds in ticket sales...

  • Dartford Football Club. Craik, David // Ecologist;Oct2008, Vol. 38 Issue 8, p39 

    The article discusses the construction of Princes Park, home field of the British soccer team the Dartford Football Club. Topics include a description of the stadium including ecological features, a brief biography of and comments from Bill Archer, director of the club, and how building the...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics