Contributions and challenges of cross-national comparative research in migration, ethnicity and health: insights from a preliminary study of maternal health in Germany, Canada and the UK

Salway, Sarah M.; Higginbottom, Gina; Reime, Birgit; Bharj, Kuldip K.; Chowbey, Punita; Foster, Caroline; Friedrich, Jule; Gerrish, Kate; Mumtaz, Zubia; O'Brien, Beverley
January 2011
BMC Public Health;2011, Vol. 11 Issue 1, p514
Academic Journal
Background: Public health researchers are increasingly encouraged to establish international collaborations and to undertake cross-national comparative studies. To-date relatively few such studies have addressed migration, ethnicity and health, but their number is growing. While it is clear that divergent approaches to such comparative research are emerging, public health researchers have not so far given considered attention to the opportunities and challenges presented by such work. This paper contributes to this debate by drawing on the experience of a recent study focused on maternal health in Canada, Germany and the UK. Discussion: The paper highlights various ways in which cross-national comparative research can potentially enhance the rigour and utility of research into migration, ethnicity and health, including by: forcing researchers to engage in both ideological and methodological critical reflexivity; raising awareness of the socially and historically embedded nature of concepts, methods and generated 'knowledge'; increasing appreciation of the need to situate analyses of health within the wider socio-political setting; helping researchers (and research users) to see familiar issues from new perspectives and find innovative solutions; encouraging researchers to move beyond fixed 'groups' and 'categories' to look at processes of identification, inclusion and exclusion; promoting a multi-level analysis of local, national and global influences on migrant/minority health; and enabling conceptual and methodological development through the exchange of ideas and experience between diverse research teams. At the same time, the paper alerts researchers to potential downsides, including: significant challenges to developing conceptual frameworks that are meaningful across contexts; a tendency to reify concepts and essentialise migrant/ minority 'groups' in an effort to harmonize across countries; a danger that analyses are superficial, being restricted to independent country descriptions rather than generating integrated insights; difficulties of balancing the need for meaningful findings at country level and more holistic products; and increased logistical complexity and costs. Summary: In view of these pros and cons, the paper encourages researchers to reflect more on the rationale for, feasibility and likely contribution of proposed cross-national comparative research that engages with migration, ethnicity and health and suggests some principles that could support such reflection.


Related Articles

  • ETHNICITY AND IMMIGRATION IN YUGOSLAVIA. Sharp, Samuel L. // Studies in Comparative International Development;Fall75, Vol. 10 Issue 3, p63 

    Deals with ethnicity and migration in Yugoslavia. Types of migration within and from the country; Significant event that reflected ethnicity in the country; Migration rate in Yugoslavia.

  • ETHNICITY IN MIGRATION. ROMANIAN IMMIGRANTS AT HOME AND ABROAD. CULIC, IRINA; ANGHEL, REMUS GABRIEL // Studia Universitatis Babes-Bolyai, Sociologia;Dec2012, Vol. 57 Issue 2, p3 

    An introduction is presented in which the editor discusses various reports within the issue on topics including the role of ethnicity in migration, the use of ethnic identity in comparative political science, and the remaking of ethnicity through international migration.

  • To Live and Let Live in South Los Angeles. Ciria-Cruz, Rene P. // NACLA Report on the Americas;May/Jun2007, Vol. 40 Issue 3, p37 

    An excerpt from the article "To Live and Let Live in South Los Angeles," by Rene P. Ciria-Cruz, about the relations between African Americans and Hispanic Americans in south Los Angeles, California in line with the immigration problem in the U.S., which originally appeared on the Web site of New...

  • Arguments within geographies of movement: the theoretical potential of migrants’ stories. Lawson, V.A. // Progress in Human Geography;Jun2000, Vol. 24 Issue 2, p173 

    Abstract: In this article, I engage the ways in which migrants’ experiences are socially constructed and situated in particular political-economic and cultural contexts in meaningful ways. Drawing on migrants’ own stories, I examine the ways in which social relations of gender and...

  • A different sort of welcome.  // Wilson Quarterly;Spring92, Vol. 16 Issue 2, p131 

    Comments on the article `Immigration and Group Relations in France and America,' by Donald L. Horowitz, as discussed in the January 1992 issue of `The Bulletin of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences.' Mass immigration to France since the 19th century; Exaltation of ethnicity.

  • Impact of Immigration on Ethnic Identity and Leisure Behavior on Adolescent Immigrants from Korea, Mexico and Poland. Stodolska, Monika; Yi, Jouyeon // Journal of Leisure Research;2003 1st Quarter, Vol. 35 Issue 1, p49 

    Deals with a study which investigated the impact of immigration on the emergence of ethnic identity as well as post immigration changes in leisure behavior. Method; Results; Discussion; Conclusions.

  • Counseling a Hispanic/ Latino Client- Mr. X. Delgado-Romero, Edward A. // Journal of Mental Health Counseling;Jul2001, Vol. 23 Issue 3, p207 

    The author responds to the case scenario of Mr. X assuming that Mr. X is Hispanic/Latino. Factors important in counseling Hispanic/Latino clients are reviewed. The following models of racial and/or ethnic identity are reviewed: Racial/Cultural Identity Development model, (R/CID; Sue & Sue,...

  • The Baltic Sea southern coast and the interior. Selected problems. Błażejewski, Artur // Archaeologia Lituana;2014, Vol. 15, p65 

    No abstract available.

  • Migration, Ethnicity, Race, and Health in Multicultural Societies - Second edition. Ryan, Bridget // Nursing Standard;2/19/2014, Vol. 28 Issue 25, p32 

    No abstract available.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics