Words matter: a qualitative investigation of which weight status terms are acceptable and motivate weight loss when used by health professionals

Gray, Cindy M.; Hunt, Kate; Lorimer, Karen; Anderson, Annie S.; Benzeval, Michaela; Wyke, Sally
January 2011
BMC Public Health;2011, Vol. 11 Issue 1, p513
Academic Journal
Background: Health professionals have an important role to play in the management of obesity, but may be unsure how to raise weight issues with patients. The societal stigma associated with excess weight means that weight status terms may be misunderstood, cause offence and risk upsetting patient-professional relationships. This study investigated the views of people who were overweight or obese on the acceptability of weight status terms and their potential to motivate weight loss when used by health professionals. Methods: A qualitative study comprising 34 semi-structured interviews with men and women in their mid-to-late 30s and 50s who were overweight or obese and had recently been informed of their weight status. Thematic framework analysis was conducted to allow the systematic comparison of views by age, gender and apparent motivation to lose weight. Results: Although many people favoured 'Overweight' to describe their weight status, there were doubts about its effectiveness to motivate weight loss. Terms including 'BMI' ('Body Mass Index') or referring to the unhealthy nature of their weight were generally considered acceptable and motivational, although a number of men questioned the validity of BMI as an indicator of excess weight. Participants, particularly women, felt that health professionals should avoid using 'Fat'. Whilst response to 'Obese' was largely negative, people recognised that it could be appropriate in a health consultation. Some younger people, particularly those who appeared motivated to lose weight, felt 'Obese' could encourage weight loss, but it was also clear the term could provoke negative emotions if used insensitively. Conclusions: Although most people who are overweight or obese accept that it is appropriate for health professionals to discuss weight issues with patients, there is great variation in response to the terms commonly used to describe excess weight. There is no one-size-fits-all approach to discussing weight status: some men and younger people may appreciate a direct approach, whilst others need to be treated more sensitively. It is therefore important that health professionals use their knowledge and understanding to select the terms that are most likely to be acceptable, but at the same time have most potential to motivate each individual patient.


Related Articles

  • Cardiac Strain between Normal Weight and Overweight Workers in Hot/Humid Weather in the Persian Gulf. Dehghan, Habibollah; Mortazavi, Seyed Bagher; Jafari, Mohammad Javad; Maracy, Mohammad Reza // International Journal of Preventive Medicine;Oct2013, Vol. 4 Issue 10, p1147 

    Background: In hot weather, overweight and obesity are considered as significant risk factors for the incidence of cardiac strain in workers. This study was aimed to compare cardiac strain among overweight and normal weight workers in hot, humid conditions in the south of Iran. Methods: This...

  • Resistin concentrations before and after weight loss in obese children. Reinehr, T.; Roth, C. L.; Menke, T.; Andler, W. // International Journal of Obesity;Feb2006, Vol. 30 Issue 2, p297 

    Objective:The influences of gender, puberty, and obesity on resistin levels and the longitudinal relationships between insulin resistance, weight loss, and resistin have not yet been studied in childhood.Methods:Age, pubertal stage, gender, weight status (standard deviation score-body mass index...

  • Re-thinking 'the obesity problem'. Colls, Rachel; Evans, Bethan // Primary Geographer;Jul2010, Vol. 95 Issue 2, p99 

    In recent times the 'obesity problem' has become a key public health concern in Britain. As a consequence a range of policy initiatives have been put in place in order to treat obese bodies and to halt and prevent any increase in obesity rates. Situated within recent work in geography on health...

  • Independent Nurse: Clinical - Obesity - When surgery can be an option for obesity. Haslam, David // GP: General Practitioner;2/17/2006, p103 

    The article presents information related to the treatment of obesity. The last resort for those unable to lose weight is surgery. Type-2 diabetes alone is around 100 times more likely in morbidly obese patients. Surgery is approved by NICE for patients with a body mass index of 40, or 35 with...

  • The talent study: a multicentre randomized controlled trial assessing the impact of a 'tailored lifestyle self-management intervention' (talent) on weight reduction. Doerfler, Wolfgang; Eustachi, Axel; Wellenhofer-Li, Yanqing; Weidenhammer, Wolfgang; Melchart, Dieter // BMC Obesity;10/2/2015, Vol. 2 Issue 1, p1 

    Background: Overweight is considered an important risk factor for diseases in the context of metabolic syndrome. Lifestyle modifications are the means of choice to reduce weight in persons with a Body Mass Index of 28 to 35. The study examines whether there are any differences between two...

  • Manejo de la vía aérea en pacientes llevados a cirugía bariátrica en el Hospital Universitario de San Ignacio, Bogotá, Colombia. Gempeler, Fritz E.; Díaz, Lorena; Sarmiento, Lina // Colombian Journal of Anesthesiology / Revista Colombiana de Anes;May-Jul2012, Vol. 40 Issue 2, p119 

    Introduction: Obesity has increased in the past few years, more so for the morbidly obese; in whom comorbilities that complicate the perioperative anaesthetic and airway management have been identified. The pre-anaesthetic assessment of the patient includes parameters of physical examination and...

  • Ä°lköğretim öğrencilerinde obezite prevalansı ve iliÅŸkili risk faktörleri. Öztürk, Ahmet; Aktürk, Saliha // TAF Preventive Medicine Bulletin;Jan/Feb2011, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p53 

    AIM: To determine the prevalence of obesity and to determine associated risk factors in school-aged children in Kayseri Province, Turkey. METHOD: This is a nested case-control study which conducted in two phases. First phase was carried out on 1226 students at four primary schools in the city...

  • The World's 10 Fattest Countries.  // AirGuide Online.com;12/21/2009, p4 

    The article reports on the 10 countries worldwide that have the most increasing rate of obesity. These include China, Europe, and the U.S. It notes that waistlines of various individual in those countries are expanding so rapidly that health experts recently coined a term for the epidemic,...

  • The implementation of the Counterweight Programme in Scotland, UK.  // Family Practice;Jan2012 Supplement 1, Vol. 29 Issue suppl_1, pi139 

    Background. The Counterweight Programme is a proven model for the management of obesity in the UK, evaluated over 5 years (2000–05) and demonstrating clinical and cost effectiveness. The Scottish Government commissioned three phases of Counterweight implementation during the period...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics