Forecasting Skill Limits of Nested, Limited-Area Models: A Perfect-Model Approach

de Ela, Ramón; Laprise, René; Denis, Bertrand
August 2002
Monthly Weather Review;Aug2002, Vol. 130 Issue 8, p2006
Academic Journal
The fundamental hypothesis underlying the use of limited-area models (LAMs) is their ability to generate meaningful small-scale features from low-resolution information, provided as initial conditions and at their lateral boundaries by a model or by objective analyses. This hypothesis has never been seriously challenged in spite of some reservations expressed by the scientific community. In order to study this hypothesis, a perfect-model approach is followed. A high-resolution large-domain LAM driven by global analyses is used to generate a “reference run.” These fields are filtered afterward to remove small scales in order to mimic a low-resolution run. The same high-resolution LAM, but in a small-domain grid, is nested within these filtered fields and run for several days. Comparison of both runs over the same region allows for the estimation of the ability of the LAM to regenerate the removed small scales. Results show that the small-domain LAM recreates the right amount of small-scale variability but is incapable of reproducing it with the precision required by a root-mean-square (rms) measure of error. Some success is attained, however, during the first hours of integration. This suggests that LAMs are not very efficient in accurately downscaling information, even in a perfect-model context. On the other hand, when the initial conditions used in the small-domain LAM include the small-scale features that are still absent in the lateral boundary conditions, results improve dramatically. This suggests that lack of high-resolution information in the boundary conditions has a small impact on the performance. Results of this study also show that predictability timescales of different wavelengths exhibit a behavior similar to those of a global autonomous model.


Related Articles

  • The Lorenz-Krishnamurthy slow manifold. Fowler, A.C.; Kember, G. // Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences;5/15/96, Vol. 53 Issue 10, p1433 

    Presents the Lorenz-Krishnamurthy model for the numerical prediction of weather. Five-mode truncation of the rotating shallow-water equations; Perturbation analysis.

  • Reply. Rose, Stanley F.; Hobbs, Peter V.; Locatelli, John D.; Stoelinga, Mark T. // Weather & Forecasting;Apr2003, Vol. 18 Issue 2, p389 

    Replies to an article by Paul M. Markowski on the use of mesoscale model forecasts for forecasting severe weather associated with a cold front aloft (CFA) published in the 2003 issue vol. 18 of the academic journal 'American Meteorological Society.' Initiation of squall-line within a surface...

  • Comments on “Use of a Mesoscale Model to Forecast Severe Weather Associated with a Cold Front Aloft”. Markowski, Paul M. // Weather & Forecasting;Apr2003, Vol. 18 Issue 2, p384 

    Comments on a study entitled 'Use of a Mesoscale Model to Forecast Severe Weather Associated with a Cold Front Aloft,' by Stanley F. Rose, Peter V. Hobbs, John D. Locatelli, and Mark T. Stoelinga published in the 2002 issue of the academic journal 'American Meteorological Society.' Discussion...

  • The Correspondence Ratio in Forecast Evaluation. Stensrud, David J.; Wandishin, Matthew S. // Weather & Forecasting;Oct2000, Vol. 15 Issue 5, p593 

    The correspondence ratio is developed to evaluate output from an ensemble of numerical weather prediction models. This measure is a simple extension of the threat score, or critical success index, to more than two fields and is used to measure the divergence of the forecast fields. The ratio is...

  • Numerical Generation of Entropies. Egger, Joseph // Monthly Weather Review;Sep99, Vol. 127 Issue 9, p1 

    The spurious numerical generation and/or destruction of various types of entropies in models is investigated. It is shown that entropy s[subtheta] of dry matter tends to be generated if potential temperature is advected by a damping scheme. There is no mean tendency of entropy if the...

  • An Alternative Approach to Nonhydrostatic Modeling. Janjic, Z. I.; Gerrity, J. P.; Nickovic, S. // Monthly Weather Review;May2001, Vol. 129 Issue 5, p1164 

    Presents information on an alternative approach to the design of nonhydrostatic numerical weather prediction (NWP) models. Information on hydrostatic NWP models; Description of the alternative approach; Presentation of the nonhydrostatic model equation.

  • Model Consensus. Fritsch, J.M.; Hilliker, J.; Ross, J.; Vislocky, R.L. // Weather & Forecasting;Oct2000, Vol. 15 Issue 5, p571 

    Consensus forecasts from the control runs of several operational numerical models are compared to 1) the control-run forecasts of the individual models that compose the consensus and to 2) other consensus forecasts generated by varying the initial conditions of the various individual models. It...

  • The Use of Quasi-Nonhydrostatic Models for Mesoscale Weather Prediction. MacDonald, A.E.; Lee, J.L. // Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences;8/1/2000, Vol. 57 Issue 15, p2493 

    Presents information on a study on the application of quasi-nonhydrostatic models for mesoscale weather prediction. Methodology of the study; Results and discussion; Conclusions.

  • The hazards of weather watching. KECK, GAIL C. // Kansas Farmer (0022-8583);Jul2016, Vol. 154 Issue 7, p67 

    The article discusses the unpredictability of weather as shown by the unreliable nature of the weather forecasts and tries to explain it by the chaos theory proposed by meteorologist Edward Lorenz in the 1960s, where tiny changes in inputs could lead to forecasting chaos.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics