Pluralizing Methodologies in the Field of LD: From "What Works" to What Matters

Ferri, Beth A.; Gallagher, Deborah; Connor, David J.
August 2011
Learning Disability Quarterly;Aug2011, Vol. 34 Issue 3, p222
Academic Journal
The field of learning disabilities (LD) has a complex and complicated history. Tensions over definitions, eligibility criteria, service delivery models, and best practices, as well as epistemological debates, have been a part of that history from its inception. Given our collective struggles, as well as the current realities facing the field, there could not be a more critical moment for a conversation about how it is that we go about knowing what we know. In this concluding essay, we consider how, by focusing so intently on what works, we, as a field, may inadvertently lose sight of what matters. In other words, contrary to the push for narrowing what counts as evidence or knowledge, we examine the potential value in opening up the field to a more diverse range of methods for students who struggle academically. We also challenge taken-for-granted assumptions in the push toward evidence- or research-based practice. Finally, we highlight several compelling themes that we take away from the contributors of this special double issue.


Related Articles

  • Teaching Students With Intellectual Disability to Integrate Reading Skills: Effects of Text and Text-Based Lessons. Allor, Jill H.; Gifford, Diane B.; Al Otaiba, Stephanie; Miller, Saralyn J.; Cheatham, Jennifer P. // Remedial & Special Education;Nov2013, Vol. 34 Issue 6, p346 

    This multiple baseline study investigated the effectiveness of text-based reading lessons for students with intellectual disability (ID). Three students were selected who had not responded well to explicit and systematic reading instruction. They were provided with individual instruction in...

  • Analysis of the implementation of a dynamic assessment device of processes involved in reading with learning-disabled children Navarro, Juan-José; Mora, Joaquín // Learning & Individual Differences;Apr2011, Vol. 21 Issue 2, p168 

    Abstract: The renewed interest in the dynamic assessment of specific domains has led to reconsideration of this theory and the technique''s contribution to the learning–teaching process. In this article, we analyze some elements concerning the internal structure of a dynamic assessment...

  • Beyond Talking About Books: Implications of the Reading Comprehension Instruction and Pedagogical Beliefs of a Special Educator Perceived as Effective. Hollenbeck, Amy R. Feiker // Learning Disability Quarterly;May2013, Vol. 36 Issue 2, p112 

    This investigation extends the study of the reading comprehension practices used with students with learning disabilities (LD) via a case study, exploring the beliefs and practices in reading comprehension of “Wendy,” a cross-categorical special educator nominated as effective in her...

  • Research: Children with Dyslexia Can Benefit from FM Hearing Systems.  // Hearing Review;Nov2012, Vol. 19 Issue 12, p58 

    The article reports a study according to which, children with dyslexia can benefit from frequency modulated (FM) hearing systems, which improve a child's auditory processing of sound and give them a better chance to make associations between wheat they hear and what these sounds mean.

  • Responsiveness-to-Intervention: A Decade Later. Fuchs, Lynn S.; Vaughn, Sharon // Journal of Learning Disabilities;May2012, Vol. 45 Issue 3, p195 

    In this introduction to this special issue, “A Decade Later,” we provide an overview of the accomplishments as well as the persistent questions surrounding RTI. We organize this discussion within 3 categories: assessment, instruction, and policy. Within each of these sections, we...

  • The Effects of Using Reading Racetracks for Teaching of Sight Words to Three Third-Grade Students with Learning Disorders. McGrath, Gregory L.; McLaughlin, T. F.; Mark Derby, K.; Bucknell, Wendy // Educational Research Quarterly;Mar2012, Vol. 35 Issue 3, p50 

    The purpose of the study was to evaluate the effectiveness of reading racetracks with three 8 year-old students with learning disabilities. All. three children were performing well below grade level in reading. A single subject reversal design was used to evaluate the effects of employing...

  • Editors’ Note. Bryant, Brian R.; Bryant, Diane Pedrotty // Learning Disability Quarterly;May2013, Vol. 36 Issue 2, p67 

    An introduction is presented in which the editor discusses various reports within the issue on topics including mathematics, learning disabilities identification, and reading.

  • In knowing our students ourselves. Jackman, Jessica A. // Journal of Learning Disabilities;Nov1995, Vol. 28 Issue 9, p566 

    Describes the relationship between a middle school student teacher and one of her students with learning handicaps. Series of interviews and observations that enabled teacher to identify student's needs; Student's feeling about reading; Formation of working relationship with student.

  • Rethinking Instructional Delivery for Diverse Student Populations: Serving All Learners with Concept-Based Instruction. McCoy, Jan D.; Ketterlin-Geller, R. // Intervention in School & Clinic;Nov2004, Vol. 40 Issue 2, p88 

    When students arrive at content classes reading below grade level, teachers are challenged to deliver complex content. Also, students often study facts without reaching larger concepts. Research at the University of Oregon has concluded that if the teacher takes responsibility for identifying...

  • Meaningful Sex Education Programs for Individuals with Intellectual/Developmental Disabilities. Swango-Wilson, Amy // Sexuality & Disability;Jun2011, Vol. 29 Issue 2, p113 

    Individuals with an intellectual or developmental disability (ID/DD) may not have had the experiences to develop social skills for long term relationships. While society has denied the sexuality of these individuals, the individuals have identified their desire for intimate relationships. The...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics