Limited access to HIV prevention in French prisons (ANRS PRI2DE): implications for public health and drug policy

Michel, Laurent; Jauffret-Roustide, Marie; Blanche, Jerôme; Maguet, Olivier; Calderon, Christine; Cohen, Julien; Carrieri, Patrizia M.
January 2011
BMC Public Health;2011 Supplement 4, Vol. 11 Issue Suppl 4, p400
Academic Journal
Background: Overpopulation, poor hygiene and disease prevention conditions in prisons are major structural determinants of increased infectious risk within prison settings but evidence-based national and WHO guidelines provide clear indications on how to reduce this risk. We sought to estimate the level of infectious risk by measuring how French prisons adhere to national and WHO guidelines. Methods: A nationwide survey targeting the heads of medical (all French prisons) and psychiatric (26 French prisons) units was conducted using a postal questionnaire and a phone interview mainly focusing on access to prevention interventions, i.e. bleach, opioid substitution treatment (OST), HBV vaccination and post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) for French prisoners. Two scores were built reflecting adherence to national and WHO international guidelines, ranging from 0 (no adherence) to 10 (maximum adherence) and 0 to 9 respectively. Results: A majority (N = 113 (66%)) of the 171 prisons answered the questionnaires, representing 74% coverage (46,786 prisoners) of the French prison population: 108 were medical units and 12 were psychiatric units. Inmate access to prevention was poor. The median[IQR] score measuring adherence to national guidelines was quite low (4.5[2.5; 5.5]) but adherence to WHO guidelines was even lower 2.5[1.5; 3.5]; PEP was absent despite reported risky practices. Unsuitable OST delivery practices were frequently observed. Conclusions: A wide gap exists between HIV prevention policies and their application in prisons. Similar assessments in other countries may be needed to guide a global policy reform in prison settings. Adequate funding together with innovative interventions able to remove structural and ideological barriers to HIV prevention are now needed to motivate those in charge of prison health, to improve their working environment and to relieve French prisoners from their currently debilitating conditions.


Related Articles

  • Editorial: Improving HIV/AIDS Prevention in Prisons is Good Public Health Policy. Gaiter, Juarlyn; Doll, Lynda S. // American Journal of Public Health;Sep96, Vol. 86 Issue 9, p1201 

    The article emphasizes the importance of improving HIV and AIDS prevention in prisons as a public health policy. The high prevalence of HIV infection among inmates is linked with the concentration of injection drug users in correctional institutions. Despite HIV prevention efforts, the number of...

  • Male Prisoners and HIV Prevention: A Call for Action Ignored. Braithwaite, Ronald L.; Arriola, Kimberly R. J. // American Journal of Public Health;Sep2008 Supplement, Vol. 98, pS145 

    US prison inmates are disproportionately indigent young men of color. These individuals are severely affected by HIV/AIDS, largely owing to the high-risk behavior that they engage in prior to incarceration. Researchers and practitioners have issued a call for the importance of offering HIV...

  • AIDS and Prisons. Chappell, Duncan // Trends & Issues in Crime & Criminal Justice;Dec1989, Issue 21, p1 

    The article expresses concern regarding the possible transmission of HIV and AIDS in Australia, highlighting the changing population of the country's correctional institutions. It depicts several policies in relation to HIV and AIDS at present in place in the country's prison systems as well as...

  • Randomized controlled trial proves effectiveness of methadone maintenance treatment in prison. Haig, Thomas // Canadian HIV/AIDS Policy & Law Review;Dec2003, Vol. 8 Issue 3, p48 

    Reports on studies of recent methadone maintenance treatment in prisons. Finding of a Canadian study which showed that methadone treatment had a positive impact on release outcome and on institutional behavior. Results of the newer study in Australia which found that methadone treatment also...

  • AIDS Programmes at the Workplace: A Scoresheet for Assessing the Quality of Services. London, L. // Occupational Medicine;1996, Vol. 46 Issue 3, p216 

    Little data is available on the extent or comprehensiveness of AIDS prevention activities at South African workplaces. A cross-sectional postal survey was performed of all members of the local occupational health nursing association in the area of greater Cape Town in 1994 to assess the quality...

  • 'It was absolute hell': Inside the private prison. Taylor, Phil; Cooper, Christine // Capital & Class;Autumn2008, Vol. 32 Issue 96, p3 

    As part of a broader current of critique of the economic and political dynamics of prison privatisation -- a critique that initially emanated from the USA -- this paper focuses on Scotland and on research carried out at its then only private penal institution, HMP Kilmarnock. The authors...

  • Standing in the Gap. Treadwell, Henrie M.; Nottingham, Joyce H. // American Journal of Public Health;Sep2008 Supplement, Vol. 98, pS169 

    The author reflects on the mass migrations on the border between the community and the correctional system in the U.S. She mentions that nearly 60% of African American high school dropouts born between 1965 and 1959 served time in state or federal prison by their early 30s. She suggests the...

  • A Public Health Model to Connect Correctional Health Care With Communities. Conklin, Thomas J.; Lincoln, Thomas; Flanigan, Timothy P. // American Journal of Public Health;Aug1998, Vol. 88 Issue 8, p1249 

    The article presents information on the development of an innovative and successful public health system of medical care that links inmates to the community from which they came and to which they are to return at the Hampden County Correctional Center in Ludlow, Massachusetts. Several community...

  • CE/CME questions.  // AIDS Alert;May2008, Vol. 23 Issue 5, p59 

    A quiz about AIDS prevention and public health programs is presented.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics