A systematic review of the effect of retention methods in population-based cohort studies

Booker, Cara L.; Harding, Seeromanie; Benzeval, Michaela
January 2011
BMC Public Health;2011, Vol. 11 Issue 1, p249
Academic Journal
Background: Longitudinal studies are of aetiological and public health relevance but can be undermined by attrition. The aim of this paper was to identify effective retention strategies to increase participation in populationbased cohort studies. Methods: Systematic review of the literature to identify prospective population-based cohort studies with health outcomes in which retention strategies had been evaluated. Results: Twenty-eight studies published up to January 2011 were included. Eleven of which were randomized controlled trials of retention strategies (RCT). Fifty-seven percent of the studies were postal, 21% in-person, 14% telephone and 7% had mixed data collection methods. A total of 45 different retention strategies were used, categorised as 1) incentives, 2) reminder methods, repeat visits or repeat questionnaires, alternative modes of data collection or 3) other methods. Incentives were associated with an increase in retention rates, which improved with greater incentive value. Whether cash was the most effective incentive was not clear from studies that compared cash and gifts of similar value. The average increase in retention rate was 12% for reminder letters, 5% for reminder calls and 12% for repeat questionnaires. Ten studies used alternative data collection methods, mainly as a last resort. All postal studies offered telephone interviews to non-responders, which increased retention rates by 3%. Studies that used face-to-face interviews increased their retention rates by 24% by offering alternative locations and modes of data collection. Conclusions: Incentives boosted retention rates in prospective cohort studies. Other methods appeared to have a beneficial effect but there was a general lack of a systematic approach to their evaluation.


Related Articles

  • Episodic Memory Dysfunction in Individuals at High-Risk of Psychosis: A Systematic Review of Neuropsychological and Neurofunctional Studies. Valli, Isabel; Tognin, Stefania; Fusar-Poli, Paolo; Mechelli, Andrea // Current Pharmaceutical Design;2/1/2012, Vol. 18 Issue 4, p443 

    Cognitive impairment is one of the key features of schizophrenia, with the largest effect sizes identified for verbal learning and memory, however little is known about its features in the time that precedes psychosis onset. Here we review a total of thirty-two studies that examined memory and...

  • A Systematic Review on Health Resilience to Economic Crises. Glonti, Ketevan; Gordeev, Vladimir S.; Goryakin, Yevgeniy; Reeves, Aaron; Stuckler, David; McKee, Martin; Roberts, Bayard // PLoS ONE;Apr2015, Vol. 10 Issue 4, p1 

    Background: The health effects of recent economic crises differ markedly by population group. The objective of this systematic review is to examine evidence from longitudinal studies on factors influencing resilience for any health outcome or health behaviour among the general population living...

  • Global Typhoid Fever Incidence: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Marchello, Christian S; Hong, Chuen Yen; Crump, John A // Clinical Infectious Diseases;2019 Supplement, Vol. 68, pS105 

    Background Contemporary incidence estimates of typhoid fever are needed to guide policy decisions and control measures and to improve future epidemiological studies. Methods We systematically reviewed 3 databases (Ovid Medline, PubMed, and Scopus) without restriction on age, country, language,...

  • Nontuberculous Mycobacteria Isolation from Clinical and Environmental Samples in Iran: Twenty Years of Surveillance. Velayati, Ali Akbar; Farnia, Parissa; Mozafari, Mohadese; Mirsaeidi, Mehdi // BioMed Research International;5/28/2015, Vol. 2015, p1 

    Nontuberculous mycobacteria (NTM) are opportunistic pathogens that are widely distributed in the environment. There is a lack of data on species distribution of these organisms from Iran. This study consists of a review of NTM articles published in Iran between the years 1992 and 2014. In this...

  • Enhancing methodological developments for Cochrane Public Health Reviews: the role of exemplar reviews. Armstrong, Rebecca; Doyle, Jodie; Saith, Ruhi; Anderson, Laurie // Journal of Public Health;Dec2009, Vol. 31 Issue 4, p593 

    The article discusses processes developed by the Cochrane Public Health Review Group (PHRG) to facilitate ongoing methodological developments in conducting systematic reviews. One approach is the use of exemplar reviews as platform for conducting a series of methodological projects. This...

  • Don't turn your back on the symptoms of psychosis: a proof-of-principle, quasi-experimental public health trial to reduce the duration of untreated psychosis in Birmingham, UK. Connor, Charlotte; Birchwood, Max; Palmer, Colin; Channa, Sunita; Freemantle, Nick; Lester, Helen; Patterson, Paul; Singh, Swaran // BMC Psychiatry;2013, Vol. 13 Issue 1, p1 

    Background: Reducing the duration of untreated psychosis (DUP) is an aspiration of international guidelines for first episode psychosis; however, public health initiatives have met with mixed results. Systematic reviews suggest that greater focus on the sources of delay within care pathways,...

  • A systematic review of transitions between cigarette and smokeless tobacco product use in the United States. Tam, Jamie; Day, Hannah R.; Rostron, Brian L.; Apelberg, Benjamin J. // BMC Public Health;2015, Vol. 15 Issue 1, p1 

    Background: Smokeless tobacco use is becoming an increasingly important public health issue in the US and may influence cigarette smoking behavior. Systematic information on transitions between smokeless tobacco and cigarette use in the US is limited. Methods: We conducted a systematic review of...

  • Framework for selecting best practices in public health: a systematic literature review. Ng, Eileen; de Colombani, Pierpaolo // Journal of Public Health Research;2015, Vol. 4 Issue 3, p157 

    Evidence-based public health has commonly relied on findings from empirical studies, or research-based evidence. However, this paper advocates that practice-based evidence derived from programmes implemented in real-life settings is likely to be a more suitable source of evidence for inspiring...

  • A Meta-analysis of Chemotherapy related Cognitive Impairment in Patients with Breast Cancer. Jin-Hee Park; Sun Hyoung Bae // Journal of Korean Academy of Nursing;2012, Vol. 42 Issue 5, p644 

    Purpose: The purpose of this study was to evaluate the cognitive effects of chemotherapy in patients with breast cancer. Methods: Using several databases, prospective studies were collected up to August 2011. Of 2,106 publications identified, 12 met the inclusion criteria, and 8 studies were...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics