Do existing research summaries on health systems match immunisation managers' needs in middle- and low-income countries? Analysis of GAVI health systems strengthening support

Bosch-Capblanch, Xavier; Kelly, Marion; Garner, Paul
January 2011
BMC Public Health;2011 Supplement 4, Vol. 11 Issue Suppl 4, p449
Academic Journal
Background: The GAVI Alliance was created in 2000 to increase access to vaccines. More recently, GAVI has supported evidence-based health systems strengthening to overcome barriers to vaccination. Our objectives were: to explore countries' priorities for health systems strengthening; to describe published research summaries for each priority area in relation to their number, quality and relevance; and to describe the use of national data from surveys in identifying barriers to immunisation. Methods: From 44 health systems strengthening proposals submitted to GAVI in 2007 and 2008, we analysed the topics identified, the coverage of these topics by existing systematic reviews and the use of nation-wide surveys with vaccination data to justify the needs identified in the proposals. Results: Thirty topics were identified and grouped into three thematic areas: health workforce (10 topics); organisation and management (14); and supply, distribution and maintenance (6). We found 51 potentially relevant systematic reviews, although for the topic that appeared most frequently in the proposals ('Health information systems') no review was identified. Thematic and geographic relevance were generally categorised as "high" in 33 (65%) and 25 (49%) reviews, respectively, but few reviews were categorised as "highly relevant for policy" (7 reviews, 14%). With regard to methodological quality, 14 reviews (27%) were categorised as "high". The number of topics that were addressed by at least one high quality systematic review was: seven of the 10 topics in the 'health workforce' thematic area; six of the 14 topics in the area of 'organisation and management'; and none of the topics in the thematic area of 'supply, distribution and maintenance'. Only twelve of the 39 countries with available national surveys referred to them in their proposals. Conclusion: Relevant, high quality research summaries were found for few of the topics identified by managers. Few proposals used national surveys evidence to identify barriers to vaccination. Researchers generating or adapting evidence about health systems need to be more responsive to managers' needs. Use of available evidence from local or national surveys should be strongly encouraged.


Related Articles

  • Resources.  // Nutrition in Clinical Care;Oct-Dec2003, Vol. 6 Issue 3, p144 

    The article presents information resources on health. "The Pocket Guide to Good Health for Adults" is the revised and expanded booklet for health care consumers released by the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. The Website, www.eatright.org of the American Dietetic Association offers...

  • Construction of the Vero cell culture system that can produce infectious HCV particles. Jia Guo; Ran Yan; Guodong Xu; Weiyun Li; Congyi Zheng // Molecular Biology Reports;Jan2009, Vol. 36 Issue 1, p111 

    Abstract  The hepatitis C virus is a major cause of chronic liver disease worldwide. Lack of culture system supporting virus production has been one of the major impediments in HCV research and vaccine development. Here, we use a HCV (1b) full-length cDNA clone that replicates...

  • The pandemic defense. Barry, David A. // Pharmacy Today;Jul2006, Vol. 12 Issue 7, p14 

    The article discusses the significant role of pharmacists in health care preparation for future pandemics. According to an author, pharmacists play an active role in the preparation by becoming immunization advocates and conducting individualized immunization regimen for protection against...

  • Promoting disease prevention as a priority intervention.  // American Journal of Health-System Pharmacy;7/1/2003, Vol. 60 Issue 13, p1317 

    Editorial. Focuses on the significance of disease prevention in pharmaceutical care. Role of vaccination in reducing the mortality rates due to various infections; Role of pharmacists in the development of immunization in health care practices; Efforts of pharmacists to implement direct...

  • Immunization clinic set Tuesday.  // Graham Leader;5/31/2009, Vol. 133 Issue 83, p5A 

    The article reports on the conduction of an immunization clinic by the Texas Department State Health Services in Graham, Young County, Texas. It mentions that incoming seventh grade students are required to get Tdap, second varicella and the Meningococcal vaccines before the first day of school....

  • Systems pathology—or how to solve the complex problem of predictive pathology. Manfred Dietel; Reinhold Schäfer // Virchows Archiv;Oct2008, Vol. 453 Issue 4, p309 

    Abstract  To understand the extreme complexity of biological events requires a systemic approach. This holds particularly for the disordered biological interactions that are characteristic of disease, the subject of pathology. Which options are available to untie the Gordian knot? In this...

  • Combined vaccine may lower immune response. Bowden, Rachel // GP: General Practitioner;4/15/2005, p7 

    The article informs that some concerns have been raised over combined childhood vaccinations after trials of a pneumococcal-meningococcal vaccine showed reduced efficacy compared with a single jab. A phase-II study showed a combined pneumococcal-men-ingococcal vaccine produced less of an immune...

  • GAVI commits $500 million for health systems.  // Finance & Development;Mar2007, Vol. 44 Issue 1, p3 

    The article reports on the commitment of Global Alliance for Vaccines and Immunization (GAVI) to help children in poor countries in terms of medical care. GAVI is a public-private partnership focused on increasing children's access to vaccines in poor countries. In an effort to further increase...

  • The Effects of the Changes in Section 317 Rules for Administration of Federally Purchased Vaccines. Knight, Margaret A.; Kershenbaum, Anne D.; Buchanan, Martha; Ridley, Janet; Erwin, Paul C. // Frontiers in Public Health Services & Systems Research;Apr2014, Vol. 3 Issue 2, preceding p1 

    Section 317 of the Public Health Services Act is a federal program that provides funds for the purchase of vaccines. These annual Congressional allocations fluctuate from year to year as Congress responds to changes in national needs for immunizations. The Affordable Care Act requires first...


Other Topics