Public Perceptions of Union Efficacy: A Twenty-Four Country Study

Givan, Rebecca Kolins; Hipp, and Lena
March 2012
Labor Studies Journal;Mar2012, Vol. 37 Issue 1, p7
Academic Journal
Since the perceived efficacy of unions is one of the best predictors of an individual’s willingness to vote for or join a union, this article examines the relationship between union membership and perceptions of unions. In particular, we ask: How do union members feel about unions in comparison to nonunion members? How do former union members feel about unions in comparison with those who were never members? How do different groups of workers perceive unions? We answer these questions by analyzing large-scale, cross-national survey data on perceptions of unions. The data contain 14,733 observations in twenty-four countries and are taken from the 2005 wave of the International Social Survey Program (ISSP). The survey asks how respondents feel about the effects of unions on both job security and working conditions. From our analysis, we can conclude that union-membership status (both current and past) and gender matter in determining perceptions of the efficacy of unions. In particular, we find that union members feel more positive about the ability of unions to improve working conditions and job security than nonunion members and that former members tend to be more positive than never union members in these views. We also find that among nonunion members, women tend to hold a more positive view than men of the effect of unions on job security.


Related Articles

  • Once were class warriors? Haynes, Peter // Human Resources Magazine;Dec2004, Vol. 9 Issue 5, p24 

    Reports on the findings of the New Zealand Worker Representation and Participation Survey on union membership by employees. Job satisfaction of employees; Level of demand for union membership; Views on unions in non-union workplaces; Motive of employees for joining unions in a workplace.

  • Support from the Rank and File.  // Time;9/6/1971, Vol. 98 Issue 10, p14 

    The article offers information on a public opinion poll for wage-price freeze which took place in the U.S. in August 1971. It informs that 1,114 persons have polled for this decision of the U.S. president Richard M. Nixon. It tells that labor union members are in favour of wage-price freeze. It...

  • How's Work?  // American Enterprise;Sep2000, Vol. 11 Issue 6, p62 

    Presents the results of an opinion poll conducted in the United States (U.S.) regarding the job satisfaction of workers in the country.

  • Cornell's Empire poll shows workers not satisfied. Spohr, George // Business Journal (Central New York);12/17/2004, Vol. 18 Issue 51, p3 

    The article informs that Cornell University's annual New York State Empire Poll shows that New Yorkers feel that employment is the top problem facing the state. The poll, whose 2004 results were released December 10, says that 45 percent of those surveyed say their current jobs do not adequately...

  • Workers Are Surprisingly Satisfied, Though They Have Their Complaints. Dolliver, Mark // Adweek;9/6/2004, Vol. 45 Issue 33, p36 

    This article focuses on the feelings of the American workers in relation to different aspects of their jobs. The latest edition of a Gallup survey quantifies those feelings by asking people how satisfied (or dissatisfied) they are with different aspects of their jobs. It was found that if one...

  • SNAPSHOT.  // Crain's Cleveland Business;7/11/2005, Vol. 26 Issue 28, p15 

    This article presents the results of a public opinion poll conducted to determine job security in Ohio. Although the workers said that the job market remains tight, nearly 80% of the 1,000 full-time workers surveyed say they do not fear losing their jobs in the coming year. 13% of the workers...

  • High levels of job satisfaction among London's social workers, survey finds. Leason, Katie // Community Care;6/20/2002, Issue 1427, p18 

    Reports on the job satisfaction level of social workers in London, England. Public opinion poll conducted by Unison on the job satisfaction of social workers; Factors that make social workers satisfied in their job; Other findings of the survey.

  • Workplace safety top reason workers join unions.  // Industrial Safety & Hygiene News;Jun2007, Vol. 41 Issue 6, p14 

    The article reports on the major reasons behind the participation of employees to organized labor unions in the U.S. The Employment Law Alliance found that workplace safety tops in the list by garnering a 63% vote among respondents. Forty percent of those polled likewise believe that unions help...

  • What Do the Numbers Say? Krohe Jr., James // Across the Board;Jul/Aug99, Vol. 36 Issue 7, p32 

    Discusses the use of opinion surveys in business management. Employee opinion surveys; Customer-satisfaction surveys; Why surveys will become significant to businesses; Effect of surveys on managers.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics