How does anybody live in this strange place? A reply to Samantha Vice

Benatar, David
November 2012
South African Journal of Philosophy;2012, Vol. 31 Issue 4, p619
Academic Journal
Samantha Vice has argued that 'white' South Africans are so tainted by the history of racial oppression in their country that they are incapable of attaining a great degree of moral virtue. She recommends that they should live in humility and political silence. There are a number of flaws in her argument. First, none of the characteristics of 'white' South Africans that she says provides the basis for these conclusions can distinguish (almost) all 'white' South Africans from (almost) all 'black' South Africans. Second, because it is not only 'white' South Africans but everybody in the world who either perpetrates serious injustice or is tainted by others' perpetration of it, her argument, if sound, would imply that nobody is capable of great virtue and that everybody ought to be politically silent. Finally, her recommendation that 'white' South Africans should be politically silent is a very dangerous one.


Related Articles

  • The Rubicon Revisited: A Documentary Approach Re-examining Racial Identity Constructions in 1980s Apartheid South Africa. Kosciejew, Marc // International Journal of Diversity in Organisations, Communities;Sep2008, Vol. 8 Issue 4, p77 

    This paper argues that P.W. Botha's constitutional reforms and, most importantly, his subsequent re-engineering of Apartheid's documentary apparatus, laid the foundation for a future non-racial state. By altering certain Apartheid documents, these reforms re-imagined South African identity as...

  • PEOPLE.  // Background Notes on Countries of the World: South Africa;Jan2005, p3 

    Focuses on the people and education in South Africa. Major racial categories; Overview of its apartheid system of education; Challenge being faced by the educational system.

  • Backing Off.  // Time;8/17/1981, Vol. 118 Issue 7, p49 

    The article focuses on South African Prime Minister P.W. Botha who told his fellow Afrikaners that they must adapt or die in confronting racial segregation. It states that two years back Botha has ideas for moderating South Africa's rigidly segregationist policies of apartheid. It reports that...

  • The invisibility of richness: A critique of Vice's 'strange place'. Villet, Charles // South African Journal of Philosophy;2012, Vol. 31 Issue 4, p702 

    This article builds on Samantha Vice's argument on the problem of whiteness in contemporary South Africa. I will explore the thesis of invisibility regarding whiteness and argue for its relevance to the rich per se. This thesis demonstrates how white privilege and affluence, despite being...

  • Southern Comforts.  // National Geographic Adventure;Dec2004/Jan2005, Vol. 6 Issue 10, p26 

    This article reports that ten years ago, boycotts prevented many South Africans products from getting out of the country. But with the end of the apartheid, the nation's delicates are now available in the United States. South Africa has Pinotage, a Cape Town-area grape variety made by crossing...

  • South Africa and the climatology of race: excerpts from an early 20th century discourse of environmental determinism. Barnard, Wilhelm S. // Tydskrif vir Geesteswetenskappe;maa2006, Vol. 46 Issue 1, p138 

    Because of its low middle latitude location and the juxtaposition of vigorous white and black communities South Africa figured prominently in the early 20th century discourse of environmental determinism, the notion especially entertained by geographers that human physique and culture were...

  • 'We were not part of apartheid': rationalisations used by four white pre-service teachers to make sense of race and their own racial identities. le Roux, Adré // South African Journal of Education;2014, Vol. 34 Issue 2, p1 

    Despite fundamental reforms to South African education, large performance gaps still prevail between former black schools and former white schools. Nineteen years into a democracy and education in post-apartheid South Africa still retains a strong racial dimension between poorer communities and...

  • The bigger, better deal? Jekwa, Sizwekazi // Finweek;10/12/2006, p22 

    The author reflects on the issues of race in South Africa. The author describes various perception of white and black South Africans about the country. Also, she contends that being South African means that they have to constantly deal with the realities of living in a country that created and...

  • SOME HIGHLIGHTS OF JEWISH AFRICANA. Musiker, Reuben // African Research & Documentation;2007, Issue 104, p49 

    Although the Jewish Community in South Africa has always been a small but nevertheless significant minority, it has featured prominently in the country's history. This paper sets out to highlight some of the most important events and developments in the community's local history, culturally,...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics