Reframing South African TV news as peace journalism: interim findings from a field experiment

Lynch, J.; McGoldrick, A.
December 2012
Communicare;Dec2012, Vol. 31 Issue 2, p78
Academic Journal
This article presents an indicative sample from the results of an experiment that gathered audience responses to television news that was coded as "war journalism" and "peace journalism" respectively, in South Africa, during April 2012. From the peace journalism model, evaluative criteria were derived under a set of five headings for content analysis of two television news programmes and four newspapers. Distinctions under the headings were particularised for individual stories by critical discourse analysis to disclose potential sources of influence transmitted into audience frames. The test material was then coded to fall within the upper and lower peace journalism quartiles of the 'idiom and range' of journalism, as currently practised, demonstrated by the content analysis. Transcripts of discussions by focus groups who saw the material, as well as written notes made whilst viewing by a larger sample of participants, were themed according to Entman's model of framing (1993), where causal interpretation is linked to treatment recommendation. From these interim findings, peace journalism proved to be ideational in the sense that peace journalism viewers were more likely to perceive structural and/or systemic explanations for problems, and more likely to see opportunities for therapeutic and/or cooperative remedies to be applied through exertions of political agency from different levels.


Related Articles

  • News programmes on Polish and foreign television (comparative analysis).  // Media Studies;2009, Issue 38, p1 

    No abstract available.

  • Television News and Presidential Campaigns: The Legitimization of Televised Political Advertising. Kaid, Lynda Lee; Gobetz, Robert H.; Garner, Jane; Leland, Chris M.; Scott, David K. // Social Science Quarterly (University of Texas Press);Jun93, Vol. 74 Issue 2, p274 

    Media professional Tony Schwartz declared that in the past "political parties were the means of communication from the candidate to public." For most candidates, the preferred message format for television communication is the political spot advertisement. However, while a candidate can control...

  • Erratum: "Qualitative Content Analysis of Television News: Systematic Techniques"  // Qualitative Sociology;Spring89, Vol. 12 Issue 1, p3 

    A correction is presented to the article "Qualitative Content Analysis of Television News: Systematic Techniques" by Echo E. Field, which was published in the journal's Fall 1988 issue, reproducing three figures which had been omitted.

  • Ethnic minorities in Australia's television news: a second snapshot. Phillips, Gail // Australian Journalism Review;Jul2009, Vol. 31 Issue 1, p19 

    The nightly news on Australia's television screens presents a view of Australia and Australians that is different from what most of us encounter in our daily lives. This paper reports on the results of two content analyses of television news conducted in 2005 and 2007 which demonstrate that...

  • Making sense of cancer news coverage trends: a comparison of three comprehensive content analyses. Jensen, Jakob D.; Moriarty, Cortney M.; Hurley, Ryan J.; Stryker, Jo Ellen // Comunicação e Sociedade;2012 numero special, Vol. 22, p39 

    Cancer stories (N = 5,327) in the top 50 U.S. newspapers were analyzed by a team of four coders and the results were compared with the earliest analyses of this type (from 1977 and 1980). Using cancer incidence rates as a comparison, three cancers were found to be consistently underreported...

  • Nicaragua, the Peace Process, and Television News: A Study of U.S. and Canadian Coverage in Three Languages. Adam, Barry D. // Canadian Journal of Communication;1991, Vol. 16 Issue 1, p19 

    The article focuses on the television (TV) news broadcasting of the Central American peace process in Nicaragua on national news networks in the U.S. and Canada covering in English, French, and Spanish languages. The news coverage encompassed the last major military offensive of the U.S.-backed...

  • The Coming Together of New and News Media: An Exploratory Study. Lee, Angela // Conference Papers -- National Communication Association;2008, p1 

    As an exploratory study, this study examines, through comparative content analyses, the differences and similarities between local print and television news media in Philadelphia, PA. The results suggest that both the "Philadelphia Inquirer" and "6 ABC News" are conservative in their...

  • WHAT IS TELEVISION STUDIES? King, Noel // Framework: The Journal of Cinema & Media;1984, Issue 25, p111 

    The article discusses various reports in this issue, including one by Jeanne Allen on the way it took 20 years to implement television and another by Robert Stam on television news.

  • Controlling Nature: Weathercasts on Local Television News. Doherty, Richard; Barnhurst, KevinG. // Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media;Apr2009, Vol. 53 Issue 2, p211 

    Since discovering the shrinking politician sound-bite, researchers have shown that TV news grew more journalist-centered since the 1960s. To explore how far journalistic authority extends, this study turns to the weather. It examines local coverage weekday mornings on three local stations before...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics