Generic Hockey-Stick Model for Estimating Benchmark Dose and Potency: Performance Relative To BMDS and Application to Anthraquinone

Bogen, Kenneth T.
April 2011
Dose-Response;2011, Vol. 9 Issue 2, p182
Academic Journal
Benchmark Dose Model software (BMDS), developed by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, involves a growing suite of models and decision rules now widely applied to assess noncancer and cancer risk, yet its statistical performance has never been examined systematically. As typically applied, BMDS also ignores the possibility of reduced risk at low doses ("hormesis"). A simpler, proposed Generic Hockey-Stick (GHS) model also estimates benchmark dose and potency, and additionally characterizes and tests objectively for hormetic trend. Using 100 simulated dichotomous-data sets (5 dose groups, 50 animals/group), sampled from each of seven risk functions, GHS estimators performed about as well or better than BMDS estimators, and a surprising observation was that BMDS mis-specified all of six non-hormetic sampled risk functions most or all of the time. When applied to data on rodent tumors induced by the genotoxic chemical carcinogen anthraquinone (AQ), the GHS model yielded significantly negative estimates of net potency exhibited by the combined rodent data, suggesting that-consistent with the anti-leukemogenic properties of AQ and structurally similar quinones-environmental AQ exposures do not likely increase net cancer risk. In addition to its simplicity and flexibility, the GHS approach offers a unified, consistent approach to quantifying environmental chemical risk.


Related Articles

  • Hormesis in Regulatory Risk Assessment - Science and Science Policy. Gray, George // Dose-Response;2011, Vol. 9 Issue 2, p158 

    This brief commentary will argue that whether hormesis is considered in regulatory risk assessment is a matter less of science than of science policy. I will first discuss the distinction between science and science policy and their roles in regulatory risk assessment. Then I will focus on...

  • US broadens scientific base of controls on carcinogens. Reichhardt, Tony // Nature;4/25/1996, Vol. 380 Issue 6576, p659 

    Reports that the US Environmental Protection Agency unveiled the first revisions to its guidelines for determining human cancer risk. Flexibility in regulating carcinogens; Decision to drop the scheme for classifying cancer hazards by assigning each substance to one of six categories; Weight of...

  • No Evidence of Dioxin Cancer Threshold. Mackie, David; Junfeng Liu; Yeong-Shang Loh; Thomas, Valerie // Environmental Health Perspectives;Jul2003, Vol. 111 Issue 9, p1145 

    The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has developed an estimate of the human cancer risk from dioxin, using the standard low-dose linear extrapolation approach. This estimate has been controversial because of concern that it may overestimate the cancer risk. An alternative approach has...

  • Pesticides benefits.  // Chemical Week;11/12/1997, Vol. 159 Issue 43, p40 

    Focuses on the possible continued use of pesticides that exceeds its cancer risk standard if canceling made by US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) would have severe economic impact. Estimated corn crop loss on the proposed ban of pesticide use.

  • EPA Report Will Reassess Dioxin Risks.  // Chemical Market Reporter;05/22/2000, Vol. 257 Issue 21, p5 

    Reassesses the cancer risks from dioxin exposure, based on a report released by the United States Environmental Protection Agency. Details on the report; Health effects of dioxin.

  • Equivalent Leak Definitions for Smart LDAR (Leak Detection and Repair) When Using Optical Imaging Technology. Epperson, David; Lev-On, Miriam; Taback, Hal; Siegell, Jeffrey; Ritter, Karin // Journal of the Air & Waste Management Association (Air & Waste M;Sep2007, Vol. 57 Issue 9, p1050 

    Controlling fugitive emissions from leaks in petrochemical industry process equipment now requires periodic monitoring of valves, flanges, pumps etc., typically on a quarterly basis. Previous studies have shown that over 90% of the reducible emissions come from approximately 0.1% of the...

  • Derivation of New Emission Factors for Quantification of Mass Emissions When Using Optical Gas Imaging for Detecting Leaks. Lev-On, Miriam; Epperson, David; Siegell, Jeffrey; Ritter, Karin // Journal of the Air & Waste Management Association (Air & Waste M;Sep2007, Vol. 57 Issue 9, p1061 

    This paper describes the development of new "leak/no-leak" emission factors that are suitable for estimating facilities' fugitive emissions when using an alternative work practice (AWP) that is based on optical gas imaging technology for detecting leaking piping system components. These emission...

  • Life cycle greenhouse gas footprint of shale gas: a probabilistic approach. Shahriar, Anjuman; Sadiq, Rehan; Tesfamariam, Solomon // Stochastic Environmental Research & Risk Assessment;Dec2014, Vol. 28 Issue 8, p2185 

    With the increase in natural gas (NG) production in recent years, primarily from shale gas, some sources, including the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), have suggested that upstream methane emissions are increasing. Much of the recent controversy has centered on emissions during well...

  • Local Government Redeveloping Superfund Site.  // Public Management (00333611);Oct99, Vol. 81 Issue 9, pA-3 

    Deals with the redevelopment of the Superfund sites administered by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). Benefits of the sites to nearby communities; Obstacle that have prevented local governments in the decision making process; Details on the controls designed to protect the...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics