Are 401(k) Plans Bad for Your Clients' Financial Health?…

August 2002
Journal of Financial Planning;Aug2002, Vol. 15 Issue 8, p25
Academic Journal
This article discusses the conclusions made on whether or not the shift from predominately defined-benefit plans to predominately defined-contribution plans has been good for future retirees. Despite the booming stock market of the 1990s, an increasing percentage of older U.S. citizens are headed toward retirement with smaller net worths than they had 15 years ago, contents a New York University economist, who blames much of the shortfall on the rise of 401(k) plans. Edward Wolff measured U.S. citizens' wealth between 1983 and 1998, and found that over 40 percent of those 47 to 64 will not be able to fund even half of their pre-retirement income, versus only 30 percent in 1989. It is mainly families in the $35,000 to $75,000 range who lost ground. Workers earning $75,000 or more gained ground. Although part of the problem is increasing personal debt, Wolff blames much of the problem on the shift to defined-contribution plans, in part because workers substituted in 401(k) plans money they would have saved anyway if they had had traditional pension plans. Wolff stated that it is a concept that on the surface seemed very attractive, but has really failed workers.


Related Articles

  • Auto-enrollment 'lite' appeals to many employers. Hirschman, Carolyn // Employee Benefit News;Dec2005, Vol. 19 Issue 15, p47 

    The article discusses issues surrounding automatic enrollment of 401(k) plans. According to consultants, automatic enrollment does not make sense for plan sponsors with defined benefit plans, high 401(k) participation rates already, high turnover and those without paternalistic culture. The cost...

  • Notepad.  // NEA Today;May2005, Vol. 23 Issue 8, p11 

    Looks at the disadvantages of the 401(k) retirement plans to public employees in the U.S. based on the results of a study conducted by Hewitt Associates. Scope of the retirement plan; Benefits of defined-benefit pension plans.

  • Largest 401 (k) plan administrators.  // Business Insurance;8/30/2004, Vol. 38 Issue 35, pT10 

    This article focuses on a survey related to 401 (k) plan. Companies must offer 401(k) plan administration services, such as recordkeeping and handling of account activity, on an unbundled basis. It includes both unbundled and bundled 401(k) plans. It reflects staff dedicated to 401(k) plan...

  • Expanded (Contracted?) Vesting Rules. Littell, David A.; Tacchino, Kenn Beam // Journal of Financial Service Professionals;May2007, Vol. 61 Issue 3, p11 

    The article discusses vesting options in pension plans. The author states that vesting schedules are more complex than previously, in part because of changes introduced by the U.S. Congress. Topics considered include salary deferral, plan termination, safe-harbor 401(k) plans, two-year...

  • In retirement services, the right menu is the key. Errett, Amy J. // American Banker;9/15/1995, Vol. 160 Issue 178, p11 

    Opinion. Focuses on acquisition activity in the retirement services industry as banks and nonbank competitors move to transform themselves into full-service providers of 401(k) and defined benefits plans to employers. Banks, discount brokerage houses and mutual fund companies' offer of...

  • The New Defined Benefit/401(k): Two Plans Become One. Caudill, April K. // Journal of Financial Service Professionals;May2007, Vol. 61 Issue 3, p32 

    The article discusses the U.S. Pension Protection Act of 2006 (PPA 2006) and its impact on the 401(k) benefit plan. The author states that PPA 2006 created a new plan design that combines the security of a traditional pension with the market potential of an investment-based account. The design,...

  • If you own a business, it's time to think about tomorrow. Marable, Don // Fort Worth Business Press;8/17/2009, Vol. 24 Issue 30, p19 

    The article looks at possible retirement plan options which small business might consider offering. The owner-only 401(k) is also referred as an individual 401(k) which offers a range of investment options, tax-deductible contributions and tax-deferred earnings growth. Another option is a solo...

  • Future of Pension Plans Looks Dark. Morgan, John // Investment Management Weekly;3/3/2008, Vol. 21 Issue 9, p4 

    The article reports on the importance for employees in the U.S. to manage their funds efficiently through the help of asset managers and fund companies, as more and more companies are retiring the idea of the traditional, defined benefit pension plan in favor of do-it-yourself IRA and 401(k)...

  • Playing hardball on 401(k)s. Hollon, John // Workforce Management;Oct2005, Vol. 84 Issue 11, p58 

    The article focuses on the 401(k) pension plan being offered by aerospace engineering company Lockheed Martin Corp. The company replaced its traditional defined-benefit pension plan with a 401(k) defined-contribution plan for any new and rehired employees who begin work in 2006. Workers are free...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics