Reply to Armour-Garb

Balaguer, Mark
October 2011
Philosophia Mathematica;Oct2011, Vol. 19 Issue 3, p345
Academic Journal
Hermeneutic non-assertivism is a thesis that mathematical fictionalists might want to endorse in responding to a recent objection due to John Burgess. Brad Armour-Garb has argued that hermeneutic non-assertivism is false. A response is given here to Armour-Garb's argument.


Related Articles

  • Understanding and Mathematical Fictionalism†. Armour-Garb, Bradley // Philosophia Mathematica;Oct2011, Vol. 19 Issue 3, p335 

    In a recent paper in this journal, Mark Balaguer develops and defends a new version of mathematical fictionalism, what he calls ‘Hermeneutic non-assertivism’, and responds to some recent objections to mathematical fictionalism that were launched by John Burgess and others.In this...

  • Burgess's ‘Scientific’ Arguments for the Existence of Mathematical Objects. CHARLES, CHIHARA // Philosophia Mathematica;Oct2006, Vol. 14 Issue 3, p318 

    This paper addresses John Burgess's answer to the ‘Benacerraf Problem’: How could we come justifiably to believe anything implying that there are numbers, given that it does not make sense to ascribe location or causal powers to numbers? Burgess responds that we should look at how...

  • The Implausibility of Hermeneutic Non-Assertivism†. Armour-Garb, Bradley // Philosophia Mathematica;Oct2011, Vol. 19 Issue 3, p349 

    In a recent paper, Mark Balaguer has responded to the argument that I launched against Hermeneutic Non-Assertivism, claiming that, as a matter of empirical fact, ‘when typical mathematicians utter mathematical sentences, they are doing something that differs from asserting in a pretty...

  • The Problem is not Mathematics, but Mathematicians: Plato and the Mathematicians Again†. Benson, Hugh H. // Philosophia Mathematica;Jun2012, Vol. 20 Issue 2, p170 

    I argue against a formidable interpretation of Plato’s Divided Line image according to which dianoetic correctly applies the same method as dialectic. The difference between the dianoetic and dialectic sections of the Line is not methodological, but ontological. I maintain that while this...

  • Structuralism and the identity of indiscernibles. Ketland, Jeffrey // Analysis;Oct2006, Vol. 66 Issue 4, p303 

    The article presents a study on mathematical structuralism and the objection raised by John Burgess and Jukka Keränen on mathematical structuralism. Mathematical structuralism states that mathematics is the science of pattern and structure. The objection raised by the two individual focuses...

  • John P. Burgess. Mathematics, Models, and Modality: Selected Philosophical Essays.  // Philosophia Mathematica;Feb2009, Vol. 17 Issue 1, p127 

    The article cites the authors and titles of papers discussed in the book "Mathematics, Models, and Modality: Selected Philosophical Essays," by John P. Burgess.

  • The Burgess-Rosen critique of nominalistic reconstructions. CHIHARA, CHARLES // Philosophia Mathematica;Feb2007, Vol. 15 Issue 1, p54 

    In the final chapter of their book A Subject With No Object, John Burgess and Gideon Rosen raise the question of the value of the nominalistic reconstructions of mathematics that have been put forward in recent years, asking specifically what this body of work is good for. The authors conclude...

  • Egyptian mathematics. Wilson, Robin // Mathematical Intelligencer;Winter99, Vol. 21 Issue 1, p80 

    Focuses on the achievement of early Egyptian mathematicians. Practical skill of measurement; Sources of Egyptian mathematics.

  • De Morgan's Ramanujan: An incident in recovering our endangered cultural memory of mathematics. Muses, C. // Mathematical Intelligencer;Summer98, Vol. 20 Issue 3, p47 

    Focuses on the work and relations of the mathematicians Augustus De Morgan and Ramchundra of India. How De Morgan met Ramchundra; Information on De Morgan and Ramchundra's educational background; Reference to books published by Ramchundra; What De Morgan and Ramchundra contributed to mathematics.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics