Sorting out autism spectrum disorders: Evidence-based medicine and the complexities of the clinical encounter

Lenne, Brydan Sarah; Waldby, Catherine
March 2011
Health Sociology Review;Mar2011, Vol. 20 Issue 1, p70
Academic Journal
Autism spectrum disorders (ASDs) present particular problems for diagnosis, encompassing as they do communication difficulties, learning difficulties, social awkwardness, and severe disability, as well as some strengths and special skills (such as perfect pitch or artistic abilities). Hence ASDs have proven difficult to standardise, and evidence-based medicine (EBM) advocates deplore the absence of clean randomised control trial data for different approaches. This study explores the extent to which the drive for standardisation and statistical approaches to clinical medicine influence the ways paediatricians diagnose and treat ASDs. To this end, we interviewed nine paediatricians in private practice using a face-to-face, semi-structured approach. Three primary themes emerged from the interview data. First the essentially tacit, experiential nature of diagnosing autism, second the necessity of tinkering with and adapting existing diagnostic tools to particular patients and circumstances, and third, the influence of social constraints on the clinical encounter. This study demonstrates that the process of diagnosis and treatment recommendation involves constant negotiation between clinical experience, the evidence, and the family's social situation. Furthermore, we find that statistical and EBM approaches are used most often at the margins of the clinical encounter to diagnose outlier patients, rather than the typical patient these approaches claim to describe.


Related Articles

  • Brief Report: Are ADHD Traits Dissociable from the Autistic Profile? Links Between Cognition and Behaviour. Ames, Catherine S.; White, Sarah J. // Journal of Autism & Developmental Disorders;Mar2011, Vol. 41 Issue 3, p357 

    Reports of co-morbid symptoms of ADHD in children with ASD have increased. This research sought to identify ADHD-related behaviours in a sample of children with ASD, and their relationship with the ASD triad of impairments and related cognitive impairments. Children with ASD ( n = 55) completed...

  • The decisions regarding ADHD management (DRAMa) study: uncertainties and complexities in assessment, diagnosis and treatment, from the clinician's point of view. Kovshoff, Hanna; Williams, Sarah; Vrijens, May; Danckaerts, Marina; Thompson, Margaret; Yardley, Lucy; Hodgkins, Paul; Sonuga-Barke, Edmund // European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry;Feb2012, Vol. 21 Issue 2, p87 

    Clinical decision making is influenced by a range of factors and constitutes an inherently complex task. Here we present results from the decisions regarding ADHD management (DRAMa) study in which we undertook a thematic analysis of clinicians' experiences and attitudes to assessment, diagnosis...

  • 'There is Something not Quite Right with Brad...': The Ways in Which Families Construct ADHD Before Receiving a Diagnosis. Lewis-Morton, Ruth; Dallos, Rudi; McClelland, Lynn; Clempson, Rachel // Contemporary Family Therapy: An International Journal;Jun2014, Vol. 36 Issue 2, p260 

    This study explored how four families who were in the midst of the process of a potential diagnosis of 'Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder' (ADHD) for their child negotiated competing explanations of the problems. The research drew on a social constructionist, systemic and attachment lens...

  • ADHD-a parent's view. Gould, Jane // Therapy Today;Mar2014, Vol. 25 Issue 2, p42 

    A letter to the editor is presented in response to the article "ADGD passport or label," in the December 2013 issue.

  • Exploring Physician Decisions about End-of-Life Opiate Prescribing: A Qualitative Study. Zerzan, Judy; Lee, Courtney A.; Haverhals, Leah M.; Nowels, Carolyn T. // Journal of Palliative Medicine;May2011, Vol. 14 Issue 5, p567 

    Background: Opiates are commonly used for symptoms at the end of life (EOL). Little is known about the decision-making process physicians go through when deciding to prescribe opiates for their EOL patients. The study's objective was to explore physician factors affecting EOL opiate prescribing....

  • The Value of Evidence-Based Continuing Education. DePalma, Judith A. // Journal of Continuing Education in Nursing;Mar/Apr2007, Vol. 38 Issue 2, p52 

    The article focuses on the evidence-based continuing education and its importance in the improvement of clinical practice. The evidence-based continuing education provides clinicians with various evidences that can be used by them for future reference. It can be delivered by organizing...

  • What differentiates primary care physicians who predominantly prescribe diuretics for treating mild to moderate hypertension from those who do not? A comparative qualitative study.  // BMC Family Practice;2012, Vol. 13 Issue 1, p9 

    The article offers information on a study conducted on what differentiates between primary care physicians, who prescribe diuretics for treating mild to moderate hypertension. It states that marketing strategies of pharmaceutical industry and practice experience contribute to the differences in...

  • Use of a supportive care pathway for end-of-life care in an intensive care unit: a qualitative study. Radcliffe, Christina; Hewison, Alistair // International Journal of Palliative Nursing;2015, Vol. 21 Issue 12, p608 

    Background: Providing palliative care support in intensive care settings is beneficial, however, barriers to delivering high-quality end-of-life care remain. To address this, pathways have been used to improve the quality of palliative care in generalist settings. This study describes the views...

  • What About the Dam Break Upstream? Börner, Joachim // Deutsches Aerzteblatt International;12/27/2010, Vol. 107 Issue 51/52, p918 

    A letter to the editor is presented in response to the article "The Changing Prevalence of Attention-Deficit/ Hyperactivity Disorder and Methylphenidate Prescriptions: A Study of Data From a Random Sample of Insurees of the AOK Health Insurance Company in the German State of Hesse, 2000-2007."


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics