Comparing Two Methods for Reducing Variability in Voice Quality Measurements

Kreimana, Jody; Gerratta, Bruce R.
June 2011
Journal of Speech, Language & Hearing Research;Jun2011, Vol. 54 Issue 3, p803
Academic Journal
Purpose: Interrater disagreements in ratings of quality plague the study of voice. This study compared 2 methods for handling this variability. Method: Listeners provided multiple breathiness ratings for 2 sets of pathological voices, one including 20 male and 20 female voices unselected for quality and one including 20 breathy female voices. Ratings for each listener were averaged together, mean ratings were z transformed, and the likelihood that 2 listeners would agree exactly in their ratings was calculated as a function of averaging and standardizing condition. Data were also multidimensionally scaled to examine similarities among listeners in perceptual strategy. Results were compared with parallel analyses of existing breathiness ratings of the same voices gathered using a method-of-adjustment task. Results: Three-way interactions between the mean rating for a voice, standardization condition, and the number of voices averaged together were observed, but no main effect of averaging condition emerged. Multidimensional scaling revealed significant residual differences in perceptual strategy across listeners after averaging and standardizing. Ratings from the method-of-adjustment task showed both high agreement levels and consistent perceptual strategies across listeners, as theoretically predicted. Conclusion: Averaging multiple ratings and standardizing the mean are inadequate in addressing variations in voice quality perception.


Related Articles

  • Comparison of three hand dynamometers in relation to the accuracy and precision of the measurements. Amaral, Josária F.; Mancini, Marcelly; Novo Júnior, José M. // Brazilian Journal of Physical Therapy / Revista Brasileira de Fi;mai/jun2012, Vol. 16 Issue 3, p216 

    Background: Given the variety of available hand-held dynamometers and their different handle shapes, reliability studies are needed. Objectives: To compare the accuracy and reliability between three different hand-held dynamometers and analyze the influence of their handles on grip strength....

  • Reducing the Negative Vocal Effects of Superficial Laryngeal Dehydration With Humidification. Levendoski, Elizabeth Erickson; Sundarrajan, Anusha; Sivasankar, M. Preeti // Annals of Otology, Rhinology & Laryngology;Jul2014, Vol. 123 Issue 7, p475 

    OBJECTIVES:Environmental humidification is a simple, cost-effective method believed to reduce superficial laryngeal drying. This study sought to validate this belief by investigating whether humidification treatment would reduce the negative effects of superficial laryngeal dehydration on...

  • Sentence-Position Effects on Children's Perception and Production of English Third Person Singular --s. Sundara, Megha; Demuth, Katherine; Kuhl, Patricia K. // Journal of Speech, Language & Hearing Research;Feb2011, Vol. 54 Issue 1, p55 

    Purpose: Two-year-olds produce third person singular —s more accurately on verbs in sentence-final position as compared with verbs in sentence-medial position. This study was designed to determine whether these sentence-position effects can be explained by perceptual factors. Method: For...

  • Enhancing the Vocabulary Knowledge of First-Grade Children With Supplemental Booster Instruction. Puhalla, Eve M. // Remedial & Special Education;Nov2011, Vol. 32 Issue 6, p471 

    This study examined the effects of instructional intensity on the acquisition of storybook vocabulary in first graders who were at risk of early reading failure. It also measured whether the intervention was effective for closing the vocabulary knowledge gap between students who were at risk and...

  • Comparative Efficacy of LEAP, TEACCH and Non-Model-Specific Special Education Programs for Preschoolers with Autism Spectrum Disorders. Boyd, Brian; Hume, Kara; McBee, Matthew; Alessandri, Michael; Gutierrez, Anibal; Johnson, LeAnne; Sperry, Laurie; Odom, Samuel // Journal of Autism & Developmental Disorders;Feb2014, Vol. 44 Issue 2, p366 

    LEAP and TEACCH represent two comprehensive treatment models (CTMs) that have been widely used across several decades to educate young children with autism spectrum disorders. The purpose of this quasi-experimental study was to compare high fidelity LEAP (n = 22) and TEACCH (n = 25) classrooms...

  • Body-Density Measurement in Children: The BOD POD Versus Hydrodensitometry. Holmes, Jason C.; Gibson, Ann L.; Cremades, J. Gualberto; Mier, Constance M. // International Journal of Sport Nutrition & Exercise Metabolism;Jun2011, Vol. 21 Issue 3, p240 

    Objective: To compare estimates of body density (Db) from air-displacement plethysmography (ADP) with measured and predicted thoracic-gas-volume (TGV) measurements and those from hydrodensitometry (HD) in children. Methods: Seventeen participants (13 male and 4 female; 10.1 ± 2.20 yr, 42.0...

  • Work-related Barriers and Facilitators to Antiretroviral Therapy Adherence in Persons Living with HIV Infection. Torres-Madriz, Gilberto; Lerner, Debra; Ruthazer, Robin; Rogers, William; Wilson, Ira // AIDS & Behavior;Oct2011, Vol. 15 Issue 7, p1475 

    Little is known about how the structure of work affects adherence to HIV antiretroviral therapy. We surveyed participants in an adherence intervention study to learn more about job characteristics, including measures of psychological demand and control, and job accommodations. Adherence was...

  • The Role of Perceived Voice and Speech Characteristics in Vocal Emotion Communication. Bänziger, Tanja; Patel, Sona; Scherer, Klaus // Journal of Nonverbal Behavior;Mar2014, Vol. 38 Issue 1, p31 

    Aiming at a more comprehensive assessment of nonverbal vocal emotion communication, this article presents the development and validation of a new rating instrument for the assessment of perceived voice and speech features. In two studies, using two different sets of emotion portrayals by German...

  • Application of a Repeat-Measure Biomarker Measurement Error Model to 2 Validation Studies: Examination of the Effect of Within-Person Variation in Biomarker Measurements. Preis, Sarah Rosner; Spiegelman, Donna; Zhao, Barbara Bojuan; Moshfegh, Alanna; Baer, David J.; Willett, Walter C. // American Journal of Epidemiology;Mar2011, Vol. 173 Issue 6, p683 

    Repeat-biomarker measurement error models accounting for systematic correlated within-person error can be used to estimate the correlation coefficient (ρ) and deattenuation factor (λ), used in measurement error correction. These models account for correlated errors in the food frequency...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics