A Comparison of Cumulus Parameterizations in Idealized Sea-Breeze Simulations

Cohen, Charles
November 2002
Monthly Weather Review;Nov2002, Vol. 130 Issue 11, p2554
Academic Journal
Four cumulus parameterizations in the fifth-generation Pennsylvania State University-National Center for Atmospheric Research (Penn State-NCAR) Mesoscale Model (MM5) are compared in idealized sea-breeze simulations, with the aim of discovering why they work as they do. Compared to simulations of real cases, idealized cases produce simpler results, which can be more easily examined and explained. By determining which features of each parameterization cause them to produce differing results, a basis for improving their formulations and assisting modelers who may design new cumulus parameterizations can be provided. The most realistic results obtained for these simulations are those using the Kain-Fritsch scheme. Rainfall is significantly delayed with the Betts-Miller scheme, due to the method of computing the reference sounding. Another version of this parameterization, which computes the reference sounding differently, produces nearly the same timing and location of deep convection as the Kain-Fritsch scheme, despite the very different physics. In applying the quasi-equilibrium closure, the Grell parameterization uses horizontal and vertical advection to compute the rate of destabilization. In the present simulation, the parameterized updraft is always derived from the top of the mixed layer, where vertical advection predominates over horizontal advection in increasing the moist static energy, instead of from the most unstable layer. By doing this, it evades the question of whether horizontal advection generates instability or merely advects an existing unstable column.


Related Articles

  • An Evaluation of Mass Flux Closures for Diurnal Cycles of Shallow Cumulus. Neggers, R. A. J.; Siebesma, A. P.; Lenderink, G.; Holtslag, A. A. M. // Monthly Weather Review;Nov2004, Vol. 132 Issue 11, p2525 

    Three closure methods for the mass flux at cloud base in shallow cumulus convection are critically examined for the difficult case of a diurnal cycle over land. The closure methods are first evaluated against large-eddy simulations (LESs) by diagnosing all parameters appearing in the closure...

  • An Investigation of the Influence of Latent Heat Release on Cold-Frontal Motion. Reeves, Heather Dawn; Lackmann, Gary M. // Monthly Weather Review;Dec2004, Vol. 132 Issue 12, p2864 

    The effects of condensational heating on cold-frontal translation speed are explored through the use of potential vorticity (PV) diagnostics and model sensitivity experiments. It is hypothesized that condensational heating can lead to faster frontal translation speeds in the presence of vertical...

  • Entrainment and Detrainment in Numerically Simulated Cumulus Congestus Clouds. Part I: General... Carpenter Jr., Richard L.; Droegemeier, Kelvin K. // Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences;12/1/98, Vol. 55 Issue 23, p3417 

    Part I. Studies the mechanisms associated with entrainment and detrainment using a three-dimensional numerical model run at high resolution to simulate cumulus congestus clouds. Prescribed environment; Initiation of the convection; Importance of the turbulent motion introduced into the boundary...

  • Some Bulk Properties of Cumulus Ensembles Simulated by a Cloud-Resolving Model. Part I... Lin, Chichung // Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences;11/1/99, Vol. 56 Issue 21, p3724 

    Deals with the first part of a two-part study on the development of an improved cloud model for use in cumulus parameterization which uses a cloud-resolving model to simulate cloud root properties. Information on the model and the numerical simulations; Analysis of the shallow and deep...

  • Explicit Simulation of Midlatitude Cumulus Ensembles: Comparison with ARM Data. Kuan-Man Xu; Randall, David A. // Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences;9/1/2000, Vol. 57 Issue 17, p2839 

    Deals with a study that described some results from several simulations of cumulus ensembles at the Southern Great Plains site of the Atmospheric Radiation Measurement program during the July 1995 Intensive Observation Period (IOP). Comparison between available observations and tropical...

  • The performance of different cumulus parameterization schemes in simulating the 2006/2007 southern peninsular Malaysia heavy rainfall episodes. ARDIE, WAN; SOW, KHAI; TANGANG, FREDOLIN; HUSSIN, ABDUL; MAHMUD, MASTURA; JUNENG, LIEW // Journal of Earth System Science;Apr2012, Vol. 121 Issue 2, p317 

    The performance of four different cumulus parameterization schemes (CPS) in the Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model for simulating three heavy rainfall episodes over the southern peninsular Malaysia during the winter monsoon of 2006/2007 were examined. The modelled rainfall was compared...

  • Representing the Sensitivity of Convective Cloud Systems to Tropospheric Humidity in General Circulation Models. Del Genio, Anthony // Surveys in Geophysics;Jul2012, Vol. 33 Issue 3/4, p637 

    Convective cloud variability on many times scales can be viewed as having three major components: a suppressed phase of shallow and congestus clouds, a disturbed phase of deep convective clouds, and a mature phase of transition to stratiform upper-level clouds. Cumulus parameterization...

  • Observations and Modeling of the Sea Breeze with the Return Current.  // Monthly Weather Review;May99, Vol. 127 Issue 5, p625 

    Data from a wind profiler are used to investigate the vertical structure of the sea breeze with the accompanying return current at the North Sea coast in the Netherlands for three sea breeze cases. In one of the cases, with a very weak and constant background flow, the return current mass flux...

  • Sensitivity studies of the RegCM3 simulation of summer precipitation, temperature and local wind field in the Caribbean Region. Martínez-Castro, D.; Porfirio da Rocha, R.; Bezanilla-Morlot, A.; Alvarez-Escudero, L.; Reyes-Fernández, J. P.; Silva-Vidal, Y.; Arritt, R. W. // Theoretical & Applied Climatology;2006, Vol. 86 Issue 1-4, p5 

    We present a preliminary evaluation of the performance of three different cumulus parameterization schemes in the ICTP Regional Climate Model RegCM3 for two overlapping domains (termed “big” and “small”) and horizontal resolutions (50 and 25 km) in the Caribbean area...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics