Exploring implementation and sustainability of models of care: can theory help?

Forster, Della A.; Newton, Michelle; McLachlan, Helen L.; Willis, Karen
January 2011
BMC Public Health;2011 Supplement 5, Vol. 11 Issue Suppl 5, p1
Academic Journal
Objective: Research on new models of care in health service provision is complex, as is the introduction and embedding of such models, and positive research findings are only one factor in whether a new model of care will be implemented. In order to understand why this is the case, research design must not only take account of proposed changes in the clinical encounter, but the organisational context that must sustain and normalise any changed practices. We use two case studies where new models of maternity care were implemented and evaluated via randomised controlled trials (RCTs) to discuss how (or whether) the use of theory might inform implementation and sustainability strategies. The Normalisation Process Model is proposed as a suitable theoretical framework, and a comparison made using the two case studies - one where a theoretical framework was used, the other where it was not. Context and approach: In the maternity sector there is considerable debate about which model of care provides the best outcomes for women, while being sustainable in the organisational setting. We explore why a model of maternity care - team midwifery (where women have a small group of midwives providing their care) - that was implemented and tested in an RCT was not continued after the RCT's conclusion, despite showing the same or better outcomes for women in the intervention group compared with women allocated to usual care. We then discuss the conceptualisation and rationale leading to the use of the 'Normalisation Process Model' as an aid to exploring aspects of implementation of a caseload midwifery model (where women are allocated a primary midwife for their care) that has recently been evaluated by RCT. Discussion: We demonstrate how the Normalisation Process Model was applied in planning of the evaluation phases of the RCT as a means of exploring the implementation of the caseload model of care. We argue that a theoretical understanding of issues related to implementation and sustainability can make a valuable contribution when researching complex interventions in complex settings such as hospitals. Conclusion and implications: Application of a theoretical model in the research of a complex intervention enables a greater understanding of the organisational context into which new models of care are introduced and identification of factors that promote or challenge implementation of these models of care.


Related Articles

  • Standardizing CTA's: International Efforts. Goldfarb, Norman M. // Applied Clinical Trials;Feb2005, Vol. 14 Issue 2, p48 

    This article reports that most pharmaceutical companies place a high priority on reducing their costs to offset pressure on profit margins. Based on drug sale statistics, pharmaceutical companies lose substantial revenue each day a new drug is delayed from reaching the market. Pharmaceutical...

  • When Does Innovative Care Become Clinical Research? Mackintosh, Douglas R.; Molloy, Vernette J. // Applied Clinical Trials;Feb2005, Vol. 14 Issue 2, p59 

    This article examines the overlapping of clinical research by medical care. There are compounds administered to patients, as well as procedures performed on patients that are unapproved, untested, and could in no way be considered the generally accepted standard of care. These therapies are...

  • Is it better to consent to an RCT or to care? Dreyfuss, Didier // Intensive Care Medicine;Mar2005, Vol. 31 Issue 3, p345 

    The article cites that twenty-five years ago the Belmont report established a formal distinction between care and research in order to protect patients. The legitimate fear that research might be conducted under the pretence of medical care regardless of whether this increased the risk to...

  • Infant Orthopedics and Facial Appearance: A Randomized Clinical Trial (Dutchcleft). Prahl, Charlotte; Prahi-Andersen, Birte; Van 't Hof, Martin A.; Kuijpers-Jagtman, Anne M. // Cleft Palate-Craniofacial Journal;Nov2006, Vol. 43 Issue 6, p659 

    Objective: To study the effect of infant orthopedics on facial appearance. Design: Prospective two-arm randomized controlled trial in parallel with three participating academic cleft palate centers. Treatment allocation was concealed and performed by means of a computerized balanced allocation...

  • Clinical trial design in systemic lupus erythematosus: lessons learned and future directions. Strand, V. // Lupus;2004, Vol. 13 Issue 5, p406 

    Designing successful randomized controlled trials (RCTs) in systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) poses many challenges. It remains difficult to correlate alterations in biologic markers with clinical outcome, especially when signs and symptoms are intermittent and broadly variable between...

  • Use of qualitative methods alongside randomised controlled trials of complex healthcare interventions: methodological study. Lewin, Simon; Glenton, Claire; Oxman, Andrew D. // BMJ: British Medical Journal (Overseas & Retired Doctors Edition;9/26/2009, Vol. 339 Issue 7723, p732 

    Objective To examine the use of qualitative approaches alongside randomised trials of complex healthcare interventions. Design Review of randomised controlled trials of interventions to change professional practice or the organisation of care. Data sources Systematic sample of 100 trials...

  • Designing Clinical Research Studies: Part III. Colling, Joyce // Urologic Nursing;Feb2004, Vol. 24 Issue 1, p58 

    Explains measurement issues in conducting clinical studies in medicine and nursing. Aspects of design associated with operationalizing concepts; Types of measurements to consider; Distinctions of measurement categories; Ways of analyzing data.

  • How to make sense of clinical research. Wooten, James M.; Ross, Vicki M. // RN;Jan2005, Vol. 68 Issue 1, p22 

    Provides tips on how to evaluate research studies. Implication of research evaluation on patient care; Importance of statistical terms on research evaluation; Features of randomized controlled trials; Individual components of a research article.

  • Integrating data to facilitate clinical research: a case study. Ackerman, Ilana N.; Osborne, Richard H. // Informatics in Primary Care;Dec2005, Vol. 13 Issue 4, p263 

    The integration of routine clinical administrative activities into ongoing rigorous clinical research poses challenges for both clinicians and researchers. This case study describes the development of a responsive database system used to facilitate comprehensive longitudinal research into the...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics