The Limits of Razian Authority

Tucker, Adam
August 2012
Res Publica (13564765);Aug2012, Vol. 18 Issue 3, p225
Academic Journal
It is common to encounter the criticism that Joseph Raz's service conception of authority is flawed because it appears to justify too much. This essay examines the extent to which the service conception accommodates this critique. Two variants of this critical strategy are considered. The first, exemplified by Kenneth Einar Himma, alleges that the service conception fails to conceptualize substantive limits on the legitimate exercise of authority. This variant fails; Raz has elucidated substantive limits on jurisdiction within the service conception of authority, albeit reluctantly and equivocally. The second, exemplified by Scott Hershovitz, alleges that the service conception fails to conceptualize procedural limits on the legitimate exercise of authority. He objects that the normal justification thesis fails to deny legitimacy to rational and expert dictators. This argument is more potent, but its force is concealed when it is aimed at the normal justification thesis rather than the quite separate jurisdictional limits of Raz's theory. Clarifying those jurisdictional aspects of the service conception shows why the first argument fails and exposes the real strength of the second. Both variants have important consequences for our understanding of the service conception.


Related Articles

  • Political Anarchism and Raz's Theory of Authority. Leipold, Bruno // Res Publica (13564765);Aug2015, Vol. 21 Issue 3, p309 

    This article argues that using Joseph Raz's service conception of authority to reject philosophical anarchism can be affected by political anarchism. Whereas philosophical anarchism only denies the authority of the state, political anarchism claims that anarchism is a better alternative to the...

  • Raz on Authority and Democracy. Rondel, David // Dialogue: Canadian Philosophical Review;Jun2012, Vol. 51 Issue 2, p211 

    ABSTRACT: I argue that Joseph Raz’s service conception of authority cannot convincingly account for the nature and source of democratic authority. It cannot explain (a) why decisions made democratically are more likely to be sound than decisions made non-democratically, and therefore, (b)...

  • Unresolved Problems in the Service Conception of Authority. Sherman, James // Oxford Journal of Legal Studies;Autumn2010, Vol. 30 Issue 3, p419 

    This article introduces and discusses a series of problems which any adequate account of legitimate practical authority must be able to solve. I then argue that Joseph Raz's influential Service Conception of Authority is unable to solve them. I develop a new account of legitimate authority by...

  • Authority and Democracy in Corporate Governance? (Hans) van Oosterhout, J. // Journal of Business Ethics;Apr2007, Vol. 71 Issue 4, p359 

    Although McMahon offers a potentially valuable extension of Joseph Raz's conceptualization of authority by distinguishing three different kinds of authority, this paper argues, first, that his account of the conditions and considerations that would justify managerial authority is problematic...

  • Democratic theory and the present/absent international. Walker, R. B. J. // Ethics & Global Politics;03/01/2010, Vol. 3 Issue 1, p21 

    In this article the author examines the basic theory of democracy. The author discusses the relationship between a federation of democracies and a profoundly problematic category of humanity. He also argues that any attempt to rethink democracy must be highly sensitive to the historical and...

  • Political Legitimacy Without a (Claim-) Right to Rule. Reglitz, Merten // Res Publica (13564765);Aug2015, Vol. 21 Issue 3, p291 

    In the contemporary philosophical literature, political legitimacy is often identified with a right to rule. However, this term is problematic. First, if we accept an interest theory of rights, it often remains unclear whose interests justify a right to rule (the 'grounds of authority'...

  • Don't Go Breaking My Hart. Krishnamurthi, Guha // Texas Law Review;Mar2010, Vol. 88 Issue 4, p833 

    The article reviews the book "The Rule of Recognition and the U.S. Constitution," edited by Matthew D. Adler and Kenneth Einar Himma.

  • The very idea of legal positivism. Paulson, Stanley L. // Revista Brasileira de Estudos Politicos;jan-jun2011, Issue 102, p139 

    The article discusses the concept of legal positivism, particularly inclusive and exclusive legal positivism. It cites the opinion of Kenneth Einar Himma on the so called separation principle, as well as the necessary overlap between the law and morality. It presents the legal philosophy of John...

  • Democracy in Spain: Legitimacy, discontent, and disaffection. Montero, Jose Ramon; Gunther, Richard; Torcal, Mariano // Studies in Comparative International Development;Fall97, Vol. 32 Issue 3, p124 

    Examines changes in public perceptions of democracy in Spain, in relation to democratic legitimacy, dissatisfaction and discontent. Comparison between democratic legitimacy and political discontent; Ways in which these attitudes evolved in Spain; Empirical indicators of democratic legitimacy.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics