TITLE

Fallibilism and Organizational Research

AUTHOR(S)

Powell, Thomas C.

PUB. DATE

September 2001

SOURCE

Journal of Management Research (09725814);Sep2001, Vol. 1 Issue 4, p201

SOURCE TYPE

Academic Journal

DOC. TYPE

Article

ABSTRACT

Epistemology is the study of knowledge - of what is known and how we know it. Organizational epistemology is dominated by the dualist opposition of objectivist and subjectivist philosophies of science. Objectivists accept knowledge claims as potentially true and warranted on objective evidence, whereas subjectivists ground knowledge in perception, phenomenology and social construction. Though these two perspectives differ in their ontologies (the reality of constructs and relations) and methodologies (how these relations can be observed), both views accept that reliable organizational knowledge is possible. This paper introduces a third epistemological perspective fallibilism - and shows how neglect of this third epistemology has constrained advance in the objectivist-subjectivist debate. Fallibilism, which challenges the foundations and reliability of knowledge claims, occupies a significant place in every major philosophical tradition, but contradicts the prevailing rhetoric of knowledge-claiming in organizational research, and has been systematically excluded from the debate. In this article we present the foundations and precepts of fallibilism, show how its absence has invited divisive and sectarian dogmatism, and explore its potential contributions to organizational research.

ACCESSION #

7313686

Tags: ORGANIZATIONAL research;  SCIENCE

 

Related Articles

• Who Gets Power -- And How They Hold on to It. Salancik, Gerald R.; Pfeffer, Jeffrey // Organizational Dynamics;Winter77, Vol. 5 Issue 3, p3 

  Examines the impact of power on an organization. Significance of power for success; Implication of institutionalization for the administration of power; Effect of political power on the economy.

• Collaborations: do your research! Wallace, Gordon // Chemistry in Australia;Apr2013, p32 

  The article offers information on the need for organizations or individuals to be able to build an effective collaborative resarch activities in order to sustain a competitive position and to have a successful career. It cites several considerations in finding the right collaborative research...

• One Person Organizations as a Resource For Researchers and Practitioners. Katz, Jerome A. // American Journal of Small Business;Winter84, Vol. 8 Issue 3, p24 

  The one person organization has been neglected in much of organizational research. This has occurred despite the one person organization's ubiquity and importance to organizational theory and the workforce. Prior admonishments about the uniqueness of such firms have gone largely unheeded, and...

• The Evolution of the Management Sciences: A Report on the 1988 Survey of TIMS Membership. King, William R.; Grover, Varun; Nelson, Anthony // Interfaces;Nov/Dec89, Vol. 19 Issue 6, p10 

  This article discusses about the evolution in the field of management science as evidenced by the changing profile and habits of The Institute of Management Sciences' (TIMS) members. This paper assess the current status of the field and the organization, also, it evaluates the changes in...

• Corporate Reputation and Scientific Reputation:The Mysterious Case of Girard and Agassiz. Middleton, Stuart; Hanson, Dallas // Corporate Reputation Review;Summer2003, Vol. 6 Issue 2, p147 

  Argues that the construction of reputation in the scientific sphere can prove illustrative for the study of corporate reputation. Background on the case of two individuals in science and its implication on organizational research about corporate reputations; Lessons for academics and business.

• Abstracts.  // Administrative Science Quarterly;Dec56, Vol. 1 Issue 3, p404 

  The article presents a collection of abstracts about administrative science, including a study about absentee-owned corporations and community power structure, a discussion of business leadership in the Southern U.S., and a paper on the concentration of economic power and the economic elite in...

• Metodologia Qualitativa e Quantitativa nos Estudos em Administra��o e Organiza��es: li��es da hist�ria da Ci�ncia. De Benedicto, Samuel Carvalho; De Benedicto, Gideon Carvalho; Stieg, Carlos Maciel; de Andrade, Gustavo Henrique Nogueira // Revista de Ci�ncias da Administra��o;May2011, Vol. 13 Issue 30, p39 

  This work of theoretical nature investigates the contributions of the history of science to the production of scientific knowledge in the field of management and organizational studies. It was found in the study that the theories concerning the management and organizational studies are fallible...

• WHAT YOU SHOULD KNOW ABOUT USING SURVEYS. Aiman-Smith, Lynda; Markham, Stephen K. // Research Technology Management;May/Jun2004, Vol. 47 Issue 3, p12 

  Presents advice on developing and administering surveys. Guidelines for organizational research; Effect of the quality of survey questions on the quality and quantity of responses; Tips for conducting pilot tests and random sampling.

• UK management development lags behind Europe.  // Management Services;Jul2004, Vol. 48 Issue 7, p9 

  The Chartered Management Institute, University of London and the Department of Trade and Industry have launched a two-year study looking at management development across Europe. The study demonstrated that of the seven countries examined, only Romania spends less per capita on development than...

Read the Article