Breakdowns in Implementing Models of Organization Change

Van de Ven, Andrew H.; Sun, Kangyong
August 2011
Academy of Management Perspectives;Aug2011, Vol. 25 Issue 3, p58
Academic Journal
Practice theories of implementing change are lagging behind process theories of organizational change and development. To address this gap, this paper examines common breakdowns in implementing four process models of organization change: teleology (planned change), life cycle (regulated change), dialectics (conflictive change), and evolution (competitive change). Change agents typically respond to these breakdowns by taking actions to correct people and organizational processes so they conform to their model of change. Although this strategy commands most of the attention in the literature, we argue that in many situations managers and scholars might do better if they reflected on and revised their mental model to fit the change journey that is unfolding in their organization.


Related Articles

  • Management Theory for Small Business: Attempts and Requirements. d;Amboise, GĂ©rald; Muldowney, Marie // Academy of Management Review;Apr88, Vol. 13 Issue 2, p226 

    This paper examines the attempts that have been made to develop theories of small business management. The discussion of various contributions is structured according to task environment, organizational configuration, managerial characteristics, success-failure issues, and growth issues....

  • An Introduction to Organizational Design. McCaskey, Michael B. // California Management Review;Winter74, Vol. 17 Issue 2, p13 

    In this synthesis of key concepts and findings from research on the design of organizations, the complex trade-offs involved in designing the structures and processes of an organization are examined from the contingency approach viewpoint. Empirical research provides guidelines for fitting...

  • EFFECTS OF OD INTERVENTION ON ABSENCE AND OTHER TIME-USES: A MULTI-YEAR TIME-SERIAL INVESTIGATION. Miners, Ian A.; Moore, Michael L.; Champoux, Joseph E.; Martocchio, Joseph // Academy of Management Best Papers Proceedings;1992, p196 

    Statistics showing the impact of OD intervention on a system of five employee time-use variables are plotted daily showing change over three years. 0D significantly reduced short-term legitimate forms of nonwork, and increased time worked. Stopping OD, and later supervisory pressure tactics,...

  • BUILDING A MODEL OF WORK FORCE REDUCTION THAT IS GROUNDED IN PERTINENT THEORY AND DATA: REPLY TO McKINLEY. Sutton, Robert I.; D'Aunno, Thomas // Academy of Management Review;Jan1992, Vol. 17 Issue 1, p138 

    In this article the authors respond to comments made about a paper they published in a pervious issue that discussed that examined organizational decline. The authors proposed two models of the process in their original work, the second of which drew the most scrutiny. In this article they...

  • STRATEGIC CHANGE ANALYSIS: A LONGITUDINAL STUDY OF THE PERIODS AND PATTERNS OF CHANGE. Topping, Sharon // Academy of Management Best Papers Proceedings;1992, p101 

    This study examines the strategic responses of one health care organization over a 19-year period. This involves the application of statistically derived definitions of incremental and revolutionary change and the consequent identification of periods and patterns of change. Findings are examined...

  • Environment, Strategy, and the Implementation of Administrative Change: The Case of Civil Service Reform. Gaertner, Gregory H.; Gaertner, Karen N.; Akinnusi, David M. // Academy of Management Journal;Sep84, Vol. 27 Issue 3, p525 

    A comparative study was done on implementing innovations by an entrepreneurial-generalist and an efficiency-based specialist organization. In the generalist organization administrative innovation was sought by top management to improve coordination, but was difficult to achieve. In the...

  • Executive Commentary.  // Academy of Management Executive;Nov94, Vol. 8 Issue 4, p28 

    The article presents a commentary on the paper "Rethinking Organizational Design," by Robert W. Keidel. The author contends that restructuring and re-engineering are quick fixes for ongoing organizational problems. She says most firms ignore the need for thoughtful consideration when tackling...

  • A General contingency Theory of Management. Luthans, Fred; Stewart, Todd I. // Academy of Management Review;Apr1977, Vol. 2 Issue 2, p181 

    Recent formal recognition of situational influences on the management of complex organizations has led to an increasing number of contingency models, but a comprehensive and integrative theoretical framework for contingency management has been lacking. A General Contingency Theory (GCT) of...

  • The Congruence Perspective of Organization Design: A Conceptual Model and Multivariate Research Approach. Randolph, W. Alan; Dess, Gregory G. // Academy of Management Review;Jan1984, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p114 

    This paper provides direction for a systematic program of research on a congruence perspective of organization design. A theoretical model of strategic choice is elaborated and serves as an integrating framework from the organization design literature. The model is based on a multivariate...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics