When did they leave, and why? A retrospective case study of attrition on the Nottingham undergraduate medical course

Yates, Janet
January 2012
BMC Medical Education;2012, Vol. 12 Issue 1, p43
Academic Journal
Background: As part of a wider study into students who experience difficulties, we examined the course files of those who had failed to graduate. This was an exploratory, descriptive study investigating how many students left after academic failure or non-academic problems, or simply changed their minds about reading medicine, and at what stage. The aim of the study was to increase our knowledge about the timings of, and reasons for, attrition. This understanding might help to reduce student loss in the future, by informing selection procedures and improving pastoral support at critical times. It might also assist in long-term workforce planning in the NHS. Methods: Relevant data on admission and course progress were extracted manually from the archived files of students who had failed to graduate from five recent consecutive cohorts (entry in 2000-2004 inclusive), using a customised Access database. Discrete categories of information were supplemented with free text entries. Results: 1188 students registered over the five-year entry period and 73 (6%) failed to graduate. The highest rates of attrition (46/1188, 4%) occurred during the first two years (largely preclinical studies), with 34 students leaving voluntarily, including 11 within the first semester, and 12 having their courses terminated for academic failure. Seventeen left at the end of the third year (Honours course plus early clinical practice) and the remaining ten during the final two clinical years. The reasons for attrition were not always clear-cut and often involved a mixture of academic, personal, social and health factors, especially mental health problems. Conclusions: The causes of attrition are complex. A small number of students with clear academic failure might require individual educational interventions for remediation. However, this could have substantial resource implications for the Faculty. Mental health problems predominate in late course attrition and may have been undisclosed for some time. The introduction of a structured exit interview may provide further insight, especially for those students who leave suddenly and unexpectedly early in the course.


Related Articles

  • La croisée des chemins, 50 ans de soins aux enfants. Gignac, Martin; Boileau, Bernard; Bedwani, Charles Nagy; DiNicola, Vicenzo; Gauthier, Yvon; Lévesque, Alain; Morissette, Louis // Sante Mentale au Quebec;ete2015, Vol. 40 Issue 2, p191 

    Introduction Through a journey in time, we propose to revisit the birth of the first mental health care settings for children with mental disorders affiliated with Université de Montréal, Quebec, Canada. Methods The main centers of child psychiatry affiliated with the Université de...

  • Medical Education in the United States and Canada. Pritchett, Henry S.; Flexner, Abraham // Bulletin of the World Health Organization;2002, Vol. 80 Issue 7, p594 

    Presents results of the medical education assessment in the U.S. conducted by the Carnegie Foundation. History of medical education; Gradual development of the commercial medical school; Movement for the transfer of medical education to university surroundings.

  • Around the world: within the shadow of Table Mountain -- undergraduate medical education in South Africa. Gibbs, Trevor // Education for Primary Care;Nov2004, Vol. 15 Issue 4, p564 

    Focuses on the history of the undergraduate medical education at the University of Cape Town's Faculty of Health Sciences in Cape Town, South Africa. Impetus to the founding; Difficulties encounter by the faculty in the establishment of the campus; Reason behind the changes made to the curriculum.

  • NIMHANS' objective structured clinical assessment and feedback model could be a boon for budding medical colleges in India. Loganathan, Santosh // Indian Journal of Psychiatry;Apr-Jun2012, Vol. 54 Issue 2, p199 

    A letter to the editor is presented in response to the article "Postgraduate patients as simulated patients in psychiatric training: Role players and interviewers perceptions," by S. K. Chaturvedi and P. S. Chandra in the 2010 issue.

  • Medical students' views about an undergraduate curriculum in psychiatry before and after clinical placements. Oakley, Clare; Oyebode, Femi // BMC Medical Education;2008, Vol. 8, Special section p1 

    Background: It has been suggested that medical students wish to focus their learning in psychiatry on general skills that are applicable to all doctors. This study seeks to establish what aspects of psychiatry students perceive to be relevant to their future careers and what psychiatric...

  • Symposium on the Teaching of Psychiatry to Undergraduates.  // British Journal of Psychiatry;Apr83, Vol. 142, p327 

    The article discusses the approaches of several universities in teaching psychiatry to medical students in Great Britain. The teaching of psychiatry to medical students has changed. The psychiatric specialists has come out of the institution and are now play a societal role as advisor, team...

  • England: St George's Hospital Medical School, London. Crisp, A. H. // British Journal of Psychiatry;Apr83, Vol. 142, p345 

    The article discusses the teaching of psychiatry at St. George's Hospital Medical School in London, England. The school's Department of Psychiatry is involved in the undergraduate teaching. The first two years are taught mainly by basic medical scientists, while the next two years are taught by...

  • England: University of Manchester. Goldberg, David; Benjamin, Sidney; Creed, Francis; Maguire, Peter // British Journal of Psychiatry;Apr83, Vol. 142, p350 

    The article discusses the teaching of psychiatry at the University of Manchester in England. The necessary groundwork is laid during the preclinical years of the medical students. The main clinical teaching takes place in seven weeks of a full-time nine-week clerkship in the fourth year. A range...

  • Scotland: Aberdeen University. Blackwood, G. W.; Alexander, D. A. // British Journal of Psychiatry;Apr83, Vol. 142, p358 

    The article discusses the teaching of psychiatry at Aberdeen University in Scotland. The medical course lasts five years, with approximately 120 students in each year. The main teaching of medicine and surgery during the third year involves coordinated systems teaching with daily ward work. In...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics