Can it be Ethical to Apply Limited Resources in Low-income Countries to Ineffective, Low-reach Smoking Cessation Strategies? A Reply to Bitton and Eyal

Chapman, Simon; Mackenzie, Ross
April 2012
Public Health Ethics;Apr2012, Vol. 5 Issue 1, p29
Academic Journal
Bitton and Eyal's lengthy critique of our article on unassisted cessation was premised on several straw-man arguments. These are corrected in our reply. It also confused the key concepts of efficacy and effectiveness in assessing the impact of cessation interventions and policies in real-world settings; ignored any consideration of reach (cost, consumer acceptability and accessibility) and failed to consider that clinical cessation interventions which fail more than they succeed also may ‘harm’ smokers by reducing agency. Our article addresses each of these problems, concluding that any consideration of the ethics of promoting smoking cessation in low-income nations should begin and end with the question of whether the strategies to be adopted have any prospect of influencing significant numbers of smokers to quit.


Related Articles

  • Comparison of the Cost-Effectiveness of a High- and a Low-Intensity Smoking Cessation Intervention in Sweden: A Randomized Trial. Nohlert, Eva; Helgason, Ásgeir R.; Tillgren, Per; Tegelberg, Åke; Johansson, Pia // Nicotine & Tobacco Research;Sep2013, Vol. 15 Issue 9, p1519 

    Objective: To assess the relative cost-effectiveness of a high-intensity treatment (HIT) and a low-intensity treatment (LIT) for smoking cessation. Methods: The societal and health care perspective economic evaluation was based on the reported number of quitters at 12-month follow-up (point...

  • Epidemiology of menthol cigarette use in the United States. Caraballo, Ralph S.; Asman, Katherine // Tobacco Induced Diseases;2011 Supplement 1, Vol. 9 Issue Suppl 1, p1 

    Background: Approximately one-fourth of all cigarettes sold in the United States have the descriptor “menthol” on the cigarette pack. It is important to determine what socio-demographic factors are associated with smoking menthol cigarettes if indeed these types of cigarettes are...

  • Predictors of Weight Change in Sedentary Smokers Receiving a Standard Smoking Cessation Intervention. Prod’hom, Sylvain; Locatelli, Isabella; Giraudon, Karine; Marques-Vidal, Pedro; Clair, Carole; Bize, Raphaël; Cornuz, Jacques // Nicotine & Tobacco Research;May2013, Vol. 15 Issue 5, p910 

    Introduction: Quitting smoking is associated with weight gain, which may threaten motivation to engage or sustain a quit attempt. The pattern of weight gained by smokers treated according to smoking cessation guidelines has been poorly described. We aimed to determine the weight gained after...

  • Validation of Content of an Online Knowledge Training Program. Brose, Leonie S.; West, Robert; Michie, Susan; McEwen, Andy // Nicotine & Tobacco Research;May2013, Vol. 15 Issue 5, p997 

    No abstract available.

  • Readiness to Quit Smoking and Quit Attempts Among Australian Mental Health Inpatients. Stockings, Emily; Bowman, Jenny; McElwaine, Kathleen; Baker, Amanda; Terry, Margarett; Clancy, Richard; Bartlem, Kate; Wye, Paula; Bridge, Paula; Knight, Jenny; Wiggers, John // Nicotine & Tobacco Research;May2013, Vol. 15 Issue 5, p942 

    Introduction: Mental health inpatients smoke at higher rates than general population smokers. However, provision of nicotine-dependence treatment in inpatient settings is low, with barriers to the provision of such care including staff views that patients do not want to quit. This paper reports...

  • Effectiveness of Motivational Interviewing in Influencing Smoking Cessation in Pregnant and Postpartum Disadvantaged Women. Hayes, Catherine B.; Collins, Claire; O’Carroll, Helen; Wyse, Emma; Gunning, Miriam; Geary, Michael; Kelleher, Cecily C. // Nicotine & Tobacco Research;May2013, Vol. 15 Issue 5, p969 

    Introduction: Systematic assessments of Motivational Interviewing (MI) in smoking behavior have been rare to date. This study aimed to determine whether an integrated approach, involving staff training in MI techniques, was sufficient to affect change in smoking status or intensity in low-income...

  • Interest in technology-based and traditional smoking cessation programs among adult smokers in Ankara, Turkey.  // Tobacco Induced Diseases;2011, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p10 

    The article presents a research study which measures interest in smoking cessation services among current smokers in Ankara, Turkey. It specifically analyzes interest of smokers in technology-based services. The study concludes that there is an underutilization of low-cost, high-reach,...

  • The Quitting Rollercoaster: How Recent Quitting History Affects Future Cessation Outcomes (Data From the International Tobacco Control 4-Country Cohort Study). Partos, Timea R.; Borland, Ron; Yong, Hua-Hie; Hyland, Andrew; Cummings, K. Michael // Nicotine & Tobacco Research;Sep2013, Vol. 15 Issue 9, p1578 

    Introduction: Most smokers have a history of unsuccessful quit attempts. This study used data from 7 waves (2002–2009) of the International Tobacco Control 4-country cohort study to examine the role of smokers’ quitting history (e.g., recency, length, and number of previous quit...

  • Perceived Partner Responsiveness Predicts Decreases in Smoking During the First Nine Years of Marriage. Derrick, Jaye L.; Leonard, Kenneth E.; Homish, Gregory G. // Nicotine & Tobacco Research;Sep2013, Vol. 15 Issue 9, p1528 

    Introduction: Support for quitting is associated with smoking cessation, but few studies have examined the influence of more general social support on smoking outcomes. The current research examines perceptions of the partner’s willingness and ability to provide general social support...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics