An integrated approach for evaluating the effectiveness of landslide risk reduction in unplanned communities in the Caribbean

Holcombe, Elizabeth; Smith, Sarah; Wright, Edmund; Anderson, Malcolm
May 2012
Natural Hazards;May2012, Vol. 61 Issue 2, p351
Academic Journal
Despite the recognition of the need for mitigation approaches to landslide risk in developing countries, the delivery of 'on-the-ground' measures is rarely undertaken. With respect to other 'natural' hazards, it is widely reported that mitigation can pay. However, the lack of such an evidence base in relation to landslides in developing countries hinders advocacy amongst decision makers for expenditure on ex-ante measures. This research addresses these limitations directly by developing and applying an integrated risk assessment and cost-benefit analysis of physical landslide mitigation measures implemented in an unplanned community in the Eastern Caribbean. In order to quantify the level of landslide risk reduction achieved, landslide hazard and vulnerability were modelled (before and after the intervention), and project costs, direct and indirect benefits were monetised. It is shown that the probability of landslide occurrence has been substantially reduced by implementing surface-water drainage measures and that the benefits of the project outweigh the costs by a ratio of 2.7-1. This paper adds to the evidence base that 'mitigation pays' with respect to landslide risk in the most vulnerable communities-thus strengthening the argument for ex-ante measures. This integrated project evaluation methodology should be suitable for adoption as part of the community-based landslide mitigation project cycle, and it is hoped that this resource, and the results of this study, will stimulate further such programmes.


Related Articles

  • Landslide hazard and risk assessment: a case study from the Hlohovec-Sered' landslide area in south-west Slovakia. Bednarik, Martin; Yilmaz, Işık; Marschalko, Marian // Natural Hazards;Dec2012, Vol. 64 Issue 1, p547 

    Landslide hazard or susceptibility assessment is based on the selection of relevant factors which play a role on the slope instability, and it is assumed that landslides will occur at similar conditions to those in the past. The selected statistical method compares parametric maps with the...

  • Susceptibility evaluation and mapping of China’s landslides based on multi-source data. Liu, Chun; Li, Weiyue; Wu, Hangbin; Lu, Ping; Sang, Kai; Sun, Weiwei; Chen, Wen; Hong, Yang; Li, Rongxing // Natural Hazards;Dec2013, Vol. 69 Issue 3, p1477 

    Landslides are occurring more frequently in China under the conditions of extreme rainfall and changing climate, according to News reports. Landslide hazard assessment remains an international focus on disaster prevention and mitigation, and it is an important step for compiling and...

  • Characterization and disaster management of landslides in the Nilgiris mountainous terrain of Tamil Nadu, India. Manimaran, G.; Antony Ravindaran, A.; Selvam, S.; Manimaran, D.; Sugan, M. // International Journal of Geomatics & Geosciences;2012, Vol. 3 Issue 1, p1 

    Steep slope, steep dips of the lithotypes, presence of clay layering in weathered rock types, events of continuous heavy rains, flooding on the slopes and improper land use practices play a major role in the genesis of landslides in the Nilgiris. Recent enhancement in the events of the...

  • Risk evaluation of geological hazards of mountainous tourist area: a case study of Mengshan, China. Peng, Shao-Hui; Wang, Kui // Natural Hazards;Aug2015, Vol. 78 Issue 1, p517 

    Risk evaluation is crucial for the construction projects in the areas with high risk of geological hazards. In this paper, based on the projects of Mengshan tourism area, geological hazard risk evaluation model is put forward based on the analysis of geological and environmental conditions as...

  • Quantitative hazard and risk assessment for slow-moving landslides from Persistent Scatterer Interferometry. Lu, Ping; Catani, Filippo; Tofani, Veronica; Casagli, Nicola // Landslides;Aug2014, Vol. 11 Issue 4, p685 

    Preparation of reliable landslide hazard and risk maps is crucial for hazard mitigation and risk management. In recent years, various approaches have been developed for quantitative assessment of landslide hazard and risk. However, possibly due to the lack of new data, very few of these hazard...

  • Assessing landslide exposure in areas with limited landslide information. Pellicani, Roberta; Van Westen, Cees; Spilotro, Giuseppe // Landslides;Jun2014, Vol. 11 Issue 3, p463 

    Landslide risk assessment is often a difficult task due to the lack of temporal data on landslides and triggering events (frequency), run-out distance, landslide magnitude and vulnerability. The probability of occurrence of landslides is often very difficult to predict, as well as the expected...

  • Comparing Landslide Maps: A Case Study in the Upper Tiber River Basin, Central Italy. Guzzetti, F.; Cardinali, M.; Reichenbach, P.; Carrara, A. // Environmental Management;Mar2000, Vol. 25 Issue 3, p247 

    ABSTRACT / The preparation of landslide maps is an important step in any landslide hazard assessment. Landslides maps are prepared around the world, but little effort is made to assess their reliability, outline their main characteristics, and pinpoint their limitations. In order to redress this...

  • The effects of decentralization on the production and use of risk assessment: insights from landslide management in India and Italy. Sharma, Upasna; Scolobig, Anna; Patt, Anthony // Natural Hazards;Dec2012, Vol. 64 Issue 2, p1357 

    Landslides represent a major threat to human life, property and the environment. Landslide hazard and risk assessments seek to inform the policy and practice of landslide hazard risk management, for example, by identifying high-risk areas so that appropriate policy and private actions could be...

  • Mountain hazards: reducing vulnerability by adapted building design. Holub, Markus; Suda, Jürgen; Fuchs, Sven // Environmental Earth Sciences;Aug2012, Vol. 66 Issue 7, p1853 

    Despite the long tradition of technical mitigation on a catchment scale in European mountain regions, losses due to mountain hazards are still considerably high in number and monetary loss. Therefore, the concept of technical mitigation had been supplemented by land-use planning and, more...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics