Accuracy of tympanic and infrared skin thermometers in children

Paes, B. F.; Vermeulen, K.; Brohet, R. M.; van der Ploeg, T.; de Winter, J. P.
December 2010
Archives of Disease in Childhood -- Fetal & Neonatal Edition;Dec2010, Vol. 95 Issue 12, p974
Academic Journal
Background Rectal measurement is considered a gold standard in many healthcare systems for body temperature measurement in children. Although this method has several disadvantages, an ideal alternative thermometer has not yet been introduced. However tympanic and infrared skin thermometers are potential alternatives. Methods A prospective cohort study was performed including 100 children between 0 and 18 years of age admitted to the general paediatric ward of Spaarne Hospital in The Netherlands between January and March 2009. The objectives of this study are to evaluate the accuracy of tympanic and two types of infrared skin thermometers (Beurer and Thermofocus) compared to rectal measurement and furthermore to evaluate the influence of different variables on temperature measurements. Results Compared to rectal measurement (37.56�C), the mean temperatures of the tympanic (37.29�C), Beurer (36.79�C) and Thermofocus (37.30�C) thermometers differed significantly (p<0.001). Mean and SD of differences between rectal temperature and temperature measured with these alternative devices varied significantly (p<0.001). Sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive values for detecting rectal fever measured with the tympanic, Beurer and Thermofocus thermometers are unacceptable, especially for the Beurer thermometer. This difference in temperature between rectal and the alternative thermometers remained after stratification on gender, age, skin colour and otoscopic abnormalities. Conclusions In this study the authors demonstrated that the tympanic, Beurer and Thermofocus thermometers cannot reliably predict rectal temperature. Therefore the authors do not advise replacement of rectal measurement as the gold standard for detecting fever in children by one of these devices. When rectal measurement is not used, the infrared skin thermometers appear to perform less well than tympanic measurements.


Related Articles

  • The Performance of Two Tympanic Thermometers in a Pediatric Emergency Department. Terndrup, Thomas E.; Milewski, Anne // Clinical Pediatrics;Apr1991 Supplement, Vol. 30 Issue S4, p18 

    In a prospective, unblinded, controlled study, 303 children underwent comparison of rectal (RT) and right-sided tympanic membrane (TMT) temperatures. Digital electronic thermometers were used for RT, while two different infrared detection devices assessed TMT. The performance of TMT devices were...

  • Comparison of a Tympanic Thermometer to Rectal and Oral Thermometers in a Pediatric Emergency Department. Chamberlain, James M.; Grandner, John; Rubinoff, Jeffrey L.; Klein, Bruce L.; Waisman, Yeheskel; Huey, Margaret // Clinical Pediatrics;Apr1991 Supplement, Vol. 30 Issue S4, p24 

    We performed a clinical trial of a new tympanic thermometer to test its accuracy in a pediatric emergency department. Tympanic temperature was compared to oral or rectal glass and electronic temperature, depending on the developmental age of the child. Results were controlled for age of the...

  • Behavioral Aspects of Temperature-Taking. Schmitt, Barton D. // Clinical Pediatrics;Apr1991 Supplement, Vol. 30 Issue S4, p8 

    The article discusses the behavioral aspects of temperature-taking. The development and emergence of tympanic thermometry provided medical professionals with accurate, instantaneous temperature readings. Development of an ear thermometer for home use is in process. In all studies conducted,...

  • Comparison of Pulmonary Artery, Rectal, and Tympanic Membrane Temperatures in Adult Intensive Care Unit Patients. Milweski, Anne; Ferguson, Kevin L.; Terndrup, Thomas E. // Clinical Pediatrics;Apr1991 Supplement, Vol. 30 Issue S4, p13 

    Tympanic thermometry using infrared thermography technology offers a noninvasive, rapid temperature measurement tool which may be useful for selected intensive care unit (ICU) patients. Multiple comparisons of pulmonary artery catheter (PAC), rectal (R), and tympanic membrane (TM) temperatures...

  • Tympanic Membrane Temperatures Compared to Rectal and Oral Temperatures. Talo, Haitham; Macknin, Michael L.; Medendorp, Sharon VanderBrug // Clinical Pediatrics;Apr1991 Supplement, Vol. 30 Issue S4, p30 

    One hundred thirty-seven children at the Cleveland Clinic Foundation were enrolled in a study comparing the accuracy and acceptability of tympanic membrane temperatures taken with Thermoscan' to rectal or oral temperatures taken by IVAC" electronic thermometers. The mean age of the rectal/ear...

  • Tympanic Thermometry: Poor Correlations. Brogan, Paul A. // Clinical Pediatrics;Nov1993, Vol. 32 Issue 11, p699 

    Presents a letter to the editor about tympanic thermometry.

  • Quick answer to pyrexia problem. Gnanapragasam, Vasa // GP: General Practitioner;1/27/2003, p55 

    Presents information on a tympanic thermometer called the Omron Gentle 510. Various thermometer that measure temperature; Features of Omron Gentle 510; Benefits of the thermometer.

  • Tympanic membrane thermometers: The heat is on. P.G.O'C. // Cortlandt Forum;01/25/98, Vol. 11 Issue 1, p121 

    Cautions against the use of tympanic membrane thermometers (TMTs). Unreliability of temperature readings using TMTs in a study of runners; Concerns on the accuracy of TMT readings in children with otitis.

  • Effect of Otitis Media on Infrared Tympanic Thermometry. Kelly, Barbara; Alexander, David // Clinical Pediatrics;Apr1991 Supplement, Vol. 30 Issue S4, p46 

    This study was designed to determine if temperature readings using a new tympanic thermometer are affected by otitis media. These readings were also compared to a rectal or oral temperature. Eighty-four children with unilateral suppurative or non-suppurative otitis media diagnosed clinically by...


Read the Article


Sign out of this library

Other Topics