A Hockey Night in Canada: An Imagined Conversation between Theorists

Fogel, Curtis
May 2010
Qualitative Report;May2010, Vol. 15 Issue 3, p658
Academic Journal
In this paper, various methodological issues surrounding the sociological study of sport are explored. Through an imagined dialogue between two graduate students at a hockey game, this work brings together three divergent approaches to social enquiry: Positivist Grounded Theory, Constructivist Grounded Theory, and Actor-Network Theory. This paper challenges conventional writing on method in two ways: (a) assembling three divergent approaches within a single work, and (b) employing a scripted narrative as a means of exploring methodological issues. Through this innovative approach, many of the overlaps and tensions between these theories/methods are captured. In so doing, numerous methodological questions about the sociological study of sport, as well social science research more generally are raised.


Related Articles

  • Grounded Theory Method: An Essential Approach to Analyse Design. Lopes, Arminda // Proceedings of the European Conference on Research Methods for B;2010, p275 

    This paper presents an experience using grounded theory method. The intention is to substantiate in a realistic practice how by one hand Grounded Theory Method (GTM) was chosen and how it was used as a method to follow, and conversely, since methodological texts, at the beginning, did not...

  • Beware of Allies! Notes on Analytical Hygiene in Actor-Network Account-making. Passoth, Jan-Hendrik; Rowland, Nicholas J. // Qualitative Sociology;Dec2013, Vol. 36 Issue 4, p465 

    In science and technology studies (STS), reflexivity is not the foremost political or ethical concern that it is for some postmodernists, feminists, anthropologists, or those earnest students of Bourdieu. For us, reflexivity is a practical methodological concern. When reflexivity is raised in...

  • Constructivist Grounded Theory? Glaser, Barney G. // Historical Social Research - Supplement;2007 Supplement 19, Issue 32, p93 

    I refer to and use as scholarly inspiration CHARMAZ's excellent article on constructivist grounded theory as a tool of getting to the fundamental issues on why grounded theory is not constructivist. I show that constructivist data, if it exists at all, is a very very small part of the data that...

  • A Constructive/ist Response to Glaser's "Constructivist Grounded Theory?". Bryant, Antony // Historical Social Research - Supplement;2007 Supplement 19, Issue 32, p106 

    Recent articles on the Grounded Theory Method (GTM) have started to analyze its conceptual and philosophical foundations. In particular it has been argued that the early characterizations by GLASER and STRAUSS exhibit a scientistic and positivist orientation that is no longer tenable. In her...

  • Exposing the Influencing Factors on Software Project Delay with Actor-Network Theory. Ahmedshareef, Zana; Hughes, Robert; Petridis, Miltos // Electronic Journal of Business Research Methods;2014, Vol. 12 Issue 2, p132 

    Managing large software projects through global development teams is a complex undertaking; it involves managing interdependent problems and dynamic situations that are constantly changing. The research and practice bodies of knowledge need to match that complexity if they are to provide...

  • BRUNO LATOUR I „KONIEC" POSTMODERNIZMU. Markiewka, Tomasz Szymon // Diametros: An Online Journal of Philosophy;Sep2012, Issue 33, p101 

    Bruno Latour is one of the key thinkers in actor-network theory. Although his conception is sociological, the author of We Have Never Been Modern takes into consideration theses which are interesting from a philosophical point of view. The aim of the article is to interpret Latour's writings as...

  • An overview of three different approaches to the interpretation of qualitative data. Part 2: practical illustrations. Woods, Leslie; Priest, Helena; Roberts, Paula // Nurse Researcher;2002, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p43 

    Part II. Discusses the essential features and methods inherent within three approaches to the interpretation of qualitative data. Analysis of transcription exemplar on the application of three approaches; Details on the use of grounded theory, qualitative content analysis and narrative...

  • The Relevance of Glaserian and Straussian Grounded Theory Approaches in Researching Human Resource Development. Devadas, Udaya Mohan; Silong, Abu Daud; Ismail, Ismi Arif // International Proceedings of Economics Development & Research;2011, Vol. 11, p348 

    This paper is aimed at researching Human Resource Development via employing the Grounded Theory (GT) approaches. This study, sought to resolve the main question of: how should the alternative GT methodologies be applied in researching the areas of HRD. For this purpose, a focused literature...

  • Building Knowledge -- Developing a Grounded Theory of Knowledge Management for Construction. Graham, Brian; Thomas, Ken // Electronic Journal of Business Research Methods;2008, Vol. 6 Issue 2, p115 

    As part of an on-going doctoral study, a constructivist approach to grounded theory is being used to develop an integrated model of knowledge management (KM) for the leading Irish construction organisations. Using multiple data collection methods; employees in a number of these organisations...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics