TITLE

Sticks and Carrots: The Effect of Contract Frame on Effort in Incomplete Contracts

AUTHOR(S)
Christ, Margaret H.; Sedatole, Karen L.; Towry, Kristy L.
PUB. DATE
November 2012
SOURCE
Accounting Review;Nov2012, Vol. 87 Issue 6, p1913
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
In this study, we examine the effect of incentive contract framing on agent effort in an incomplete contract setting. Prior research suggests that when governed by complete incentive contracts, agents exert greater effort under penalty contracts relative to bonus contracts. However, in an incomplete contract setting, in which the incentive contract does not govern all tasks for which the agent is responsible, the agent's trust in the principal is relevant. In this setting, we predict that bonus contracts create a more trusting environment, and this effect spills over to tasks not governed by the incentive contract, such that bonus contracts elicit greater effort on these tasks as compared to penalty contracts. We develop and experimentally validate a theoretical model of the effects of contract frame on trust and effort in this incomplete contract setting. The main intuition behind the model is that the framing of an incentive contract affects the degree to which the contract terms are interpreted by the agent as a signal of mistrust. More specifically, penalty contracts engender greater distrust than do bonus contracts and, therefore, when contracts are incomplete, penalty contracts lead to lower effort on tasks not governed by the contract than do bonus contracts.
ACCESSION #
83392147

 

Related Articles

  • Exclusive dealing, preferential dealing, and dynamic efficiency. Gilbert, Richard J. // Review of Industrial Organization;Mar2000, Vol. 16 Issue 2, p167 

    Examines the legal treatment of exclusive and preferential dealing, and dynamic efficiency in the United States. Implications of contracts terms for investment behavior; Incentives for a seller and a buyer from contract terms penalizing trade with entrant; Contrasts between dynamic efficiency...

  • Penalty clauses and liquidated damages: traps for the unwary.  // Lawyer (Online Edition);2/25/2013, p29 

    The article reports on a judgement on penalty clauses and liquidated damages which has reignited debate about take or pay clauses in a particular breach of contract.

  • Contractual compensation: An Iraqi law perspective.  // Law Update;5/20/2015, p1 

    The article discusses contractual compensation, based on Iraqi law perspective. It offers information on the Iraqi Civil Code in context of contractual compensation. It offers information on the compensation when the object of the obligation is cash money and the legal notice requirements a...

  • Don't pay the penalty. Levy, James // EG: Estates Gazette;6/3/2006, Issue 623, p171 

    The article presents insights on how to avoid the risk of invalid and unenforceable liquidated damages clause in building contracts. Under the clause, the contractor responsible for the delay in the completion of a building will pay a fixed sum to the employer. It cites the differences between...

  • liquidated damages. Stim, Richard // Contracts: The Essential Business Desk Reference;2010, p278 

    An encyclopedia entry for "liquidated damages" is presented. It refers to parties' estimate, made when they sign the contract, of the damages that would be caused by a breach. It presents an example of a liquidated damages provision in a contract. The criteria that a liquidated damages clause...

  • Giving more, getting more from employee bonuses. Cumpata, George // Crain's Chicago Business;12/18/2000, Vol. 23 Issue 52, p11 

    Discusses the approach of gain-sharing in reinvigorating companies' incentive plans and holiday bonuses in the United States. Role of gain-sharing in tying bonuses to specific company targets and distributing them to all employees regularly; Key elements in gain-sharing; Benefits of the...

  • The Remoteness Rules in Contract: Holmes, Hoffmann, and Ships that Pass in the Night. Lawson, K. W. // King's Law Journal;Feb2012, Vol. 23 Issue 1, p1 

    The article presents information on the governance of the rules regarding the damages in contract with respect to the role of the lawyers of Great Britain. The recovery of damages in contract by a party is due to the loss suffered during the breach of contract. Information on the entitlement of...

  • DISCUÅ¢II CU REFERIRE LA CLAUZELE ABUZIVE ÃŽN CONTRACTELE NEGOCIATE, CU PRIVIRE SPECIALÄ‚ ASUPRA CLAUZEI PENALE ABUZIVE. LUDUŞAN, FLORIN // Dreptul;2014, Issue 6, p155 

    In negotiated contracts where parties have established clauses by mutual agreement so-called "abusive clauses" may exist. The abusive character of such clauses may be invoked in negotiated contracts on the ground that one party is always stronger than the other. The penal clause in negotiated...

  • Survey finds managers happy with PFI performance.  // Public Private Finance;Nov2005, Issue 98, p8 

    The article discusses a survey conducted by financial advisers KPMG and Business Services Association which cites that majority of private sector managers believe their private initiative contracts are operating well. Most of the projects are meeting their agreements with the public sector. Some...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of THE LIBRARY OF VIRGINIA

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics