Learners favour high resolution oesophageal manometry with better diagnostic accuracy over conventional line tracings

Soudagar, A. Samad; Sayuk, Gregory S.; Gyawali, C. Prakash
June 2012
Gut;Jun2012, Vol. 61 Issue 6, p798
Academic Journal
Background High resolution manometry (HRM) provides a colourful representation of oesophageal motility. Novice and intermediate learners were tested to compare HRM Clouse plots and conventional manometry for accuracy, ease of interpretation and knowledge retention. Methods 36 learners evaluated 60 randomised motility sequences (30 HRM Clouse plots with corresponding line tracings) 4 months apart, following a tutorial. Learners rated prior knowledge of oesophageal pathophysiology and manometry and scored ease and speed of interpretation on 10 cm visual analogue scales (VAS). Results Understanding of oesophageal pathophysiology was low in all cohorts (2.9±0.4 on VAS) and knowledge of HRM and conventional motility studies was even lower (1.9±0.4 and 1.8±0.3, respectively, p=NS). After the tutorial, diagnostic accuracy was significantly higher with HRM Clouse plots than with line tracings (p<0.001). HRM gains in diagnostic accuracy were evident over line tracings (43.1%), particularly with aperistalsis (36.1%), oesophageal body hypomotility (25.8%) and relaxation of the lower oesophageal sphincter (21.0%) (p<0.001 for each comparison); these were maintained at the second evaluation. Gains were independent of academic level (F=0.56, p=0.5) and did not correlate with prior experience of learners (r=-0.18, p=0.29). Learners favoured HRM Clouse plots (80.6%) over line tracings and reported faster interpretation (94.4%). Conclusions HRM Clouse plots provide ease of interpretation that translates into higher diagnostic accuracy and better knowledge retention in novice and intermediate learners of oesophageal manometry. These results implicate the value of pattern recognition in HRM interpretation, irrespective of academic level and prior understanding of oesophageal motor function. INSET: Significance of this study.


Related Articles

  • Effect of Mosapride Combined with Esomeprazole Improves Esophageal Peristaltic Function in Patients with Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease: A Study Using High Resolution Manometry. Cho, Yu; Choi, Myung-Gyu; Park, Eun; Lim, Chul; Kim, Jin; Park, Jae; Lee, In; Kim, Sang; Choi, Kyu // Digestive Diseases & Sciences;Apr2013, Vol. 58 Issue 4, p1035 

    Background: Whether addition of prokinetics to proton pump inhibitors improves esophageal peristalsis and symptoms in patients with gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) remains unknown. Aim: We evaluated the effect of mosapride, a 5-HT agonist, and PPI cotherapy in patients with GERD on...

  • Mediastinal traversing fatal oesophageal injury from an unusual trajectory: A case report and review of literature. Ahmad, Jameel Ismail; Inuwa, Ismail Mohammed; Atiku, Mahmud; Atiku, Adamu // Nigerian Journal of Basic & Clinical Sciences;2015, Vol. 12 Issue 2, p121 

    Oesophageal perforation is a potentially lethal clinical condition. Penetrating thoracic oesophageal injury is associated with increased morbidity and mortality, especially if the interval between the injury and commencement of treatment is delayed beyond 24 h. We present a 20-year-old man with...

  • A delayed presentation of Boerhaave's syndrome with mediastinitis managed using the over-the-scope clip. Ramhamadany, Eamon; Mohamed, Saif; Jaunoo, Shameen; Baker, T.; Mannath, Jayan; Harding, James; Menon, Vinod // Journal of Surgical Case Reports;May2013, Vol. 2013 Issue 5, Special section p1 

    Boerhaave syndrome is a spontaneous perforation of the oesophagus secondary to forceful emesis. Surgery has been advocated in delayed presentations of Boerhaave's syndrome with mediastinitis. The over-the-scope clip (OTSC) by OVESCOw (Tubingen, Germany) has been used in the endoscopic management...

  • Ooesophageal injuries position paper, WSES, 2013. Ivatury, Rao R.; Moore, Frederick A.; Biffl, Walter; Leppeniemi, Ari; Ansaloni, Luca; Catena, Fausto; Peitzman, Andrew; Moore, Ernest E. // World Journal of Emergency Surgery;2014, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p1 

    The oesophagus is a difficult challenge for the surgeon because of its lack of serosal covering, the tenuous, segmental blood supply and the common delay in the diagnosis of injury. Early diagnosis is the key to successful management. Recent introduction of newer, minimally invasive techniques...

  • Conquer The Ins and Outs of Esophageal Dilations With This Expert Advice.  // Gastroenterology Coding Alert;Aug2012, Vol. 14 Issue 8, pp57 

    The article offers coding techniques for esophageal dilation. It discusses various codings to be reported for balloon dilation procedures done if only the esophagus is visualized, and if the gastroentologist visualized beyond the pyloric channel into the stomach, duodenum, and jejunum. According...

  • Anaesthesia for oesophagectomy. Sherry, Kathleen M.; Smith, Fang Gao // Continuing Education in Anaesthesia, Critical Care & Pain;Jun2003, Vol. 3 Issue 3, p87 

    The article focuses on esophagectomy and its appropriate anesthetic management. It can be approached by either a left or right transthoracic, which allows good visualization for en-bloc removal of the esophagus, and transhiatal, which involves resection of the intrathoracic esophagus through...

  • Doxycyclin induced esophageal injury: A Case series. Demiryılmaz, İsmail; Yılmaz, İsmayil; Peker, Kemal; Şahin, Atalay; Sekban, Nurdan // Dicle Medical Journal / Dicle Tip Dergisi;2013, Vol. 40 Issue 2, p281 

    Some drugs have been known to damage to esophagus for a long time. Half of the cases reported are of tetracycline and its derivatives. The damage caused by these drugs is depends on the drug itself and the patient. In this paper we present 5 patients having diagnosed esophageal damage...

  • DYSPHAGIA CLINIC. Esophageal perforation in a patient with diverticulum following anterior discectomy and fusion. Kazi, Aasif A.; Solowski, Nancy L.; Postma, Gregory N.; Weinberger, Paul M. // ENT: Ear, Nose & Throat Journal;Oct/Nov2013, Vol. 92 Issue 10/11, p506 

    The article describes the case of esophageal perforation in a patient with diverticulum following anterior discectomy and fusion. The patient was a 42-year-old man who presented with a history of dysphagia and regurgitation, weight loss and protein malnutrition. The diagnosis, surgery and...

  • Surgical Repair of Traumatic Oesophageal Rupture in a Pigeon. Kushwaha, R. B.; Dwivedi, D. K. // Intas Polivet;Jul-Dec2010, Vol. 11 Issue 2, p395 

    The article presents a case study concerning surgical repair of traumatic oesophageal rupture in a pigeon. It cites an adult free flying indigenous pigeon which has a history of traumatic injury in the cervical area. It notes that the diagnosis involves oesophageal rupture which demands...


Read the Article


Sign out of this library

Other Topics