Orthopaedic Resident and Program Director Opinions of Resident Duty Hours

Mir, Hassan R.; Cannada, Lisa K.; Murray, Jayson N.; Black, Kevin P.; Wolf, Jennifer M.
December 2011
Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;12/7/2011, Vol. 93-A Issue 23, p2239
Academic Journal
Background: The Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) established national guidelines for resident duty hours in July 2003. Following an Institute of Medicine report in December 2008, the ACGME recommended further restrictions on resident duty hours that went into effect in July 2011. We conducted a national survey to assess the opinions of orthopaedic residents and of directors of residency and fellowship programs in the U .S. regarding the 2003 and 2011 ACGME resident duty-hour regulations and the effects of these regulations on resident education and patient care. Methods: A fifteen-item questionnaire was electronically distributed by the Candidate, Resident, and Fellow Committee of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (AAOS) to all U.S. orthopaedic residents (n = 3860) and directors of residency programs (n = 184) and fellowship programs (n = 496) between January and April 2011. Thirty-four percent (1314) of the residents and 27% (185) of the program directors completed the questionnaire. Statistical analyses were performed to detect differences between the responses of residents and program directors and between the responses of junior and senior residents. Results: The responses of orthopaedic residents and program directors differed significantly (p < 0.001) for fourteen of the fifteen survey items. The responses of residents and program directors were divergent for questions regarding the 2003 rules. Overall, 71% of residents thought that the eighty-hour work week was appropriate, whereas only 38% of program directors agreed (p < 0.001). Most program directors (70%) did not think that the 2003 duty-hour rules had improved patient care, whereas only 24% of residents responded in the same way (p < 0.001). The responses of residents and program directors to questions regarding the 2011 duty-hour rules were generally compatible, but the degree to which they perceived the issues was different. Only 18% of residents and 19% of program directors thought that the suggested strategic five-hour evening rest period implemented in July 2011 for on-call residents was appropriate (p > 0.05), and both groups (84% of residents and 74% of program directors) also disagreed with the limitation of intern shifts to sixteen hours (p < 0.001). Seventy percent of residents and 79% of program directors thought that the new duty-hour regulations would result in an increased number of handoffs that would be detrimental to patient care (p < 0.001). The mean responses of junior residents and senior residents differed for eight of the fifteen survey items (p < 0.001), with the responses of senior residents more closely resembling those of program directors on six of these eight questions. The mean responses and percentiles for the survey items did not differ significantly between residency directors and fellowship directors (p > 0.05). Conclusions: This national survey indicated significant differences between the opinions of orthopaedic residents and program (residency and fellowship) directors regarding the 2003 ACGME resident duty-hour regulations and the effects of these regulations on resident education and patient care. However, both residents and program directors agreed that the further reductions in duty hours in the 2011 rules may be detrimental to resident education and patient care.


Related Articles

  • ACGME Accreditation of Orthopaedic Surgery Subspecialty Fellowship Training Programs. Daniels, Alan H.; Grabel, Zachary; DiGiovanni, Christopher W. // Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;6/4/2014, Vol. 96 Issue 11, p1 

    Background: Orthopaedic surgery training in the United States consists of a five-year-minimum orthopaedic surgery residency program, followed by optional subspecialty fellowship training. There is an increasing trend for trainees to complete at least one fellowship program following residency...

  • Assessment of Moral Reasoning Skills in the Orthopaedic Surgery Resident Applicant. Bohm, Kyle C.; Van Heest, Tyler; Gioe, Terence J.; Agel, Julie; Johnson, Todd C.; Van Heest, Ann // Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;9/3/2014, Vol. 96 Issue 17, pe151(1) 

    Background: Assessing orthopaedic surgery residency applicants is a complex process. One important applicant characteristic not commonly measured during the interview process is moral behavior, a key component of the guidelines of the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education for...

  • Residency Training at a Crossroads: Duty-Hour Standards 2010. Volpp, Kevin G.; Friedman, William; Romano, Patrick S.; Rosen, Amy; Silber, Jeffrey H. // Annals of Internal Medicine;12/21/2010, Vol. 153 Issue 12, p826 

    In 2003, the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) implemented a single duty-hour standard nationwide. The evidence to date suggests that this neither improved nor worsened patient outcomes. In June 2010, the ACGME proposed a new set of duty-hour standards for...

  • Addressing Trainees' Concerns through a Resident Advocacy Committee. Weidner, Bryan C.; Dennis, Brad M.; Ayoub, Macram M.; Hutchinson, Marcia B.; Nakayama, Don K. // American Surgeon;Mar2014, Vol. 80 Issue 3, p307 

    The article discusses the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education's (ACGME) annual Residents and Fellows Survey latest results which show a significant problem in the processes in dealing with resident grievances in a confidential and effective manner. It details the Resident...

  • ABOS Certification: The basics. Hurwitz, Shepard R.; Albanese, Stephen // AAOS Now;Apr2011, Vol. 5 Issue 4, p12 

    The article offers information on the process and requirement s for the American Board of Orthopaedic Surgery (ABOS) certification in the U.S. It notes that the ABOS intends to show the public that a Board-certified orthopaedic surgeon has met the standards of education, training, and...

  • U.S. Dermatology Faculty Evaluation by Residents: Results of a National Survey. Linnell, Erica; Nelson, Cheryl; Freeman, Scott R.; Crockett, David; Umstattd, Laura; Dellavalle, Robert P. // Open Dermatology Journal;2008, Vol. 2, p26 

    Although the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) requires regular resident evaluation of faculty, little is known about the process. The program directors of 112 ACGME-accredited dermatology residency programs were mailed a twenty-item survey and asked to return a blank...

  • Accounting for professionalism: an innovative point system to assess resident professionalism. Malakoff, Gary L.; Payne, Catherine L.; Staton, Lisa J.; Kolade, Victor O.; Panda, Mukta // Journal of Community Hospital Internal Medicine Perspectives (JC;2014, Vol. 4 Issue 2, p1 

    Background: Professionalism is a core competency for residency required by the Accreditation Council of Graduate Medical Education. We sought a means to objectively assess professionalism among internal medicine and transitional year residents. Innovation: We established a point system to...

  • Fewer Hours, Fewer Errors? COMMINS, JOHN // HealthLeaders Magazine;Nov2008, Vol. 11 Issue 11, p51 

    The article reports on the implementation of an 80-hour workweek for medical residents by the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) to reduce committing fatigue-related medical errors. "Pediatrics" magazine published a study which reviewed the work habits of 220 residents...

  • Long-term Effects of the 2003 ACGME Resident Duty Hour Reform on Hospital Mortality. Jena, Anupam B.; Prasad, Vinay; Romley, John A. // Mayo Clinic Proceedings;Jul2014, Vol. 89 Issue 7, p1023 

    A letter to the editor about the long-term impact of the 2003 Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) resident duty hour reform on hospital mortality is presented.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics