The Ideal of African Scholarship and its Implications for Introductory Philosophy: the Example of Placide Tempels

Giddy, Patrick
August 2012
South African Journal of Philosophy;2012, Vol. 31 Issue 3, p504
Academic Journal
Thinking of an academic discipline in terms of a 'social practice' (MacIntyre) helps in formulating what the ideal captured in the slogan 'African scholarship' can contribute to the discipline. For every practice is threatened by the attractiveness of goods external to the practice - in particular, competitiveness for its own sake - and to counter this virtues of character are needed. African traditional culture prioritizes a normative picture of the human person which could very well contribute here to upholding the values internal to scholarship. I argue, contrary to Matolino, that for these purposes Tempels' notion of the transactional process of becoming more of what you are by virtue of the human insertion in nature, is a useful starting point. But the dominant way philosophy is framed today, the human person outside of 'nature', omitting the key notion of presence-to-self, disallows this dialogue between the dominant tradition and African thought culture. I show, by interrogating what I take to be an impoverished understanding of objectivity in the dominant philosophical approach, how the idea of personal, subjective, growth is crucial to introductory philosophy if the project of African scholarship is to find purchase. As an example I look at rival ways of understanding the value of justice, procedurally or, alternatively, substantively and hence foregrounding participation.1


Related Articles

  • Learned societies: resilience not reliance required.  // Learned Publishing;Apr2014, Vol. 27 Issue 2, p83 

    In this article, the author argues that resilience and not reliance is required in learned societies. It notes that learned societies refer to the devotion to academic disciplines or professions that are commonly not-for-profit membership organizations. The author states that the investment of...

  • Teaching Residents How to Teach:A Scholarship of Teaching and Learning Certificate Program (STLC) for Pharmacy Residents. Romanelli, Frank; Smith, Kelly M.; Brandt, Barbara F. // American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education;May2005, Vol. 69 Issue 2, p126 

    Objectives. In 1999, the University of Kentucky (UK) College of Pharmacy first reported the development of a STLC Program for pharmacy residents. The primary goal of this program was to provide a forum for participants to gain knowledge of contemporary health professions and pharmacy education...

  • Promoting Teaching and Learning Scholarship and Exchange. Debowski, Shelda // HERDSA News;Dec2012, Vol. 34 Issue 3, p4 

    The article reports on the promotion of teaching and learning scholarship by the Higher Education Research and Development Society of Australasia (HERDSA) through the funding provided by the Office of Learning and Teaching.

  • Bridging the Disciplines. Frost, Susan H.; Jean, Paul M. // Journal of Higher Education;Mar/Apr2003, Vol. 74 Issue 2, p119 

    Examines the effects of academic culture and disciplinary specialty on scholarship in the U.S. Factors influencing the attitudes of faculty; Enhancement of the quality of the scholarships; Development of approaches for teaching and research.

  • The National Enquiry into Scholarly Communication-Twenty Years After. Abel, Richard // Publishing Research Quarterly;Spring99, Vol. 15 Issue 1, p4 

    Provides information on the report of the National Enquiry into Scholarly Communication organized under the auspices of the American Council of Learned Societies. Structure of the work of the National Enquiry; Studies relating to the issues of interests to the National Enquiry; Critiques and...

  • The view from the castle. Ripley, S. Dillon // Smithsonian;Aug84, Vol. 15 Issue 5, p10 

    Comments on the preparations for the 200th year anniversary of the Smithsonian Institution in 1984. History of the institute; Goal of the institute to provide a venue for the convergence of literary, historic and scientific institutes; Belief that scholarship and research must work together to...

  • After a long and bitter battle, a clear victory for the redwoods Jones, Robert A. // Smithsonian;Jul1978, Vol. 9 Issue 4, p38 

    Redwood National Park in California was created in 1968. Initially squeezed between enormous tracts of commercial timberland, the park was seriously threatened by erosion caused by logging cuts made at the borders. After a 10-year battle between environmentalists and loggers, additional land was...

  • Quantitative Literacy Interventions at University of Cape Town: Effects of Separation from Academic Disciplines. Frith, Vera // Numeracy: Advancing Education in Quantitative Literacy;Jan2012, Vol. 5 Issue 1, preceding p1 

    The aim of the Numeracy Centre at the University of Cape Town is to develop students' quantitative literacy (QL) in a manner consistent with their programmes of study and intended roles in the community. Our theoretical perspective on the nature of QL is in line with that of the New Literacies...

  • Faculty Involvement in the Scholarship of Teaching.  // Academic Leader;Sep2004, Vol. 20 Issue 9, p2 

    Reports on the faculty involvement in the scholarship of teaching in the U.S. Completion of academic discipline to the institutionalization of scholarship; Creation of unpublished scholarly work related to teaching; Respect and recognition of the teaching profession with the pedagogical publication.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics