Muslim Egyptian and Lebanese Students' Conceptions of Biological Evolution

BouJaoude, Saouma; Wiles, Jason R.; Asghar, Anila; Alters, Brian
September 2011
Science & Education;Sep2011, Vol. 20 Issue 9, p895
Academic Journal
In this study, we investigated distinctions among the diversity of religious traditions represented by Lebanese and Egyptian Muslim high school students regarding their understanding and acceptance of biological evolution and how they relate the science to their religious beliefs. We explored secondary students' conceptions of evolution among members of three Muslim sects-Sunni, Shiite, and Druze-in two cultural contexts; one in which the overwhelming majority of the population is Muslim (Egypt) and another in which there is a sizable Christian community (Lebanon). Data were collected via surveys that examined students' scientific and religious understandings of evolution among 162 Egyptian students (all Sunni Muslims; 63% females and 37% males) and 629 Lebanese students (38.5% Sunni, 38% Shiite, and 23.5% Druze; 49% females and 51% males). Additional data were collected via semi-structured interviews with 30 Lebanese students to allow triangulation of data for accuracy and authenticity. Results indicate that many Egyptian and Lebanese Muslim students have misconceptions about evolution and the nature of science which often lead to rejection of evolution. Also, Lebanese Sunni and Shiite students and Egyptian Sunni students tend to exhibit high levels of religiosity, and these students report that their religious beliefs influence their positions regarding evolution. Finally, Sunni and Shiite Lebanese students have religious beliefs, conceptions of evolution, and positions regarding evolution similar to those of Sunni Egyptian students. These conceptions and positions, however, are substantially different from those of Druze Lebanese students.


Related Articles

  • The hand of God.  // New Scientist;9/28/2002, Vol. 175 Issue 2362, p3 

    Comments on the controversies involving science and religion concerning the Darwinian theory of evolution. Arguments of intelligent design proponents; Claims of atheist scientists concerning the non-existence of God considering the theory of evolution; Problems of complexity and mutations.

  • Pope gives blessing to evolution theory. Kenney, Nicholas A. // National Catholic Reporter;11/08/96, Vol. 33 Issue 3, p3 

    Highlights Pope John Paul II's statement on Vatican's acceptance of evolutionary theory as more than a hypothesis, delivered to the plenary session of the pontifical Academy of Sciences on October 22, 1996. Mounting evidence for evolution in a variety of scientific disciplines; New theological...

  • Science and original sin. Wright, Robert // Time;10/28/1996, Vol. 148 Issue 20, p76 

    Examines the relationship between the Christian concept of original sin and evolutionary biology. What the Christian doctrine of original sin says; Saint Augustine's assertion concerning the doctrine; The evolutionary view of the classic sins as the unchecked expressions of impulses that arose...

  • Civic Biology and the Origin of the School Antievolution Movement. Shapiro, Adam R. // Journal of the History of Biology;Fall2008, Vol. 41 Issue 3, p409 

    In discussing the origins of the antievolution movement in American high schools within the framework of science and religion, much is overlooked about the influence of educational trends in shaping this phenomenon. This was especially true in the years before the 1925 Scopes trial, the...

  • Science and God. Goodman, Lenn // Society;Mar/Apr2008, Vol. 45 Issue 2, p130 

    Religion, like science, seeks to thematize reality. But they differ in what they abstract from: Religions focus on values; often, ultimates. The sciences seek causes, typically, proximate causes. Territorial disputes, then, are misguided, and scientism errs in seeking to displace religion. For...

  • Negotiating Darwin. The Vatican Confronts Evolution (1877-1902). A. MART├ŹNEZ, Rafael // Anuario de Historia de la Iglesia;2009, Vol. 18, p85 

    The theory of evolution faced a critical attitude from the Catholic Church at the end of the 19th century. However, the authorities of the Holy See never issued an official condemnation. The documents from the Archives of the Holy Office and the Index have recently made possible the...

  • Divining Darwin: Evolving Responses and the Contribution of David Lack. BERRY, R. J. (SAM) // Science & Christian Belief;Apr2014, Vol. 26 Issue 1, p53 

    Christian befievers, particularly evangelicals, often react to evolutionary ideas with more heat than light. A significant contribution to clarifying understanding was a book published in 1957, Evolutionary Theory and Christian Belief by the eminent ornithologist David Lack. It was the first...

  • PERSONAL GODS, DEISM, & THE LIMITS OF SKEPTICISM. Pigliucci, Massimo // Skeptic;2000, Vol. 8 Issue 2, p38 

    Analyzes the sources of confusion in the science and religion debate. Classification scheme of the positions held by creationists and evolutionists; Repercussions of the science and religion controversy on freedom of speech for scientists, skeptics and religionists; Versions of modern skepticism.

  • Master of Christian Evangelism Part 1. ANAKA, EMEKA // Insights to a Changing World Journal;2015, Vol. 2015 Issue 2, following p48 

    The author argues that evolution is a religion and not science. Topics discussed include the evolutionary idea as a religion which began with the worship of animals, the formal steps in science such as speculation, hypothesis, and theory, and the origin of everything based on the teachings of...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics