Comparison of LiST measles mortality model and WHO/IVB measles model

Wei-Ju Chen
January 2011
BMC Public Health;2011 Supplement 3, Vol. 11 Issue Suppl 3, p1
Academic Journal
Background: The Lives Saved Tool (LiST) has been developed to estimate the impact of health interventions and can consider multiple interventions simultaneously. Given its increasing usage by donor organizations and national program planner, we compare the LiST measles model to the widely used World Health Organization's Department of Immunization, Vaccines and Biologicals (WHO/IVB) measles model which is used to produce estimates serving as a major indicator of monitoring country measles epidemics and the progress of measles control. Methods: We analyzed the WHO/IVB models and the LiST measles model and identified components and assumptions held in each model. We contrasted the important components, and compared results from the two models by applying historical measles containing vaccine (MCV) coverages and the default values of all parameters set in the models. We also conducted analyses following a hypothetical scenario to understand how both models performed when the proportion of population protected by MCV declined to zero percent in short time period. Results: The WHO/IVB measles model and the LiST measles model structures differ: the former is a mixed model which applies surveillance data adjusted for reporting completeness for countries with good disease surveillance system and applies a natural history model for countries with poorer disease control program and surveillance system, and the latter is a cohort model incorporating country-specific cause-of-death (CoD) profiles among children under-five. The trends of estimates of the two models are similar, but the estimates of the first year are different in most of the countries included in the analysis. The two models are comparable if we adjust the measles CoD in the LiST to produce the same baseline estimates. In addition, we used the models to estimate the potential impact of stopping using measles vaccine over a 7-year period. The WHO/IVB model produced similar estimates to the LiST model with adjusted CoD. But the LiST model produced low estimates for countries with very low or eliminated measles infection that may be inappropriate. Conclusions: The study presents methodological and quantitative comparisons between the WHO/IVB and the LiST measles models that highlights differences in model structures and may help users to better interpret and contrast estimates of the measles death from the two models. The major differences are resulted from the usage of case-fatality rate (CFR) in the WHO/IVB model and the CoD profile in the LiST. Both models have their own advantages and limitations. Users should be aware of the issue and apply as update country parameters as possible. Advanced models are expected to validate the policy-planning tools in the future.


Related Articles

  • Progress towards measles control in WHO's African Region, 2001--2008.  // Weekly Epidemiological Record;9/25/2009, Vol. 84 Issue 39, p397 

    The article reports on the strategies recommended by the World Health Organization (WHO) towards measles control in the African Region from 2001 to 2008. According to the article, the region attained their goal of reducing measles mortality by 90% in 2001 compared with 2000. Information on...

  • Case-Fatality Rate during a Measles Outbreak in Eastern Niger in 2003. Nandy, Robin; Handzel, Thomas; Zaneidou, Maman; Biey, José; Coddy, Rene Z.; Perry, Robert; Strebel, Peter; Cairns, Lisa // Clinical Infectious Diseases;2/1/2006, Vol. 42 Issue 3, p322 

    Background. The World Health Organization (WHO) estimates that the case-fatality rate (CFR) for measles in West Africa is 4%-6%. In Niger, 50,138 measles cases and 201 deaths (CFR, 0.4%) were reported in 2003. We conducted an investigation to determine the epidemiology and the true CFR of...

  • Briefly.  // CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal;2/3/2009, Vol. 180 Issue 3, p286 

    The article offers information on the decreasing rate of mortality due to measles infection. The Measles Initiative reports that the number of deaths due to measles dropped to one hundred ninety seven people in 2007, from seven hundred fifty thousand people in 2008. The decreased in mortality...

  • Progress in Global Measles Control and Mortality Reduction, 2000-2007. Dabbagh, A.; Gacic-Dobo, M.; Featherstone, D.; Strebel, P.; Okwo-Bele, J. M.; Hoekstra, E.; Salama, P.; Uzicanin, A. // JAMA: Journal of the American Medical Association;4/8/2009, Vol. 301 Issue 14, p1430 

    The article focuses on the results of global measles immunization and surveillance activities which were conducted between 2000 and 2007 by the World Health Organization (WHO) and Unicef. The surveillance was conducted in an effort to determine the progress which had been made in reaching a goal...

  • Progress towards sustainable measles mortality reduction - South- East Asia Region, 1999-2002.  // Weekly Epidemiological Record;6/25/2004, Vol. 79 Issue 26, p241 

    Although measles remains a leading cause of vaccine-preventable deaths among children, WHO estimates that global measles mortality decreased by 29% from 1999 to 2002, including a decline of 19% among South-East Asia Region (SEAR) Member countries. In June 2003, the SEAR Regional Technical...

  • Meeting measles elimination indicators: surveillance performance in a regional area of Australia. Kohlhagen, Julie K.; Massey, Peter D.; Durrheim, David N. // Western Pacific Surveillance & Response Journal;oct-dec2011, Vol. 2 Issue 4, p1 

    The World Health Organization (WHO) Western Pacific Region has established specific measles elimination surveillance indicators. There has been concern in Australia that these indicators may be too stringent and that measles elimination can occur without all surveillance prerequisites being met,...

  • Global reductions in measles mortality 2000--2008 and the risk of measles resurgence.  // Weekly Epidemiological Record;12/4/2009, Vol. 84 Issue 49, p509 

    The article reports on the reductions in measles mortality from 2000-2008 as well as the risk of measles resurgence based on the World Health Organization (WHO)-UNICEF accelerated strategy. It notes that there was a second opportunity for measles immunization offered in 46/47 priority countries....

  • Measles death rates drop dramatically around world.  // Nation's Health;Mar2007, Vol. 37 Issue 2, p12 

    The article reports on the decline in measles death rates according to the World Health Organization (WHO). Officials called the decline in deaths a major public health success that surpassed earlier global goals. WHO Director-general Margaret Chan said this is a historic victory for global...

  • Measles progress. Kondro, Wayne // CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal;2/19/2013, Vol. 185 Issue 3, pE155 

    The article informs the decrease in the global mortality rate related to measles between 2001 and 2011 as reported by World Health Organization (WHO).


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics