TITLE

THE TRANSFORMATION OF THE UNDERSTANDING OF JUDGE INDEPENDENCE IN LATVIA

AUTHOR(S)
Neimanis, Janis
PUB. DATE
January 2011
SOURCE
European Integration Studies;2011, Issue 5, p79
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
Latvian people's craving for freedom culminated in the beginning of 1990-s. The activity of the Constitution of the Republic of Latvia was renewed, and the state power was returned to the people. From this moment, the work on dismantling the Soviet legal system in Latvia had started. A legal system had been redirected to the principles of the Western legal branch. The hard core of these principles was already in the Article 1 of the 1920 Constitution of there public of Latvia which states that Latvia is an independent and democratic republic. A key element of a democratic state is of a legal state. The division of powers, which is an essential element of a judge's independence, is in force in a legal state. Up to 2009 the judge's independence was based on the understanding of the institutional independence, when the other branches of state power must not sit as a court, and on the understanding of the personal independence, when the pressure to the judge is not acceptable during the administration of justice. Only after the complication of the financial situation, there were also highlighted other elements of the judge's independence principle, including financial security. Separate present cases in society, these together produce a variety of problems understanding the judge's independence principle. It is positively characterized, that by expanding cooperation with foreign judges, the independence of Latvian judges' self-consciousness is increasing. But these are not just demands for greater freedom. Currently, the Latvian legal system has identified several problems: 1) the admissibility of the judges participating in discussions with other government representatives, 2) the stability of judges' salaries, 3) the judges' progress in their careers, 4) the best model for evaluating judges' professional qualifications, 4) the need of judges' administrative immunity; 5) the need of the Honour Judge Institute. The decisions of the Constitutional Court had a great impact on the understanding the content of the judge's independence principle. The Constitutional Court at least in six cases has extended the judge's independence principle, have given its clarification and the methodology of application. However, in practice, the main obstacles achieving the optimal model of freedom are not the rules of law. During economic problems the public do not attach importance to nuances of a freedom's narrow aspect in the constitutional model. The public psychological portrait has not significantly changed during 20 years. Soviet people's fears and worry, lack of understanding the activity of state's democratic elements make it difficult to improve the democratic state's legal system. In addition it should be noted that the judiciary and the executive and the legislative powers are unable to negotiate with each other. Therefore, during the next few years the provisions of international rules and the arguments of the constitutional court's decisions will, however, remain as implementation tools for the judge's independence principle.
ACCESSION #
65315745

 

Related Articles

  • Judicial independence and corruption. Susan Rose-Ackerman // Global Corruption Report;2007, p15 

    The article discusses the importance of judiciary independence from the rest of the state and private sector as an effective anti-corruption tool. It is stated that independence implies that judges' careers do not depend on pleasing those with political and economic power. The separation of...

  • THE ROAD PAVED WITH GRAVEL: THE ENCROACHMENT OF SOUTH CAROLINA'S JUDICIARY THROUGH LEGISLATIVE JUDICIAL ELECTIONS. Wilder, Samantha R. // South Carolina Law Review;Summer2014, Vol. 65 Issue 4, p639 

    The article focuses on the importance of judicial independence and its development through trial and happenstance in the U.S. and the pervasive method of judicial selection in state governments. It outlines the South Carolina's judicial election system and the accountability mechanisms for the...

  • Die Leitungsstrukturen der Justiz im Bund und in ausgewählten Kantonen — Eine Studie im Spannungsfeld von Führung und verfassungsrechtlichen Prinzipien. Keel, Madeleine // University of St. Gallen, Business Dissertations;5/20/2014, p1 

    The present thesis covers the governmental structures of judiciary in Switzerland. First, judiciary in Switzerland is subject to the analysis. Subsequently, part two examines the constitutional embedment of judiciary in Switzerland, i.e. the structural principles and the procedural guarantees....

  • A PATH TO PURPOSIVE FORMALISM: INTERPRETING CHAPTER III FOR JUDICIAL INDEPENDENCE AND IMPARTIALITY. WELSH, REBECCA // Monash University Law Review;2013, Vol. 39 Issue 1, p66 

    The article discusses concerns related to interpretation of the separation of federal judicial power and also investigates which method of interpreting Chapter III of the Constitution best achieves judicial independence and impartiality. It examines functionalist test to identify whether a power...

  • Safeguarding the Independence and Impartiality of the Cambodian Extraordinary Chambers. Linton, Suzannah // Journal of International Criminal Justice;May2006, Vol. 4 Issue 2, p327 

    The article focuses on one limited but vexed issue — how to safeguard judicial independence and impartiality in the Cambodian Extraordinary Chambers (CEC). The author addresses some of the most problematic issues that she anticipates could diminish or hamper the possibility for judicial...

  • EL CONTROL CONSTITUCIONAL DE LA JUSTICIA ESPAÑOLA. GRANDA ALONSO, JOSÉ LUIS // Revista de Derecho UNED;2015, Issue 16, p383 

    The values of the Justice are like the engine of a car. If the design of the engine is correct the Justice works right. Anyway, if the engine of the car is not well built it will happen breakdowns that will make them difficult to good circulation. From this point of view, the spanish Justice has...

  • A View from Kenya. Ang'awa, Mary A. // Human Rights;Winter2009, Vol. 36 Issue 1, p23 

    The article focuses on the functionality of judicial independence in Kenya. As evident by the lack of confidence among those who lost in the elections of December 2007, judicial independence has little significance in the nation. As cited, although the Kenyan judiciary is based on the British...

  • Separation of powers in Niger. Abdoulaye, Judge Djibo // Global Corruption Report;2007, p239 

    The article focuses on the separation of powers in Nigeria. Under the constitution of the country, the judiciary is independent of the legislature and the executive. It provides that judges act independently in exercising their duties and are subject only to the authority of the law. It is a...

  • Electing judges and the impact on judicial independence. Shepard, Randall T. // Tennessee Bar Journal;Jun2006, Vol. 42 Issue 6, p22 

    The article discusses the impact of the incoming judicial elections on the legal concept of judicial independence. Judicial independence means that judges are mandated to decide cases fairly and impartially, relying only on the facts and the law. Concomitantly, the author has emphasized how...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of THE LIBRARY OF VIRGINIA

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics