Developing a matrix to identify and prioritise research recommendations in HIV Prevention

Anstee, Sydney; Price, Alison; Young, Amanda; Barnard, Katharine; Coates, Bob; Fraser, Simon; Moran, Rebecca
January 2011
BMC Public Health;2011 Supplement 4, Vol. 11 Issue Suppl 4, p381
Academic Journal
Background: HIV prevention continues to be problematic in the UK, as it does globally. The UK Department of Health has a strategic direction with greater focus on prevention as part of its World Class Commissioning Programme. There is a need for targeted evidence-based prevention initiatives. This is an exploratory study to develop an evidence mapping tool in the form of a matrix: this will be used to identify important gaps in contemporary HIV prevention evidence relevant to the UK. It has the potential to aid prioritisation in future research. Methods: Categories for prevention and risk groups were developed for HIV prevention in consultation with external experts. These were used as axes on a matrix tool to map evidence. Systematic searches for publications on HIV prevention were undertaken using electronic databases for primary and secondary research undertaken mainly in UK, USA, Canada, Australia and New Zealand, 2006-9. Each publication was screened for inclusion then coded. The risk groups and prevention areas in each paper were counted: several publications addressed multiple risk groups. The counts were exported to the matrix and clearly illustrate the concentrations and gaps of literature in HIV prevention. Results: 716 systematic reviews, randomised control trials and other primary research met the inclusion criteria for HIV prevention. The matrix identified several under researched areas in HIV prevention. Conclusions: This is the first categorisation system for HIV prevention and the matrix is a novel tool for evidence mapping. Some important yet under-researched areas have been identified in HIV prevention evidence: identifying the undiagnosed population; international adaptation; education; intervention combinations; transgender; sexworkers; heterosexuals and older age groups. Other research recommendations: develop the classification system further and investigate transferability of the matrix to other prevention areas; evidence syntheses may be appropriate in areas dense with research; have studies with positive findings been translated to practice? The authors of this study invite research suggestions relating to the evidence gaps identified within remits of Public Health or any appropriate NETSCC programme.


Related Articles

  • HIV Prevention: The Need for Methods Women Can Use. Stein, Zena A. // American Journal of Public Health;Apr90, Vol. 80 Issue 4, p460 

    Abstract: Efforts to prevent heterosexual transmission of HIV (human immunodeficiency virus) infection have thus far focused on modifying sexual behaviors and the use of condoms. While the experience of family planners, particularly in those countries most threatened by heterosexual HIV...

  • Health hazard. Swift, Richard // New Internationalist;Jan/Feb2001, Issue 331, p1 

    Focuses on issues related to public health. Reasons why some people are more prone to illness than others; Lack of quality of medical care; Promotion of preventive medicine.

  • Pandemic flu, other public health crises: U.S. has made progress in preparedness. Collins, Susan // Hill;5/15/2009, Vol. 16 Issue 56, p29 

    The article focuses on the author's discussion on the U.S.' preparation for the H1N1 influenza virus and other public health problems.

  • Public health and preventive medicine. Foege, William H. // JAMA: Journal of the American Medical Association;06/18/97, Vol. 277 Issue 23, p1894 

    Reports on scientific advances in the fields of public health and preventive medicine. Prevention which is becoming a responsibility of health care delivery systems; Various systems that can track immunizations for all children; Progress in public health which is being made in developing countries.

  • Preventive medicine and public health. Foege, William H. // JAMA: Journal of the American Medical Association;6/19/96, Vol. 275 Issue 23, p1846 

    Focuses on advances in preventive medicine and public health. Eradication of smallpox; AIDS research; Tobacco which is scheduled to triple it annual toll of victim; UNICEF's `The State of the World's Children 1996.'

  • The Next Wave. Tortolero, Susan // Journal of Primary Prevention;Apr2013, Vol. 34 Issue 1/2, p1 

    An introduction to the journal is presented in which the editor discusses the public health topics and prevention science.

  • Kansas needs improvement in public health preparedness.  // Infectious Diseases in Children;Feb2008, Vol. 21 Issue 2, p51 

    The article focuses on a report issued by the Trust for America's Health regarding the public health preparedness of states in the U.S. The report revealed that Kansas failed to meet three of the 10 criteria for public health preparedness, including an electronic database surveillance system,...

  • Impact of transition on public health in Ukraine: case study of the HIV/AIDS epidemic. DeBell, Diane; Carter, Richard // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);7/23/2005, Vol. 331 Issue 7510, p216 

    Presents a case study on the impact of economic transition on public health, as seen by the link between HIV infection and human and economic development in Ukraine. Report that the prevalence of HIV infection in Ukraine poses a serious threat to the region's social and economic stability;...

  • Sexual behaviour as the limiting and linking factor in HIV-infected people in rural Zimbabwe. Alkatout, Ibrahim; Furey, Alison; Vineberg, Rebecca; Schulz, Ulrike; Thistle, Paul // International Journal of STD & AIDS;Oct2007, Vol. 18 Issue 10, p688 

    Although the incidence of AIDS continues to increase in Zimbabwe, no systematic investigation has been done of the contextual (behavioural and situational) variables important to the tailoring of AIDS educational prevention programmes for those at risk. As part of a World Health...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics