A Study on Aggregation of TOPSIS Ideal Solutions for Group Decision-Making

Huang, Yeu-Shiang; Li, Wei-Hao
July 2012
Group Decision & Negotiation;Jul2012, Vol. 21 Issue 4, p461
Academic Journal
The technique for order preference by similarity to ideal solution (TOPSIS) has become a popular multi-criteria decision making (MCDM) technique, since it has a comprehensible theoretical structure and is able to provide an exact model for decision making. For the use of TOPSIS in group decisions, the common approaches in aggregating individual decision makers' judgments are the geometric and the arithmetic mean methods, although these are too intuitive and do not consider either preference levels or preference priorities among alternatives for individual decision makers. In this paper, a TOPSIS group decision aggregation model is proposed in which the construction consists of three stages: (1) The weight differences are calculated first as the degrees of preferences among different alternatives for each decision maker; (2) The alternative priorities are then derived, and the highest one can be denoted as the degree to which a decision maker wants his most favorite alternative to be chosen; (3) The group ideal solutions approach in TOPSIS is used for the aggregation of similarities obtained from different decision makers. A comparative analysis is performed, and the proposed aggregation model seems to be more satisfactory than the traditional aggregation model for solving compromise-oriented decision problems.


Related Articles

  • Criterion of Eliminating Single-Parameter Model Uncertainty with Principle of Assuredly Minimal Absolute Lacks and Arithmetic Mean. Romanuke, V. V. // Naukovi visti NTUU - KPI;2012, Vol. 85 Issue 5, p75 

    There is stated a problem of generation and removal of model uncertainty regarding a single parameter of the being investigated object, which is described with more than one mathematical model. Using the arithmetic mean in removing such single-parameter model uncertainty is compared to the...

  • A Comparison of Group Model Building and Strategic Options Development and Analysis. Rouwette, Etienne; Bastings, Ingrid; Blokker, Hans // Group Decision & Negotiation;Nov2011, Vol. 20 Issue 6, p781 

    A distinctive tradition within group decision support uses models to structure managerial problems. In this tradition, stakeholders jointly construct a model on their issue of concern in facilitated workshops. In the past decades a wide variety of theoretical insights into and techniques for...

  • An approach to group decision making under uncertainty with application to project selection. Sotirov, George R.; Krasteva, Evdokia B. // Annals of Operations Research;1994, Vol. 51 Issue 1-4, p115 

    In this paper we present an approach and interactive procedure for group decision making under imprecision of expert judgements as applied to problems containing explicitly given resource constraints in particular to project selection. Alternatives (projects) are evaluated in a scale with a...

  • OPTIMAL LINEAR OPINION POOLS. DeGroot, Morris H.; Mortera, Julia // Management Science;May91, Vol. 37 Issue 5, p546 

    Consider a decision problem involving a group of m Bayesians in which each member reports his/her posterior distribution for some random variable 0. The individuals all share a common prior distribution for 0 and a common loss function, but form their posterior distributions based on different...

  • Combining Expert Judgment by Hierarchical Modeling: An Application to Physician Staffing. Lipscomb, Joseph; Parmigiani, Giovanni; Hasselblad, Vic // Management Science;Feb1998, Vol. 44 Issue 2, p149 

    Expert panels are playing an increasingly important role in U.S. health policy decision making. A fundamental issue in these applications is how to synthesize the judgments of individual experts into a group judgment. In this paper we propose an approach to synthesis based on Bayesian...

  • OPTIMAL ACQUISITION OF POLLUTION CONTROL EQUIPMENT UNDER UNCERTAINTY. Hartl, Richard F. // Management Science;May92, Vol. 38 Issue 5, p609 

    This paper considers a firm, which has to acquire a certain amount of pollution control equipment in order to comply with government pollution standards. Due to political battles and lobbying efforts, the compliance date and the date when it is announced are not known in advance. Furthermore,...

  • Lessons Learned: The Complexity of Accurate Identification of in-Text Citations. Shahid, Abdul; Afzal, Muhammad Tanvir; Qadir, Muhammad Abdul // International Arab Journal of Information Technology (IAJIT);Sep2015, Vol. 12 Issue 5, p481 

    The importance of citations is widely recognized by the scientific community' . Citations are being used in making a number of vital decisions such as calculating impact factor of journals, calculating impact of a researcher (H-Index), ranking universities and research organizations....

  • An Enhanced Russell Measure of Super-Efficiency for Ranking Efficient Units in Data Envelopment Analysis. Ali Ashrafi; Azmi Bin Jaafar; Lai Soon Lee; Mohd Rizam Abu Bakar // American Journal of Applied Sciences;2011, Vol. 8 Issue 1, p92 

    Problem statement: Conventional Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) helps decision makers to discriminate between efficient and inefficient Decision Making Units (DMUs). However, DEA does not provide more information about the efficient DMUs. Super-efficiency DEA model can be used in ranking the...

  • TIN-DS/AHP: An Intelligent Method for Group Multiple Attribute Decision Making. Yuanwei Du; Chen Han; Youguo Jing; Jing Liu // Applied Mathematics & Information Sciences;2014, Vol. 8 Issue 2, p857 

    The group decision-making problems with several experts and seriously different opinions are unable to be solved by current existing DS/AHP methods. In order to solve above problems, a derived model is constructed to recognize the optimal Basic Probability Assignment (BPA) functions from TIN...


Read the Article

Courtesy of

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics