TITLE

Global Gun Control: Examining the Consequences of Competing International Norms

AUTHOR(S)

Grillot, Suzette R.

PUB. DATE

October 2011

SOURCE

Global Governance;Oct-Dec2011, Vol. 17 Issue 4, p529

SOURCE TYPE

Academic Journal

DOC. TYPE

Article

ABSTRACT

The global spread and misuse of small arms is one of the most alarming and growing security issues of the post-Cold War era. For many reasons, however, controlling the spread of small arms is extremely difficult. Nonetheless, given the serious nature of the small arms issue, numerous states, nongovernmental organizations, and individual activists have sought to address various small arms problems. One of the earliest suggestions that analysts and advocates offered was to develop international norms and standards of behavior that outline the parameters of acceptable small arms activities. Despite the numerous actions that states and NGO5 have taken over the past ten years in an effort to combat these problems, corresponding norms are relatively weak or nonexistent. This article seeks to answer why this is the case. It examines why global small arms control norms are largely weak or nonexistent and explains why the prospects for stronger norms are few. Although research on norms in international relations is swelling with studies showing whether, how, and why norms emerge and affect state behavior, few studies focus on cases where norms actually do not emerge or influence action. The primary explanation for weak small arms norms is a competitive normative environment that is facilitated and perpetuated by: (1) competing coalitions that promote opposing norms and ideas and (2) a great-power consensus that works against stronger arms control norms.

ACCESSION #

69721843

Tags: GUN control -- International cooperation;  NONGOVERNMENTAL organizations;  FIREARMS -- International cooperation;  PRESSURE groups;  VIOLENCE;  ARMS control -- Research;  INTERNATIONAL relations

 

Related Articles

• A New Call to Arms Control. Falby, Patrick // Newsweek (Pacific Edition);10/15/2007, Vol. 150 Issue 16, p4 

  This article reports on an effort by 100 countries around the world to regulate international trade in small arms. A proposed treaty would ban the sale of these weapons, which include guns and portable grenade launchers, to states with poor human-rights records or to those suspected of using the...

• A New Call to Arms Control. Falby, Patrick // Newsweek (Atlantic Edition);10/15/2007, Vol. 150 Issue 16, p4 

  This article reports on an effort by 100 countries around the world to regulate international trade in small arms. A proposed treaty would ban the sale of these weapons, which include guns and portable grenade launchers, to states with poor human-rights records or to those suspected of using the...

• U.S. POLICY ON SMALL ARMS AND LIGHT WEAPONS. Bondì, Loretta // Naval War College Review;Winter2006, Vol. 59 Issue 1, p119 

  The article focuses on the development of the U.S. policy on controlling proliferation of small arms and light weapons. The impact of the U.S. policy choice on its allies and partners and large sectors of the nongovernmental community. It also looks on how the influence of American interest...

• THE BUSINESS OF PEACE: RAIDING AND PEACE WORK ALONG THE KENYA-UGANDA BORDER (PART I). Eaton, Dave // African Affairs;Jan2008, Vol. 107 Issue 426, p89 

  Peace-building NGOs are frequently at work along the Kenya-Uganda border. But in this desolate region, results have been extremely sparse. This article contends that this is due to the inadequacies of contemporary understandings of cattle raiding. Most NGOs and many academics ascribe cattle...

• Gun control for the world. Lumpe, Lora // Christian Science Monitor;8/30/99, Vol. 91 Issue 192, p9 

  Focuses on the attention needed on the importance of gun control in the United States and in global trade.

• Mixed blessing. Sinnar, Shirin // Harvard International Review;Winter95/96, Vol. 18 Issue 1, p54 

  Examines the growing power of non-governmental organizations (NGOs). Origins of the NGOs; Factors behind the growth of its influence; Impact on weak versus strong states; Peculiar strengths which are behind their theoretical edge over governmental institutions; Potential problems of NGOs.

• A Classification and Communication Network Analysis of the United States Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs) Active in East-Africa. Musambira, George W. // World Communication;1997, Vol. 26 Issue 2, p20 

  Examines the development of non-governmental organizations (NGO) in the U.S. and its relief strategies in three East-African countries. Ability and willingness of NGO to assist the poor countries; Use of communication analysis to distinguish NGO in terms of their development and relief...

• REALITY CHECK.  // Foreign Policy;Jul/Aug2001, Issue 125, p2 

  Introduces a series of articles which deals with nongovernmental organizations and foreign policy.

• About time lobby groups were scrutinised.  // Campaign (UK);8/3/2007, Issue 31, p22 

  The article reports that calls by members of the European Parliament for scrutiny of the lobby groups will be welcomed by the advertising community in Great Britain. The Parliament plans to produce a report on these so-called non-governmental organizations (NGOs) in the autumn of 2007. According...

Read the Article