Wildlife and the Animal Welfare Act 1999: Can "Cruel" Acts of Hunting ever be Prosecuted?

Sankoff, Peter
December 2011
New Zealand Journal of Environmental Law;2011, Vol. 15, p213
Academic Journal
Tucked into the very back of the Animal Welfare Act 1999 is s 175, a clause that effectively exempts wildlife from the scope of New Zealand animal protection law. Ostensibly enacted to permit legitimate forms of hunting, fishing and pest control to remain immune from scrutiny, the clause has morphed into a comprehensive exemption. As a result, acts of ill-treatment that would clearly be punishable had the victims been domestic or farmed animals can be committed with impunity against wild animals. This article will consider how s 175 has been applied and examine its impact on wildlife. After proposing a more limited interpretation of the clause that would provide a modicum of protection for wild animals, the article proposes a number of reform options that would better balance the needs of wildlife and persons involved in the activities that cause them harm.


Related Articles

  • Part III: North America: Chapter 1: Hunting laws and customs. Comb, Richard; Elman, Robert // Hunting Allies;2003, p61 

    The chapter provides information on hunting laws and customs in North America. Two conflicting cultures shape attitudes toward hunting in the U.S. and, to a lesser degree, in Canada. Outside Alaska, little true wilderness remains in the U.S., and much farmland has given way to development in...

  • Airgun attacks on animals.  // Veterinary Record: Journal of the British Veterinary Association;1/28/2006, Vol. 158 Issue 4, p111 

    The article reports on a survey regarding air gun violence against animals conducted by the Scottish Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (SSPCA) in Scotland. It shows that at least 170 animals were injured by air guns in 2005. A questionnaire was sent out to 316 veterinary practices...

  • Wildlife belongs equally to all Ontario residents. Ford, John // Ontario Out of Doors;Dec/Jan2005, Vol. 36 Issue 10, ANGLER & HUNTER HOTLINE p2 

    This article focuses on hunting laws in Canada. Some of the laws are cancellation of Ontario's spring bear hunt; ban on hunting wolves and coyotes around Algonquin Park; and the current proposal for a northern resident moose tag draw. All of these signal a disturbing trend. All pose a threat to...

  • Senseless Seasons & Moronic Regulations. Cooney, Judd // Predator Xtreme;Apr2007, p20 

    The article criticizes the predator hunting laws in the U.S. He expresses his disappointment over a federal law that limits the total number of days for crow hunting. He despises laws in Virginia and New York that prohibit hunting coyotes during the spring. Virginia's coyote season is open...

  • Party-hunt rules to change. Helsdon, Jeff // Ontario Out of Doors;Feb2004, Vol. 36 Issue 1, p11 

    Deer, moose and bear hunters should have new, clearer party-hunting regulations this fall. The changes, which were still open to comment on the Environmental Bill of Rights Web site at the deadline for this issue, would require party hunters to have an immediate and reliable form of...

  • Seriously, Folks. Holtzmann, Roger // South Dakota Magazine;Jan/Feb2005, Vol. 20 Issue 5, p59 

    Focuses on issues concerning the restrictions needed to be imposed on the law on hunting to keep the wildlife population in South Dakota from dwindling and the kind of outsource technical support service rendered by computer companies. Suggestion wherein hunters would be allowed to hunt animals...

  • Pittman-Robertson Reform Update.  // Bowhunter;Aug/Sep2000, Vol. 29 Issue 6, p36 

    Offers an update on a United States legislation introduced to correct problems with the administration of the Pittman-Robertson Wildlife Restoration program by the US Fish and Wildlife Service.

  • Policy Changes and the Demand for Lottery-Rationed Big Game Hunting Licenses. Scrogin, David; Berrens, Robert P.; Bohara, Alok K. // Journal of Agricultural & Resource Economics;2000, Vol. 25 Issue 2, p501 

    Lotteries are commonly used to allocate big game hunting privileges. In this study, lottery demand and consumer surplus are modeled before and after policy changes designed to increase participation. The application is to New Mexico elk hunt lotteries. Given the volume and variety of hunts, we...

  • Sunday hunting update. Helsdon, Jeff // Ontario Out of Doors;Aug2005, Vol. 37 Issue 7, p13 

    This article reports that legislative changes to allow Sunday hunting in southern Ontario were still in the works at press time, but won't happen for this fall's hunting seasons. Gary Brown, fish and wildlife legislation specialist with the Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources, said that...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics