Trapped in the Wrong Phraseology: O'Donnabhain v. Commissioner Consequences for Federal Tax Policy and the Transgender Community

Ittelson, Alesdair H.
October 2011
Berkeley Journal of Gender, Law & Justice;2011, Vol. 26 Issue 2, p356
Academic Journal
The U.S. Tax Court's 2010 decision in O'Donnabhain v. Commissioner reinterpret the scope of the medical expense deduction by authorizing the deduction of surgical treatment for Gender Identity Disorder (GID). After explaining the tax framework upon which the 0 'Donnabhain decision rests, this Recent Developments piece describes the decision and examines its consequences for the U.S. federal budget and the medicalization of the transgender community. The author concludes that 0 'Donnabhain will not significantly widen the pool of deductible medical care outside of exual rea signment surgery and hormone therapy. The author applauds 0 'Donnabhain a a victory for those seeking to deduct expenses incurred in the treatment of GID but cautions that the decision may enforce a homogenous, medicalized model of the "ideal" transgender body.


Related Articles

  • U. S. Income Tax Considerations for Parents of 2e Children. Cook, Ellen D. // 2e: Twice-Exceptional Newsletter;May/Jun2012, Issue 52, p12 

    The article discusses the tax strategies that could be employed by parents of twice-exceptional (2e) children in order to save money. It focuses on the medical expense deductions that can be given to taxpayers with 2e children. It cites the learning disabilities (LD) that qualify for medical...

  • How to write off your home improvement costs as medical expenses.  // Small Business Tax Strategies;Jan2010, Vol. 5 Issue 1, p7 

    The article offers tips on how to write off home improvement costs as medical expenses in the U.S. It states that taxpayers should incur cost for the prevention or alleviation of an illness in order to qualify as a deductible medical expense. It also suggests to get a written appraisal from an...

  • Medical Expense Reimbursement Plans...a fringe benefit often overlooked. Busby, Dan // Clergy Journal;Apr2002, Vol. 78 Issue 6, p21 

    Presents information on medical expense reimbursement plans. Details of the barriers to deducting medical expenses; Benefits of a medical reimbursement plan; Relationship of the plan to the compensation package.

  • Hospital Spending Drives Increase in Health Care Costs.  // PT: Magazine of Physical Therapy;Dec2001, Vol. 9 Issue 12, p15 

    Focuses on the increase of health care costs in the United States. Complications of hospital spending on medical care costs; Statistics of the increased cost; Impacts on the premium expenses among health employers.

  • Imagining Seamless Healthcare Transactions. Harris, David; Lutz, Sandy // Journal of Healthcare Management;Jul/Aug2008, Vol. 53 Issue 4, p217 

    The author reflects on the advantage of a seamless healthcare transaction in the U.S. He opines that a seamless healthcare system will take automation, coordination and standards. He offers a method on how to move into a more consumer-friendly transaction procedure. He cites three technology...

  • What health expenses are deductible? Putman, Eileen // Buffalo Law Journal;2/1/2007, Vol. 79 Issue 10, p15 

    The article presents types of health expenses that qualify as tax-deductible medical expenses. Before medical expenses can be deducted, it must exceed 7.5 percent of adjusted gross income. As permitted by either the Internal Revenue Service or the U.S. Tax Court, costs for elastic hosiery,...

  • CHAPTER 11: If You Get Sick: Medical Deductions. Fishman, Stephen // Real Estate Agent's Tax Deduction Guide;12/1/2012, p221 

    The article focuses on how real estate agents in the U.S. can get tax deductions for health insurance and other medical expenses. It is said that real estate agents can get tax deductions for a wide variety of medical expenses that are generally not covered by health insurance, including...

  • Rescue deductions for medical dependents.  // Tax Strategist;Sep2009, Vol. 4 Issue 9, p4 

    The article discusses qualifications on the medical expense tax deduction in the U.S. It notes that in normal condition, those who have an annual adjusted gross income threshold of 7.5% are disqualified for the medical expense tax deduction. However, when a taxpayer makes payments for a...

  • THE SAVVY INVESTOR.  // Best Life;Dec/Jan2007, Vol. 3 Issue 10, p50 

    The article presents the 3 easy ways to cut one's medical expenses. One may open a flexible-spending account. If one's employer offers this, he can fund it with a percentage of his salary and use it for medical expenses that his health insurance plan does not cover, such as eyeglasses or co-pays...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics