Democracy and the Multitude: Spinoza against Negri

Field, Sandra
June 2012
Theoria: A Journal of Social & Political Theory;6/14/2012, Vol. 59 Issue 131, p21
Academic Journal
Negri celebrates a conception of democracy in which the concrete powers of individual humans are not alienated away, but rather are added together: this is a democracy of the multitude. But how can the multitude act without alienating anyone's power? To answer this difficulty, Negri explicitly appeals to Spinoza. Nonetheless, in this paper, I argue that Spinoza's philosophy does not support Negri's project. I argue that the Spinozist multitude avoids internal hierarchy through the mediation of political institutions and not in spite of them; nor do these institutions merely emanate from the multitude as it is, but rather they structure, restrain and channel its passions. In particular, the required institutions are not those of a simple direct democracy. There may be other non-Spinozist arguments on which Negri can ground his theory, but he cannot legitimately defend his conception of the democratic multitude by appeal to Spinoza.


Related Articles

  • ECHOES OF THE PAST. Pendergrast, Dell F. // Foreign Service Journal;Jan2008, Vol. 85 Issue 1, p50 

    The article reports on the move of Americans to confirm the preconceptions of Vietnamese about democracy and freedom. It is stated that most Vietnamese did not understand the American's fixation on democracy and nationbuilding. Accordingly, it points out that both in Iraq and Vietnam, Americans...

  • A Populist Specter.  // Wilson Quarterly;Winter2005, Vol. 29 Issue 1, p86 

    Presents views on liberalism. Description of modern liberals; Formation of the democracies of the West; Decline in the appeal of liberals in Europe.

  • DEMOCRACY FOR EVERYONE. Burt, Struthers // Saturday Evening Post;7/30/1932, Vol. 205 Issue 5, p21 

    Reconsiders what the meaning of democracy is. Question of whether U.S. citizens really understand the meaning of democracy; Definition of liberalism; Obligations that any U.S. citizen must assume.

  • Singularity, Community, and Mediation in Antigone. Bush, Randall // Conference Papers -- National Communication Association;2008, p1 

    The tragic figure of Antigone has been crucial for thinking the history not merely of politics and ethics, but of political and ethical paradox. In telling Antigone's response to the disfigurement of her citizen-traitor-brother's body, Sophocles' play exposes these...

  • THE AMERICAN REVOLUTIO, 1939. Lane, Rose Wilder // Saturday Evening Post;1/7/1939, Vol. 211 Issue 28, p23 

    The article offers a view on the evolution of democracy as the guiding principle of every American government. It also presents the history of the American revolution which spans for over sixty years, from which freedom originates. In addition, it gives comparison between liberal and reactionary...

  • ECONOMIC LIBERALIZATION AND INTERNATIONAL ORDER. Tures, John A. // CATO Journal;Winter2004, Vol. 23 Issue 3, p423 

    Examines the link between economic liberty and external conflict. Overview of economic freedom and external conflict reduction; Differences between observations and expectations; Relations between economically free countries and other countries.

  • Beyond the Arab Spring. CRANER, LORNE // Ripon Forum;Spring2011, Vol. 45 Issue 2, p10 

    An essay is presented on how, when, and where the U.S. can plant the seeds of freedom around the world. It mentions that revolts occur in countries for a variety of reasons that challenge all authoritarian governments. The author believes that the U.S. cannot implant democracy in the Middle...

  • Reasons for Democracy. Silvert, Kalman H. // Society;Jan/Feb98, Vol. 35 Issue 2, p176 

    This article discusses the issues concerning the U.S. democracy. The U.S. was the first country to establish a state committed to the ideal of ensuring a free people in a free nation. It can also be the first to realize this vision, the first to transcend the limitations of middle class...

  • INTIMATIONS OF THE DECLINE OF DEMOCRACY. Allan, James // Quadrant Magazine;May2010, Vol. 54 Issue 5, p20 

    The article presents the author's conception regarding the declining condition issue of democracy. The author discusses the significance of democracy to a certain country, where citizens have their utmost freedom. The author connotes the how other countries practiced democracy. Furthermore, the...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics