A Patient's Tale of Incarceration in a Victorian Lunatic Asylum

March 2011
International Journal of English Studies;2011, Vol. 11 Issue 1, p1
Academic Journal
Using the archival admissions records and the case history of a patient at a British asylum in the 1870s, the author compares two genres. The first of these is two medical certificates written and signed by two physicians attesting that the patient was of unsound mind and needed to be confined and treated. The second genre is the patient's oral testimony to Parliament's Select Committee on Lunacy Laws (1877), a narrative he delivered the year following his release from the asylum. Both genres are legal texts; however, it is the patient's narrative of personal experience, as transcribed in the committee report, that allows the reader a glimpse of the misery imposed by confinement in a "lunatic" asylum. The two medical certificates have considerably more illocutionary force, however; as speech acts they most often resulted in confinement until the patient was determined to have recovered, was transferred to another asylum, or died.


Related Articles

  • My father's madness. Taylor, D. C. // European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry;2002, Vol. 11 Issue 2, p53 

    Presents an article about the definition and interpretation of psychiatric disorder or madness. Terms used to define psychiatric disorders; Ways in which difficult concepts are explored; Story about the madness of adults.

  • Treating the Severely Mentally Ill.  // State Legislatures;Jun2005, Vol. 31 Issue 6, p9 

    Focuses on the results of the implementation of Kendra's law in New York. Provision of the law; Percentage of people with psychiatric disorders under the assisted outpatient program who attempted to commit suicide.

  • Justice for Mentally Ill Prisoners. Meyer, Joseph // Texas Observer: A Journal of Free Voices;Mar2012, Vol. 104 Issue 3, p1 

    The article discusses the laws related to trial and punishment of prisoners suffering from mental illness in the U.S.

  • Compulsory treatment in the community for the mentally ill? Dyer, Claire // British Medical Journal (Clinical Research Edition);10/17/1987, Vol. 295 Issue 6604, p991 

    Focuses on the legislation for the treatment of the mentally ill in Great Britain. Details on the 'long leash' treatment for patients with mental disorders; Proposal made by the Royal College of Psychiatrists on medical treatment outside hospital for mentally ill patients; Response of the...

  • One hundred years ago: The amendment of the lunacy acts.  // British Journal of Psychiatry;May2004, Vol. 184, p455 

    The article focuses on the amendment of the Lunacy acts as a result of an unscientific act of one person in Great Britain. It was Sir John Batty Tuke who volunteered himself to be part of the Lunacy Commission for England and Wales in order to give the extreme inadequacy of such Commission to...

  • A HUNDRED YEARS AGO. Rollin, Henry // British Journal of Psychiatry;Feb90, Vol. 156, p287 

    The article offers insights into Lunacy Act in Great Britain. The author explains the act by illustrating the risks of medical men from lunatics in Bedminster, England. The author notes that there is no reason for a medical man to run the risk under the Lunacy Act. He adds that the Act of 1853,...

  • System Effects of the Kansas Mental Health Reform Act of 1991. Lee, Robert H.; Chamberlain, Ronna; Rapp, Charles // Community Mental Health Journal;Oct2001, Vol. 37 Issue 5, p437 

    Analyzes the impact of the Mental Health Reform Act on the mentally ill in Kansas. Expansion of community support services; Creation of the Community Mental Health Centers for patients with persistent mental illnesses; Changes in financial incentives.

  • Insanity in Bar of Trial in Scotland: A State Hospital Study. Chiswick, Derek // British Journal of Psychiatry;Jun78, Vol. 132, p598 

    Legal findings of unfitness to stand trial are returned ten times more frequently in Scotland than in England and Wales. Sixty-five patients in the State Hospital who had been found insane in bar of trial were compared with a control group of 64 offender patients. They showed a significantly...

  • Insane. CYRIAX, OLIVER // Encyclopedia of Crime;2009, p219 

    An encyclopedia entry for "insane," in relation to crime, is presented. Under the law in Great Britain, a defendant is considered innocent unless he is proven guilty or insane. It is noted that actual insanity results to various consequences, which include making the defendant unfit to make a...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics