Bypassing the selection rule in choosing controls for a case-control study

Palmer, Keith T.; Kim, Miranda; Coggon, David
December 2010
Occupational & Environmental Medicine;Dec2010, Vol. 67 Issue 12, p872
Academic Journal
Objectives It has been argued that in case-control studies, controls should be drawn from the base population that gives rise to the cases. In designing a study of occupational injury and risks arising from long-term illness and prescribed medication, we lacked data on subjects' occupation, without which employed cases (typically in manual occupations) would be compared with controls from the general population, including the unemployed and a higher proportion of white-collar professions. Collecting the missing data on occupation would be costly. We estimated the potential for bias if the selection rule were ignored. Methods We obtained published estimates of the frequencies of several exposures of interest (diabetes, mental health problems, asthma, coronary heart disease) in the general population, and of the relative risks of these diseases in unemployed versus employed individuals and in manual versus non-manual occupations. From these we computed the degree of over- or underestimation of exposure frequencies and exposure ORs if controls were selected from the general population. Results The potential bias in the OR was estimated as likely to fall between an underestimation of 14% and an overestimation of 36.7% (95th centiles). In fewer than 6% of simulations did the error exceed 30%, and in none did it reach 50%. Conclusions For the purposes of this study, in which we were interested only in substantial increases in risk, the potential for selection bias was judged acceptable. The rule that controls should come from the same base population as cases can justifiably be broken, at least in some circumstances.


Related Articles

  • Reported Occupational Hazards and Illnesses among Hairdressers in Ibadan, SouthWest Nigeria. Omokhodion, F. O.; Balogun, M. O.; Ola-Olorun, F. M. // West African Journal of Medicine;Jan2009, Vol. 28 Issue 1, p20 

    BACKGROUND: Hairdressers work in small scale enterprises with little or no health supervision in the workplace. OBJECTIVE: To identify workplace hazards and health problems of workers in this trade. METHODS: A cross sectional study was conducted in hairdressing salons in Ibadan, Southwest...

  • The ill surgeon: a review of common work-related health problems amongst UK surgeons. Vijendren, Ananth; Yung, Matthew; Sanchez, Jose // Langenbeck's Archives of Surgery;Dec2014, Vol. 399 Issue 8, p967 

    Introduction: Health-care workers are subjected to various occupational hazards within the National Health Service (NHS). Surgeons are not excluded from this group due to the nature of work carried out on a daily basis. As a result, we set out to investigate the common work-related health issues...

  • Assessment of Lifetime Occupational Exposure in an Epidemiologic Study of COPD. Graziani, Monica; Doney, Brent; Hnizdo, Eva; Villnave, Jacqueline; Breen, Victor; Weinmann, Sheila; Vollmer, William M.; McBurnie, Mary Ann; Sonia Buist, A.; Heumann, Michael // Open Epidemiology Journal;2012, Vol. 5, p27 

    Ascertainment of lifetime occupational exposures in an epidemiological study of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) is important in order to investigate its effect on the disease and develop prevention strategies. The aim of our paper is to describe and evaluate a methodology used to...

  • Pesticides and other occupational exposures are associated with airway obstruction: the LifeLines cohort study. de Jong, K.; Boezen, H. M.; Kromhout, H.; Vermeulen, R.; Postma, D. S.; Vonk, J. M. // Occupational & Environmental Medicine;Feb2014, Vol. 71 Issue 2, p88 

    Objectives Occupational exposures are important and possibly modifiable contributors to the global burden of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). Exposure to vapours, gases, dusts and fumes (VGDF) has been associated with a two- to threefold higher COPD risk. Less is known about effects...

  • Coal compensation scheme failings.  // RoSPA Occupational Safety & Health Journal;Apr2008, Vol. 38 Issue 4, p8 

    The article reports that the Committee of Public Accounts in Great Britain has criticised the management of two coal compensation schemes by Department for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform. The schemes were established to pay compensation to miners suffering from chronic obstructive...

  • Current Labor Statistics: Injury and Illness.  // Monthly Labor Review;Apr2005, Vol. 128 Issue 4, p126 

    This article presents data on occupational injury and illness rates in the U.S. in 2004.

  • Hablar en public. Acosta, José María // Gestión Práctica de Riesgos Laborales;abr2013, Issue 103, p64 

    No abstract available.

  • La dificultad de probar el carácter laboral de las enfermedades no profesionales. Giménez, Daniel Toscani // Gestión Práctica de Riesgos Laborales;jul2011, Issue 84, p28 

    No abstract available.

  • COSH: A Grass-Roots Public Health Movement. Levenstein, Charles; Boden, Leslie I.; Wegman, David H. // American Journal of Public Health;Sep84, Vol. 74 Issue 9, p964 

    The article discusses the worker-based and decentralized approach to prevention of occupational injuries and illnesses and compares such practices in Italy and the U.S. One factor in the comparison is the decline in political and economic power of trade unions in the U.S. Grass roots coalitions...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics