Normativity II -- Towards an Integral Perspective

Strauss, Danie F. M.
August 2011
South African Journal of Philosophy;2011, Vol. 30 Issue 3, p360
Academic Journal
This is a follow-up article of Strauss 2011. In order to transcend the shortcomings present in the dialectical legacy regarding normativity, this article further explores key elements within the dialectical tradition focused on the basic motive of nature and freedom and the effect it had on modern social contract theories which aimed at reconstructing human society from its "atoms," the individuals. The transition to an alternative approach commences with a discussion of the distinction between conditions and what is conditioned. It concerns a correlation found within all aspects of reality, namely that between the law side or norm side on the one hand and the factual side on the other. The basic assumption of this alternative view is found in the idea of ontic normativity which is rooted in a non-reductionist ontology. Against this broader background shortcomings in Kelsen's theory of law are briefly traced to the dialectic of the causal and non-causal, before a positive characterization of the concept of a principle is given. It turned out that it is a compound basic concept in which terms from different modal aspects of reality are encapsulated at once. The recognition of ontic normativity therefore also enables a distinct methodology, the transcendental-empirical method, which makes it possible to distinguish between the pre-positive nature of a principle, as a universal and constant starting-point for human action, and the historically varying ways in which such a principle can be made valid, (enforced) through a competent organ disposing over an accountable will and capable to interpret the unique historical circumstances in which the principle has to be positivized (given a positive form or shape). The nature of modal norms is highlighted in terms of various examples, such as jural, historical, logical and aesthetic principles, with special reference to Derrida's understanding of credit as economic trust or economic faith. In order to make this transcendental-empirical method understandable a more detailed account of the nature of modal aspects is given. The emphasis on ontic normativity also helps us to steer clear of conceptions of natural law, historicism and the shortcomings present in the idea of a social construction of the world. The guiding perspective flowing from this analysis is that modal norms can be articulated through an analysis of analogical structural moments on the law sides of the normative aspects. The last part of this article briefly introduces the distinction between modal and typical norms without entering into a discussion of the latter.


Related Articles

  • Thoughtprints. Berger, Anne E.; Segarra, Marta // International Ford Madox Ford Studies;2011, Vol. 10, p3 

    An introduction is presented in which the editor discusses the distinction between animality and humanity mentioning Jacques Derrida's writing entitled "The Animal That Therefore I Am."

  • Determining the Undetermined: Derrida's "University Without Condition." Terdiman, Richard // Eighteenth-Century Studies;Spring2007, Vol. 40 Issue 3, p425 

    This article delves into the Enlightenment conception of the university-to-come projected by Jacques Derrida in the context of his essay "The University Without Condition." Derrida's evaluation on his work covers Enlightenment anticipations related to intellectual and critical freedom. An...

  • Who Follows Whom? Derrida, Animals and Women. Guenther, Lisa // Derrida Today;Nov2009, Vol. 2 Issue 2, p151 

    In ‘L'Animal que donc je suis’, Derrida analyzes the paradoxical use of discourses on shame and original sin to justify the human domination of other animals. In the absence of any absolute criterion for distinguishing between humans and other animals, human faultiness becomes a...

  • Democracy and Critique: Recovering Freedom in Nancy and Derrida. Mules, Warwick // Derrida Today;May2010, Vol. 3 Issue 1, p92 

    In this paper, I argue that we need to re-address the issue of freedom as it relates to democracy and critical practice. My argument is drawn out of Derrida's deconstructive reading of Jean-Luc Nancy's The Experience of Freedom which proposes freedom in ontological terms as an experience of...

  • Of DikÄ“ and Death: The Role of Schelling in Adjudicating between Heidegger and Derrida on Justice. Spicer, Kevin A. // Philament: an online journal of the arts & culture;Nov2012, Issue 18, p48 

    The article analyzes philosopher Jacques Derrida's "Specters of Marx" and Martin Heidegger's literature "Schelling's Treatise on the Essence of Human Freedom." Topics discussed include difference between literature of Heidegger and Derrida, critical appraisals on relationship of Schelling and...

  • ON THE MARGINS OF POLITICS. McCARTHY, THOMAS A. // Journal of Philosophy;Nov1988, Vol. 85 Issue 11, p645 

    The article offers information on the concerns raised by French philosopher Jacques Derrida on Heideggerian and Levinasian themes according to postmetaphysical ethics, politics and law. It mentions the shared interpretations and expectations about the correlations of the different elements....

  • Tierphilosophie, Tiertheorie und die teleosemantische Differenz. Borgards, Roland // Erwägen Wissen Ethik;2012, Vol. 23 Issue 1, p41 

    The article presents a response to an animal philosophy study by theoretical philosopher Markus Wild, whose teleosemantic approach to the topic is examined by the author. Note is taken of related theories by philosophers Giorgio Agamben, Jacques Derrida, and Donna Haraway. Further attention is...

  • New Jacques city.  // New York;10/20/97, Vol. 30 Issue 40, p15 

    Describes the various symposiums being held by Jacques Derrida in New York City, New York as he reigns king of literary deconstruction. His packed lecture at New York University; The sold out discussion at Cooper Union; His delayed arrival at the New School for Social research because of poor...

  • Doctor deconstructo.  // Newsweek;5/25/1992, Vol. 119 Issue 21, p42 

    Describes the controversy surrounding Cambridge University's decision to award literary critic Jacques Derrida an honorary doctorate. Cambridge philosopher Hugh Mellor's assertion that Derrida `has to write more and more obscurely to disguise the fact that he has nothing to say'; Tenets of...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics